D1S HID bulb recommendations
D1S HID bulb recommendations
Author
Discussion

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Looking to replace factory xenon bulbs which are now 12 years old and getting rather dim, they are D1S. Had a look on Amazon and it's a minefield of cheap brands that are unheard of, with Philips/Osram being around £100.

Not too sure which to go for at all. Want something that will last many years and improve light output over factory bulbs.

What would you recommend?

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Philips/OSRAM tbh, I tried a cheap brand once as an experiment and they were predictably rubbish.

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Or Sylvania.

rigga

8,808 posts

232 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Had some 6000k bulbs from amazon for over three years now, nice bright white light, as any higher rating starts turning them blue .
£25 the pair when I got them, not really a known name as I recall either.

lemonslap

1,029 posts

186 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
I used the Osram Nightbreakers on my Merc 4 years ago and they are still going strong. Yes they were expensive, however they aren’t the easiest things to change and I didn’t fancy trying to save a few ££ to do it again.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
The E46 runs D2S and everyone raved about Lunex for for £24 I got a pair, 6000K rated.

They are fine, been in two years without issue. But they are also quite harsh and blue compaired to OEM feel and the halogen main beams.

shtu

4,614 posts

177 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
I used the Osram Night Breakers when replacing my old HID lamps - they were FAR brighter than the decade-old originals, and were still working fine a couple of years later.

carl_w

10,813 posts

289 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
I got Osram Nightbreaker D2S a few years back (Jan 2018 it would seem) but I think they need changing again. Someone on a previous thread recommended Lunex as being British made and quartz glass.


aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
carl_w said:
I got Osram Nightbreaker D2S a few years back (Jan 2018 it would seem) but I think they need changing again. Someone on a previous thread recommended Lunex as being British made and quartz glass.
That's the thing, I don't want to buy a set that'll need doing again in 2-3 years which is what is swaying me towards Osram or Philips. But seems like even sometimes they have a short life too.

I've been looking at Lunex actually, I think 4600K ones. They do look well reviewed and a bargain at £35.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
The 4600k ones might be a better call than the 6000k.


james6546

1,664 posts

82 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Not the Halfords advanced ones. They weren't cheap and have only lasted 6 months frown

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
dhutch said:
The 4600k ones might be a better call than the 6000k.
How do you find the 6000K in the rain?

I did once have some 6000K LEDs in a different car, and in the wet they were as much use as a candle.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
I don't notice them being particularly awful in the rain, but would generally prefer warmer across the board. Enough that I will follow this thread and maybe re-invest.

alanshuff

67 posts

67 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Would recommend the Osram Night Breaker D1S bulbs - great output, expecially on main beam. Having said that, I put them on my car nearly 2 years ago and one of them is doing a bit of blinking now - fine on first turn on, but seems to be when turning them back on after a shortish stop - i.e. to buy petrol - and can be a bit blinky/flickery for a minute or so.

I did think surely it can't be the bulb, so swapped left with right and the problem has moved sides with the bulb, suggesting it is the bulb.

Will probably assume i've just had a bad one and will replace again (if the problem gets bad enough) with the same bulb, however if it happens again (suggesting premature failure) then might have to go with a more longer life one.

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
alanshuff said:
Would recommend the Osram Night Breaker D1S bulbs - great output, expecially on main beam. Having said that, I put them on my car nearly 2 years ago and one of them is doing a bit of blinking now - fine on first turn on, but seems to be when turning them back on after a shortish stop - i.e. to buy petrol - and can be a bit blinky/flickery for a minute or so.

I did think surely it can't be the bulb, so swapped left with right and the problem has moved sides with the bulb, suggesting it is the bulb.

Will probably assume i've just had a bad one and will replace again (if the problem gets bad enough) with the same bulb, however if it happens again (suggesting premature failure) then might have to go with a more longer life one.
Are they not covered under warranty? Pretty poor for such an expensive bulb to fail in that amount of time

alanshuff

67 posts

67 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
aturnick54 said:
alanshuff said:
Would recommend the Osram Night Breaker D1S bulbs - great output, expecially on main beam. Having said that, I put them on my car nearly 2 years ago and one of them is doing a bit of blinking now - fine on first turn on, but seems to be when turning them back on after a shortish stop - i.e. to buy petrol - and can be a bit blinky/flickery for a minute or so.

I did think surely it can't be the bulb, so swapped left with right and the problem has moved sides with the bulb, suggesting it is the bulb.

Will probably assume i've just had a bad one and will replace again (if the problem gets bad enough) with the same bulb, however if it happens again (suggesting premature failure) then might have to go with a more longer life one.
Are they not covered under warranty? Pretty poor for such an expensive bulb to fail in that amount of time
I'm not sure they have any warranty as such, although maybe I should look into this. [Edit - looks like they have a 4 year warranty, might try my luck smile]. But, yeah, i wouldn't be happy if a couple of years is the norm given the cost of them, even though they are brilliant.

Edited by alanshuff on Tuesday 15th March 15:54