So... what's the deal with car insurance comparison quotes?
So... what's the deal with car insurance comparison quotes?
Author
Discussion

FakeCarGuy

Original Poster:

107 posts

99 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
So, I'm 22 and don't have the best driving record... but I've decided to sell my expensive-to-insure car, and have started to look for a more economical run-around to save some money and prevent the temptation of putting my footdown so much. Just a sensible commuter car that gets me from A to B without any headaches.

Anyway, I've been using all of the comparison sites, and have been asking for multiple quotes. I know this in itself causes insurance prices to go up - but before I was able to disable cookies and prevent that from happening, now I can only disable 'non-essential' cookies and have now realised that I may have screwed myself over by doing so.

So, at the start of the month I searched for some quotes on a little 1.4 Toyota Corolla, where I was offered insurance at a respectable £1600 for the year (which i'm totally fine paying for). Only problem is, now whenver I run the quote with the exact same details, the quote comes out to £2600+. I get that prices change all the time - but the difference between those 2 quotes is staggering, and I literally can't find anything close to the previous quote.

I still have a week until the original quote expires, but now I'm kind of forced to buy that specific vehicle if I want reasonably priced insurance. If I were to find a better example of the same make and model - I'd be forced to pay the higher quoted figure. So, what can I do?? It feels criminal that an insurer were able to assess my risk based on the information given and to give me a price based on that risk - only to increase that quote by £1000 the next day simply because they can.

I mean, they've obviously evaluated that they can afford to take on the risk of insuring me for a reasonable amount, so how can they now say that it will cost so much more simply because of my risk profile? I don't see how there is any good argument to say that the risk of insuring me has increased by such a factor since then and now that I will now have to pay an additional 70% on the original quoted price. How am I that much more of a risk to insure since then? I can understand price fluctuations based on certain factors - but I would argue that the magnitude of those price inflations should not be as drastic as they are for me right now.

Is there something that I'm missing? Anything I can do? If I ask the insurer directly, do you think they will let me choose a different vehicle (if its the same make and model at least)? Kind of lost right now. Catching lifts to work and I feel like a burden for my colleague. I feel like I'm being punished for trying to be sensible with my choice of car :/ I know driving is a privilege, but I'm trying to do what I can to honor that privilege the best that I can.