Cash for crash scam, how to stop it?
Cash for crash scam, how to stop it?
Author
Discussion

willmagrath

Original Poster:

1,398 posts

177 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
At the end of last year my girlfriend was involved in a cash for crash.

Long story short, came up to a mini roundabout and a car entered that roundabout from our left, turning right but instead came all the way around, causing my girlfriend to emergency stop but we just bumped nose to nose.

Not much damage to her car (parts replaced without claiming for £90) and a small dent to their 2004 Mercedes.

They were very nice about it but didn't give much information and had many phones in the car...
Turns out they were UNTAXED and UNINSURED.

The little b****ds despite being uninsured, untaxed, clearly drug dealers and potentially driving a stolen car (police confirmed it may be stolen) still managed to claim £3000, claiming whiplash, off the insurer through their solicitor because there is evidence of contact between the vehicles.

This now means my girlfriends premium has doubled for at least 3 years.

Do the insurers care? No. They say its cheaper for them just to settle. No care for the customer (us).

Do the police care? Yes, but they don't have time to deal with it.

Anyone managed to deal with this and win?

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
It is what it is, there was contact between the cars, they must have medical evidence of whiplash (albeit maybe dodgy).

Go through your insurer's complaints procedure and if no joy you can try the ombudsman.

I seriously doubt that the impact on your GFs premium will be anything like that, especially if she shops around. I know that's not the point, but don't get hung up on that aspect.

SkodaIan

1,031 posts

116 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
The fact that she's had a crash at all (and presumably lost a chunk of no claims discount) will be what's affecting premium the most, rather than the specifics of the claim.

It doesn't sound like a staged crash - nobody would be stupid enough to do that if they were uninsured, just some chancers trying to take advantage of the situation.

RazerSauber

2,947 posts

91 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
No real way to stop it. Fitting a dash cam can prove that they deliberately hit you if that's the case. Things such as brake checking or random slamming on, reversing into you, swerving all over etc can be disproven but it's harder when they come full circle on a roundabout. That could more easily be a legitimate collision.

eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
SkodaIan said:
The fact that she's had a crash at all (and presumably lost a chunk of no claims discount) will be what's affecting premium the most, rather than the specifics of the claim.

It doesn't sound like a staged crash - nobody would be stupid enough to do that if they were uninsured, just some chancers trying to take advantage of the situation.
Stupid enough to get £3,000, which the insurers pay(or used to) automatically as it was the cheapest option. I assume insurers are a bit smarter now there are so many dashcams.

Mo28

907 posts

131 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Having worked in a solicitors firm that dealt with personal injury, one of the first things we did as part of the claim was to check the MID if both parties were insured, only then would we proceed ahead. If the claimant was uninsured, we would cancel the claim. I personally don't understand how they've managed to make a claim for personal injury unless it was only the passengers that did, if there were any.

Smint

3,669 posts

66 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
The insurers could stop fraud if they wanted.

Instead of fighting each other get together and when an obvious crash for cash has been found and successfuly prosecuted, then go after the criminals in civil courts for all damages caused plus costs for seriously high profile legal teams, when a few criminals have been utterly bankrupted in high profile cases it'll get the message out.

Whilst they just keeping paying out as the cheaper option in these cases it will continue indefinately.
I'd transfer my business immediately to any insurer who started fighting back against fraud.

We could all do our bit re insurance claims too, just because some clot has damaged your back bumper and light at a junction or in a car park doesn't mean you should partake of the credit hire scam, ooh i'll have a nice shiny new BMW to drive around in while my 10 year old Avensis sits out the back of the repair centre whilst the accident management sharks milk it for as long as they manage, turning a £500 7 day claim and putting up with the courtesy Aygo into a £10,000+ 2 month drama, plus the inevitable whiplash cobblers.
If we all mitigated our losses and behaved with a bit of honour we'd all be better off.

vikingaero

13,591 posts

200 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
RazerSauber said:
No real way to stop it. Fitting a dash cam can prove that they deliberately hit you if that's the case. Things such as brake checking or random slamming on, reversing into you, swerving all over etc can be disproven but it's harder when they come full circle on a roundabout. That could more easily be a legitimate collision.
Sounds like they were effectively using the roundabout to do a U-turn and your GF should have given way - it happens to us all as we don't epect many cars to go all the way around.

If the car was uninsured, untaxed and possible dealers, then they have taken advantage of the accident to claim whiplash.

As I've said many times - dashcam - not for the dashcam warrior status, but even if dashcams don't record the actual collision, they prove your positioning on the road.

so called

9,160 posts

240 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
RazerSauber said:
No real way to stop it. Fitting a dash cam can prove that they deliberately hit you if that's the case. Things such as brake checking or random slamming on, reversing into you, swerving all over etc can be disproven but it's harder when they come full circle on a roundabout. That could more easily be a legitimate collision.
Sounds like they were effectively using the roundabout to do a U-turn and your GF should have given way - it happens to us all as we don't epect many cars to go all the way around.

If the car was uninsured, untaxed and possible dealers, then they have taken advantage of the accident to claim whiplash.

As I've said many times - dashcam - not for the dashcam warrior status, but even if dashcams don't record the actual collision, they prove your positioning on the road.
My daughter was pulled over by the Police a couple of years ago for using a round about for making an illegal U-torn. laugh

willmagrath

Original Poster:

1,398 posts

177 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Mo28 said:
Having worked in a solicitors firm that dealt with personal injury, one of the first things we did as part of the claim was to check the MID if both parties were insured, only then would we proceed ahead. If the claimant was uninsured, we would cancel the claim. I personally don't understand how they've managed to make a claim for personal injury unless it was only the passengers that did, if there were any.
My girlfriends insurer just said that they managed to claim as there is evidence of vehicle contact, backed up by a now defunct black box fitted to the car. Apparently they will pay out for whiplash if there is any proven contact at any speed, despite it being about 2mph. Disgusting if you ask me!

willmagrath

Original Poster:

1,398 posts

177 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
Sounds like they were effectively using the roundabout to do a U-turn and your GF should have given way - it happens to us all as we don't epect many cars to go all the way around.

If the car was uninsured, untaxed and possible dealers, then they have taken advantage of the accident to claim whiplash.

As I've said many times - dashcam - not for the dashcam warrior status, but even if dashcams don't record the actual collision, they prove your positioning on the road.
Very true. She was technically in the wrong yeah, but definitely chancers or cash for crash. Just makes me very angry that someone uninsured and untaxed can scam a driver out of thousands over the next 5 years.

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
willmagrath said:
My girlfriends insurer just said that they managed to claim as there is evidence of vehicle contact, backed up by a now defunct black box fitted to the car. Apparently they will pay out for whiplash if there is any proven contact at any speed, despite it being about 2mph. Disgusting if you ask me!
I had this with an accident where I went into the side of someone. I was fully in the wrong and not a question of blame...but you don't get whiplash from a side impact and the medical stuff in the claim by the doctor was all regarding a front/rear accident.

Obviously there was a chance she *did* have a soft tissue injury (and again I *was* at fault) but the whiplash claim itself was utter bks.

austinsmirk

5,597 posts

154 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Dash cam.

Countdown

49,579 posts

227 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
AIUI Crash4cash tends to be somebody doing an emergency stop in front of you, resulting in you driving into the back of them.

This seems a case where your GF has joined the roundabout without giving way to traffic already on it, so probably 100% your gf's fault. I doubt the scrotes were driving around on the off-chance that somebody would pull in front of them. I'm also not sure what benefit a dashcam would have provided in this case.

Out of curiosity how do the police confirm that it was probably stolen? Surely it was either stolen or it wasn't?

Glenn63

3,982 posts

115 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Actual Crash for cash are rare people band the term about when they’ve just had a crash but don’t want to accept they were at fault.
This just sounds like the 3rd party was doing a u-turn which your gf didn’t anticipate and it ended in a genuine crash. After which they jumped on the claim train for few free £££

dundarach

6,230 posts

259 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Obvious being a here, (and I do have a dashcam) however this wouldn't have helped in this situation.

Alas she pulled out (by the sounds of it) when the round-about wasn't clear.

They sound like throbbers, you have my sympathy (especially as I'm a tight git).

However, move on, learn from it and let it go!

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,202 posts

254 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
surely the answer in this case, is to tell them that you're not insured? (takes reasonable presence of mind I admit) Give them some story about you're on your way to an MOT, or you forgot to sort it out and were going to do it tomorrow.

If they are scammers, they'll probably wonder off, if real then it'll be sorted by the police, and limit their chances of a prosecution.

Ankh87

1,169 posts

133 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
So basically this is what happened.

Your girlfriend assumed that the car were leaving the roundabout at that exit. So she pulled out of the junction on the roundabout only to find that the 3rd party was not taking that exit. Therefore making it clearly her fault.

Moral of the story is don't assume that the 3rd party is going to exit even if it's got an indicator on. Your girlfriend should now have learned that people are idiots and that they will do the unexpected.


As to stop crash for cash scams, the only way is to get a dashcam. Video of the event is key to know exactly what has happened. Things such as braking for no reason. I know someone who this happened to. They had a dashcam, it were determined that the car in front had deliberately caused the incident and even though they argued that the car following were too close, the car in front were charged by the police for dangerous driving.


So go out and buy a dashcam and hopefully she won't be involved in any other incidents.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,284 posts

181 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Mo28 said:
Having worked in a solicitors firm that dealt with personal injury, one of the first things we did as part of the claim was to check the MID if both parties were insured, only then would we proceed ahead. If the claimant was uninsured, we would cancel the claim. I personally don't understand how they've managed to make a claim for personal injury unless it was only the passengers that did, if there were any.
That's total nonsense. If you crash into the back of someone, you were negligent, and are liable for their damage and injuries, regardless of them being uninsured, drunk, driving a stolen car and using it as a getaway car from an armed robbery.

There are punishments in law for driving uninsured. Being hit up the back by someone not paying attention isn't one of them.

KungFuPanda

4,655 posts

201 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Mo28 said:
Having worked in a solicitors firm that dealt with personal injury, one of the first things we did as part of the claim was to check the MID if both parties were insured, only then would we proceed ahead. If the claimant was uninsured, we would cancel the claim. I personally don't understand how they've managed to make a claim for personal injury unless it was only the passengers that did, if there were any.
Why would you cancel the claim if the Claimant was uninsured? An uninsured party can still make a legal claim for PI and uninsured losses.