Insurance company called to cancel my policy their fault!
Discussion
Hi all,
Wanted to post this up to hopefully get some advice on the rather surprising situation I find myself in today.
I've just taken a phone call from my insurance broker (well known for being great until you need to claim) and they are seeking to cancel my policy due to the underwriter having terms which they didn't make me aware of when I agreed to the policy.
I stress this is not my fault - they did not inform me at the time when they sold the policy.
It's a high powered car and they are seeking either prior experience of insuring a car in group 46 or above, or else having owned it for 6 months.
I've owned the car for 3 months and whilst I've driven some pretty fast stuff it's generally been modified so never owned something in that bracket.
Therefore they said they would be seeking to cancel my policy.
So the SHTF as you can imagine.
I've told them that first of all, they've had two months to tell me about this and we are far beyond the cooling off period so they are effectively going to be breaching the contract.
Obviously I would be referring them to the financial ombudsman and insurance ombusman and seek damages.
Secondly, what difference does owning the car for 6 months make. if it's parked up and not being driven, that's obviously not giving me any experience. An arbitrary ownership period is nonsensical and surely irrelevant to experience vs what I've actually driven.
Thirdly I've reminded them that I've got 4 cars insured with them currently and I frequent many a car forum and have plenty of time to tell my story.
So just wondering if anyone has some experience or ideas I should lay on them so I can stay on cover.
I'm waiting to hear back from "someone higher up" who is looking at it.
I see a possible solution of them seeking cover via a different underwriter and of course they pay the difference as its' their fault, but they of course haven't offered me anything other than the bad news.
What I'm mostly concerned about is cancelling my policy and how that may affect me in the future with getting new quotes when they ask you "have you ever had a policy cancelled".
I assume/hope that when it's the insurance company mis-selling it, they have to take the blame and there is no marker against me. If it affects my premiums I will of course be suing them for consequential loss for the next x years and x policies and my time.
Anyway I hope your day is going better than mine, and if you have good experience or industry knowledge and sound advise, please please get in touch over PM or below.
Thanks
Bob
Wanted to post this up to hopefully get some advice on the rather surprising situation I find myself in today.
I've just taken a phone call from my insurance broker (well known for being great until you need to claim) and they are seeking to cancel my policy due to the underwriter having terms which they didn't make me aware of when I agreed to the policy.
I stress this is not my fault - they did not inform me at the time when they sold the policy.
It's a high powered car and they are seeking either prior experience of insuring a car in group 46 or above, or else having owned it for 6 months.
I've owned the car for 3 months and whilst I've driven some pretty fast stuff it's generally been modified so never owned something in that bracket.
Therefore they said they would be seeking to cancel my policy.
So the SHTF as you can imagine.
I've told them that first of all, they've had two months to tell me about this and we are far beyond the cooling off period so they are effectively going to be breaching the contract.
Obviously I would be referring them to the financial ombudsman and insurance ombusman and seek damages.
Secondly, what difference does owning the car for 6 months make. if it's parked up and not being driven, that's obviously not giving me any experience. An arbitrary ownership period is nonsensical and surely irrelevant to experience vs what I've actually driven.
Thirdly I've reminded them that I've got 4 cars insured with them currently and I frequent many a car forum and have plenty of time to tell my story.
So just wondering if anyone has some experience or ideas I should lay on them so I can stay on cover.
I'm waiting to hear back from "someone higher up" who is looking at it.
I see a possible solution of them seeking cover via a different underwriter and of course they pay the difference as its' their fault, but they of course haven't offered me anything other than the bad news.
What I'm mostly concerned about is cancelling my policy and how that may affect me in the future with getting new quotes when they ask you "have you ever had a policy cancelled".
I assume/hope that when it's the insurance company mis-selling it, they have to take the blame and there is no marker against me. If it affects my premiums I will of course be suing them for consequential loss for the next x years and x policies and my time.
Anyway I hope your day is going better than mine, and if you have good experience or industry knowledge and sound advise, please please get in touch over PM or below.
Thanks
Bob
I had a similar scenario with my Impreza a few years ago although at the time I was looking to renew an existing policy through my broker.
I wanted to add my partner to the policy so she could share the driving on holidays but the insurer refused stating she had no experience of driving such a car. After much arguing with the broker I put it to them that the only way she could get experience the insurer required would be if they provided insurance and the threat of pulling my other 4 policies was enough to get the broker on my side to argue the case on my behalf.
I wanted to add my partner to the policy so she could share the driving on holidays but the insurer refused stating she had no experience of driving such a car. After much arguing with the broker I put it to them that the only way she could get experience the insurer required would be if they provided insurance and the threat of pulling my other 4 policies was enough to get the broker on my side to argue the case on my behalf.
Brett748 said:
.
Insurance companies are a joke.
Insurance companies exist to make money, not serve you.Insurance companies are a joke.
Everything is based on risk factors and maths, not knowing individuals and thier driving habits or skills.
OP that does sound pretty crap though, and both company and broker should have made such terms clear.
smokey mow said:
I wanted to add my partner to the policy so she could share the driving on holidays but the insurer refused stating she had no experience of driving such a car.
As it happens my mrs is on this car just because of it's value and the rare chance that she might drive home from the pub.Her driving history is not great, with two faults and one non fault, and not being a fan of driving just a means to get places.
But they happily added her. Which makes even more mockery of the situation.
POIDH said:
OP that does sound pretty crap though, and both company and broker should have made such terms clear.
As far as Im concerned this is not a case of not being clear, it's a new term. It simply didn't exist when I took the policy out. It was never communicated to me. it's not on any of the documents nor was any proof related to it asked for.
They might as well have invented it this morning.
I will be pressing them for proof of it's existence before policy inception.
Gad-Westy said:
Have you considered just cancelling the policy yourself now before they do it for you? Yes, you shouldn’t have to but at least you’ll avoid having a cancelled policy on your record.
I cannot believe that the system of insurance would allow for a company to break the rules (law?) and then I cop the blame for their fault.And I would certainly hope/expect that if it does, a court would understand how that was unfair and rule according for damages.
I've read some stuff after my post about such a cancellation being flagged as "not at fault" but of course the information out there is mostly about the person being at fault.
The industry doesn't air it's dirty laundry, does any ?
And we all know how your premium goes up in a non-fault claim..
Zarco said:
Gad-Westy said:
Have you considered just cancelling the policy yourself now before they do it for you? Yes, you shouldn’t have to but at least you’ll avoid having a cancelled policy on your record.
Sounds like the most sensible course of action.Pro-rata refund, minus the brokers commission for selling the policy, underwriters policy setup fee, cancellation admin fee means your refund comes to... £5.72 sir.
Jakg said:
Zarco said:
Gad-Westy said:
Have you considered just cancelling the policy yourself now before they do it for you? Yes, you shouldn’t have to but at least you’ll avoid having a cancelled policy on your record.
Sounds like the most sensible course of action.Pro-rata refund, minus the brokers commission for selling the policy, underwriters policy setup fee, cancellation admin fee means your refund comes to... £5.72 sir.
What brought about the call from the insurance company? Just out of the blue? Seems very unusual but if an insurer wants to come off cover because they’re not happy with something, they almost certainly can (without seeing t’ and c’s or knowing the insurer involved).
As it’s via a broker I would be pushing them to resolve and find you alternative cover. No point going all-in threatening suing and court action at this time - give them a chance to resolve it first.
As it’s via a broker I would be pushing them to resolve and find you alternative cover. No point going all-in threatening suing and court action at this time - give them a chance to resolve it first.
youmustbejoking said:
What I'm mostly concerned about is cancelling my policy and how that may affect me in the future with getting new quotes when they ask you "have you ever had a policy cancelled".
I assume/hope that when it's the insurance company mis-selling it, they have to take the blame and there is no marker against me. If it affects my premiums I will of course be suing them for consequential loss for the next x years and x policies and my time.
No worries on this point Bob - when you explain the genuine reasons for the cancellation it will not affect you future premiums. No MarkerI assume/hope that when it's the insurance company mis-selling it, they have to take the blame and there is no marker against me. If it affects my premiums I will of course be suing them for consequential loss for the next x years and x policies and my time.
bencollins4 said:
No point going all-in threatening suing and court action at this time - give them a chance to resolve it first.
Yeah I hear you. Unfortunately if I hadn't taken that stance on the call they were basically phoning to say sorry it's cancelled and have a nice day.There were no alternative options being offered at all. Like we will try to help you find another quote etc.But now they say that is what they've gone away to do.
To answer the poster above regards "out of the blue" yes I'm quite a suspicious person at times and I wonder if this is the truth or there is another reason eg: they dont want this risk on their books, so I want proof of what is being claimed as a T&C.
Wouldn't be the first time I'd been lied to by an insurance company.
youmustbejoking said:
bencollins4 said:
No point going all-in threatening suing and court action at this time - give them a chance to resolve it first.
Yeah I hear you. Unfortunately if I hadn't taken that stance on the call they were basically phoning to say sorry it's cancelled and have a nice day.There were no alternative options being offered at all. Like we will try to help you find another quote etc.But now they say that is what they've gone away to do.
To answer the poster above regards "out of the blue" yes I'm quite a suspicious person at times and I wonder if this is the truth or there is another reason eg: they dont want this risk on their books, so I want proof of what is being claimed as a T&C.
Wouldn't be the first time I'd been lied to by an insurance company.
The broker/insurer relationship can't be great as in my experience minor issues like this can usually be resolved without affecting customers.
Have they given you written notice of cancellation yet? The road traffic act says 7 days notice must be provided prior to cancellation. So I'd start shopping around in preparation.
Also, there is no centralised database of cancelled policies, so no major issue there, although technically not disclosing when asked by other insurers could land you in hot water (especially if it would influence whether the insurer would accept the risk, highly unlikely in this instance). Again, make sure you get written notice of cancellation from the broker explaining the reason for the cancellation was wholly due to an error on their part, in case you ever need to refer to it in future.
youmustbejoking said:
I've just taken a phone call from my insurance broker (well known for being great until you need to claim) and they are seeking to cancel my policy due to the underwriter having terms which they didn't make me aware of when I agreed to the policy.
I stress this is not my fault - they did not inform me at the time when they sold the policy.
I think I would:I stress this is not my fault - they did not inform me at the time when they sold the policy.
1. cancel the policy,
2. find a new policy with another broker,
3. ask the first broker for details of their E&O (errors and omissions) insurance.
4. claim against their E&O policy for any additional costs you incur.
ralphrj said:
I think I would:
1. cancel the policy,
2. find a new policy with another broker,
3. ask the first broker for details of their E&O (errors and omissions) insurance.
4. claim against their E&O policy for any additional costs you incur.
As a third party you can't directly claim against someone else's professional indemnity cover. As the name suggests it indemnifies them, and the policy won't pay out until it's clear they're legally liable. Their policy is likely to have an excess of several thousand pounds too.1. cancel the policy,
2. find a new policy with another broker,
3. ask the first broker for details of their E&O (errors and omissions) insurance.
4. claim against their E&O policy for any additional costs you incur.
The ombudsman is the way forwards here for recouping any extra costs, assuming the broker aren't reasonable in the first place.
There seems to be some confusion as to the difference between a broker and the insurance carrier itself.
If you arranged a policy via a broker and whether they accepted you under an authority from the insurance company or not ie they referred it to them doesn’t change the position.
You are paying for the broker ( indirectly or otherwise ) and therefore it’s up to them to either broke your case to the insurance company or find alternatives.
They cannot wash their hands and leave you in the lurch.
It sounds like you have done nothing wrong so I would not cancel as then they can wash their hands.
If you arranged a policy via a broker and whether they accepted you under an authority from the insurance company or not ie they referred it to them doesn’t change the position.
You are paying for the broker ( indirectly or otherwise ) and therefore it’s up to them to either broke your case to the insurance company or find alternatives.
They cannot wash their hands and leave you in the lurch.
It sounds like you have done nothing wrong so I would not cancel as then they can wash their hands.
alscar said:
They cannot wash their hands and leave you in the lurch.
They shouldn't, but if they've gone outside of their authority in the first place it might be they don't have any alternative markets open to them.From what the OP has said so far though it sounds like they're far from going out of their way to be helpful.
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


