From maligned to mainstream?
From maligned to mainstream?
Author
Discussion

Luis Nazario

Original Poster:

41 posts

62 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
A funny thing happened. I was looking at my 2018 BMW and thought “Oh, the grille dates it a bit; I wish it had a newer one”.

It got me thinking about how changes in design direction are often ridiculed at first, but then become accepted, and then become the norm.

Two examples that came to mind were the jelly mold Sierra (which I think eventually spelt the end of the three box saloon design) and Bangle’s flame surfacing at BMW - which basically every car went on to copy and then take to the Nth degree.

Any other examples - either personal, where you thought something was rubbish then grew to like it, or industry wide (where something was at first mocked but then was much copied)?

Luis Nazario

Original Poster:

41 posts

62 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
I’m just going to have one feeble attempt at bumping this, because I thought it was interesting, but if the tumbleweed continues to blow I will get the message….!

FA57REN

1,279 posts

86 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Swept-back headlight clusters, from Focus Mark 1 to universal design feature.

Pebbles167

4,600 posts

183 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Luis Nazario said:
I’m just going to have one feeble attempt at bumping this, because I thought it was interesting, but if the tumbleweed continues to blow I will get the message….!
It happens, sometimes you just happen to post at a busy time, and it gets missed.

It's a decent topic, albeit one probably discussed before.

For me E60 5 series was something I hated at first but grew to like, likewise for FN2 Civic Type R, Current gen Ford Focus. There are several more, but generally the car designs I like or dislike usually stay that way, I mean I don't think I'll ever look at a Jaguar S Type and admire it, even though the R looks better, its still ugly to me.

B235r

408 posts

80 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Dame Edna Saab 9-5 with the crome round the headlights looks tame now & ahead of its time

Mortadella

5,041 posts

110 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Luis Nazario said:
A funny thing happened. I was looking at my 2018 BMW and thought “Oh, the grille dates it a bit; I wish it had a newer one”.
Said nobody ever .

Let's get the new BMW gopping grilles post out the way .

Mr Tidy

31,905 posts

158 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
I can relate to this.

The first Ford Sierras looked gopping, but by the 90s they were sort of OK.

I thought the 2006 Honda Civics looked great, but as time went by they just looked dated!

And later generations just got worse with each update.

Oh twaddy

287 posts

220 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
There are a few examples of this for me.

First one was the 2017 BMW 2 series. I was horrified when it was launched at how bulky and undefined it was around the rear arches. Looked awful compared to the E82 shaped 1 series coupe. Then the Mrs got one and I simply didn’t know what I was banging on about!!

Like others I detested the Bangle E60 5 series but now I look at one, in the right colour, with the 19” spider alloys and think it looks pretty good - interiors are still horrible though, as are pre facelift Bangle 7 series’

I also used to hate old Land Rovers and their drivers yet now I hold our old Defender dearly and would never sell it.

Age does this to you perhaps?!

All SUVs are still sh17 though ha ha ha!!!

Rob 131 Sport

4,981 posts

83 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Oh twaddy said:
There are a few examples of this for me.

First one was the 2017 BMW 2 series. I was horrified when it was launched at how bulky and undefined it was around the rear arches. Looked awful compared to the E82 shaped 1 series coupe. Then the Mrs got one and I simply didn’t know what I was banging on about!!

Like others I detested the Bangle E60 5 series but now I look at one, in the right colour, with the 19” spider alloys and think it looks pretty good - interiors are still horrible though, as are pre facelift Bangle 7 series’

I also used to hate old Land Rovers and their drivers yet now I hold our old Defender dearly and would never sell it.

Age does this to you perhaps?!

All SUVs are still sh17 though ha ha ha!!!
I always liked the design of the E60 from the off and owned an ex demo 520d (my first diesel) in metallic black followed by a new white 525i. I always liked detested the styling of the 02 to 09 7 Series. Whilst the facelift made it slightly better, to me it was just bloated.
The key point here is that I either ‘like’ or ‘dislike’ cars from the off, there is generally nothing that grows on me.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Luis Nazario said:
Two examples that came to mind were the jelly mold Sierra (which I think eventually spelt the end of the three box saloon design)
I know the Sierra moved design on and brought aerodynamics and plastic bumpers into play etc. But there are three box saloons all over the place, many manufacturers never stopped making them and still do now

andyA700

3,452 posts

68 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
The E60 5 series is an ugly lump of a thing. It may be mechanically brilliant, but I think a car has to look good as well. Personally, I think the E28 and E39 were the best looking 5 series.

cerb4.5lee

45,310 posts

211 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Luis Nazario said:
A funny thing happened. I was looking at my 2018 BMW and thought “Oh, the grille dates it a bit; I wish it had a newer one”.

It got me thinking about how changes in design direction are often ridiculed at first, but then become accepted, and then become the norm.
I echo this too. When I look at my 2018 F82 M4 I do love the way it looks, however I feel that it lacks the presence of the current generation G82 M4 in comparison. The G82 looks very aggressive, and love it or hate it I reckon that it does make a statement. The G82 makes the F82 look a bit old fashioned I think(I understand that is the idea because it is a newer generation car though).

The new 2 series coupe versus the previous generation 2 series coupe is another good example I think.

cerb4.5lee

45,310 posts

211 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
I can relate to this.

The first Ford Sierras looked gopping, but by the 90s they were sort of OK.
I didn't like the Sierras original headlights, yet I did really like the facelifted headlights(and the overall look) of the 2 XR4x4s I had though(one was a 89 F reg and the other a 90 G reg).