Lipped brakes Used Approved Mazda
Lipped brakes Used Approved Mazda
Author
Discussion

Nigel Foster

Original Poster:

57 posts

57 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
The initial message was deleted from this topic on 13 June 2022 at 02:27

itcaptainslow

4,814 posts

167 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
We need the actual thickness measurements of the discs to compare against the manufacturer’s minimum ideally.

geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Discs are consumable so the likelihood of the supplying dealer offering anything at all is remote I would say. Brakes wear out, just get them sorted.

easy_

57 posts

58 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Disks aren't expensive, just change them.

Lincsls1

4,107 posts

171 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
I'd say that the bottom line is you've owned the car for 6 months, and there will be no contribution on a consumable item.
From their POV there is nothing to say you haven't driven it very hard over those 2k miles causing the lip.
As others have said, brakes are cheap enough on a car like that, just get them changed and move on.

Lincsls1

4,107 posts

171 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
I'm assuming the car is in for a service or something too?
If so, consider that its in their interest to perhaps 'sell' you new brakes too. Some garages push harder than others.
That said, you say they will need replacing soon, that could mean another year, with the low mileage you do.

BertBert

21,346 posts

242 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
[quote=Nigel Foster]
Brakes wear out yes - but the discs will have been worn out prior to my buying the car. The pre-inspection which I don't have a copy of may have flagged this up?
/quote]
But they are not worn out now. They will be worn out at some point in the future.
You have three approaches.
1 go back to the supplying dealer and ask for a contribution (you pay parts, they throw in labour). Unlikely, but worth asking. Get some actual measurements on the disks first
2 go to be inspection people. Almost certainly not worth the effort
3 pay yourself.

I'd try 1 (hope for the best) and mentally expect to do 3 (plan for the worst)

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Nigel Foster said:
If that's considered fair I'll take it on the chin.

Brakes wear out yes - but the discs will have been worn out prior to my buying the car. The pre-inspection which I don't have a copy of may have flagged this up?

@easy £380 for genuine parts (probably required to keep warranty live?) £100 less for non genuine. That doesn't seem super cheap. I can't fit them myself.
Have you actually looked at them yourself?

Fronts and rears going at the same time isn't all that common. What IS common is for people to be told they need all 4 because it's a nice moneymaker for service departments.

I had a service department advise me that my old TT needed all 4 discs and pads replacing once. This was 3 weeks and practically no miles after they'd been renewed elsewhere.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
I'd say it's entirely analogous to tyres wearing out really. I wouldn't expect a dealer to replace them in that situation, but I also probably wouldn't expect a main dealer to be selling an "approved used" vehicle with tyres which are going to hit the legal limit in the next 2000 miles.

If you're not capable of checking yourself, I'd at least ask for the measurements and check them against the manufacturer's specifications. Our Octavia is still on its original brake discs at over 130k miles. Even my Elise, which gets driven pretty hard, is still on its original discs at 63k.

Edited by kambites on Friday 4th March 12:18

Lincsls1

4,107 posts

171 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Have you actually looked at them yourself?

Fronts and rears going at the same time isn't all that common. What IS common is for people to be told they need all 4 because it's a nice moneymaker for service departments.

I had a service department advise me that my old TT needed all 4 discs and pads replacing once. This was 3 weeks and practically no miles after they'd been renewed elsewhere.
They've only commented on the front brakes.

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Lincsls1 said:
CraigyMc said:
Have you actually looked at them yourself?

Fronts and rears going at the same time isn't all that common. What IS common is for people to be told they need all 4 because it's a nice moneymaker for service departments.

I had a service department advise me that my old TT needed all 4 discs and pads replacing once. This was 3 weeks and practically no miles after they'd been renewed elsewhere.
They've only commented on the front brakes.
The quote for £380 threw me given that disks aren't all that expensive.
@Op precisely which model of Mazda is this?

HustleRussell

26,710 posts

191 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
More info needed.

Who sold you the car?

Who told you the brakes were 'lipped', if different from the above?

Discs can be lipped and well within wear limits.

Lincsls1

4,107 posts

171 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Nigel Foster said:
Car went in because of creaking / metallic sound from OSF at near full lock.

Had hoped it was pebble trapped in pads or calliper wants greasing but Mazda say it's discs. Visual, no measurement given.

Apparently 4k life left in them which could be a year, but I don't know if I can drive around with a disconcerting creaking sound.

Are the genuine parts worth paying extra for?
With stuff like brakes on a car like this, I'd say genuine parts and their inflated prices aren't necessary. If you choose to get them replaced, call a decent independent garage and get a price to compare.
Otherwise, don't know how else to advise, maybe get a 2nd opinion, can't see how lips discs will cause creaking noises during steering near full lock, that's usually more suspension related issues.

HustleRussell

26,710 posts

191 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Nigel Foster said:
Bought from Mazda franchise at distance.

Local Mazda franchise said they were lipped.

Even if they measure okay.. (service manager just said they were lipped, photo on his smartphone) .. I think I need the creaking sound eliminated.

Maybe take to an indie to get a second opinion?
In my opinion, the car is seven years old and continuing to take it to franchised dealers and paying the associated price premium yields no benefit to you.

When are brakes worn out? It is probable that the brakes would pass an MOT brake roller test and neither the pads nor discs are currently worn beyond their limits. The work you are doing to get rid of the noise could be considered 'elective'.

Did the local franchise indicate that renewing the brake discs and pads would eliminate the noise?

geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Lincsls1 said:
CraigyMc said:
Have you actually looked at them yourself?

Fronts and rears going at the same time isn't all that common. What IS common is for people to be told they need all 4 because it's a nice moneymaker for service departments.

I had a service department advise me that my old TT needed all 4 discs and pads replacing once. This was 3 weeks and practically no miles after they'd been renewed elsewhere.
They've only commented on the front brakes.
The quote for £380 threw me given that disks aren't all that expensive.
@Op precisely which model of Mazda is this?
For genuine parts its probably about right, 2 x discs and 1 x set of front brake pads plus labour.

Approved used wont measure the thickness of the brake discs as part of the inspection... They are consumable items in any case, what was fine 6 months and 2,000 miles ago, might not be the case now. Had a track rod failed it would be the same deal.

HustleRussell

26,710 posts

191 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Nigel Foster said:
HustleRussell said:
In my opinion, the car is seven years old and continuing to take it to franchised dealers and paying the associated price premium yields no benefit to you.
Agree, however I do still have 6 months Mazda warranty so trying not to void that. smile
Yep, good point.

Nigel Foster said:
HustleRussell said:
When are brakes worn out? It is probable that the brakes would pass an MOT brake roller test and neither the pads nor discs are currently worn beyond their limits. The work you are doing to get rid of the noise could be considered 'elective'.

Did the local franchise indicate that renewing the brake discs and pads would eliminate the noise?
I did phone back to ask what happens if noise doesn't go away. Quoting service manger seemed confident.. his technician was 'quite happy replacing brakes' would resolve that.. (but adding 'the proof is in the pudding').. explained there's no wear indicator for the car, so there's a shim on the pad that can make a bit of a noise catching the lip.. and he said tends to be heard on a specific lock, suggesting right hand (which is when it's occurring for me)

They had the car in the air and couldn't see anything else obvious bushings etc..

I did make a recording, not sure how that's turned out maybe I'll post it later

Thanks Lincs and geeks..
Not necessarily doubting that replacing the brakes would rectify the noise, but at least other possibilities have been investigated. You need to know the disc minimum permissible thickness and the current thickness measurement really. If the discs are well within thickness and the lips are causing the noise you could even grind the lips off the disc with a grinder or finger sander.

davidexige

601 posts

237 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Is anyone able to explain how a lipped disc could cause the noise described as I can't visualise how it could, would genuinely be interested as I do a lot of my own maintenance and always keen to learn.thumbup

CarCrazyDad

4,280 posts

66 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Bosch Brake Disc (Front)
Bosch Brake Disc (Front)
Product Code: 104681847
£187.98
unit price £93.99
Remove
Bosch Brake Pad (Front)
Bosch Brake Pad (Front)
Product Code: 101682237
£88.99
unit price £88.99




From Euro Car Parts

Discount code : SERVICE



2x front discs
1x pair front pads
£138

Buy it and move on.


SteveR1979

601 posts

172 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
Why does a lipped disk make a creaking noise at full lock??


wpa1975

14,871 posts

145 months

Friday 4th March 2022
quotequote all
SteveR1979 said:
Why does a lipped disk make a creaking noise at full lock??
In plain and simple terms it will not, creaking to me sound more like a steering rack issue, changing the discs will not solve that.