RE: The future of VW R is electric (ish) | PH Footnote
RE: The future of VW R is electric (ish) | PH Footnote
Sunday 26th March 2023

The future of VW R is electric (ish) | PH Footnote

Volkswagen's performance division is on the road to zero emissions, but the journey there isn't straightforward


We love a hot hatch in Britain. Just look at the turnout we had for our recent best hot hatch poll. Thousands took part in the vote, which saw the Toyota GR Yaris narrowly edge the Renaultsport Clio 182 Trophy for the top spot. The top ten featured the front-wheel drive heroes – the Ford Fiesta ST, Honda Civic Type R and so on – but one stood out to me as a bit of an outlier – the Mk7 Volkswagen Golf R.

Of course, the Mk7 Golf R was always going to make our 38-car strong shortlist. Laudable straight-line performance, all-weather capabilities and the availability of a manual ‘box are all high on the hot hatch priority list. But a top ten finish - beating the GTI Performance of the same generation – goes to show just how much we love affordable(ish) performance in the UK. Something Peter Jost, head of sales and marketing at VW R, was keen to point out when we spoke at a very soggy Brands Hatch.

“The UK is the biggest market for us outside of Germany in Europe”, he said, shortly after handing the keys VW’s 10,000th Tiguan R to its new UK-based customer. So we clearly can’t get enough of the stuff, suggesting that VW R’s formula over shoving 300-odd horsepower turbo four pots into everything it can find (save for the Touareg R hybrid) is working quite nicely. The only problem for R is that it’s going to need to reinvent the formula for the end of the decade.

If the EU gets its way, all new high-volume cars produced and sold in the bloc must be powered exclusively by electric power by 2035 (unless the German transport minister and newfound PH hero gets his way). And with VW seemingly all-in on EVs regardless, that means its R division is lumped into an electric switch, too.

Jost, however, claims that the general principles of the current R line-up will remain intact following the electric switchover. “It will be all-wheel drive, the most powerful car [and] the best looking. So the philosophy of what we have today will basically also be the philosophy of in the electric world, however, it will be added with convenience, which means fast charging [and] a lot of other stuff, like things beyond the car.”

That’s all well and good – and largely what we’d expect from an EV – but VW R still faces the same challenge as many of its rivals in making the switch to electric power: how do you make it a car for drivers? While R has arguably never been a bastion for engagement, it’s made significant strides in recent years. Perhaps that’s the influence of an influx of employees from the company’s now-defunct motorsport division. Jost claims that “a lot of people” were moved from the firm’s racing squad into R, most notably those who have experience working on the mighty ID.R. Okay, so the likelihood of a mad, two-seater electric hypercar with giant wings is unlikely (though I’d love to be proven wrong on that one), but they clearly know a thing or two about making electric cars that aren’t afraid of corners.

“For us, it was important that we have all the, um, the employees”, he said of the disbanded motorsport squad. “We have all these motorsport guys. The drivers help us to develop our cars. So if we, if we develop an R model, we go to the Nurburgring Nordschleife with these drivers. They drive our cars at a very early stage - or in every development stage, actually - and give us feedback on what we can do better in terms of driving dynamics.”

Speaking of development, Jost revealed that VW R actually had a hand in shaping VW’s MEB platform, which underpins a bunch of EVs from the ID.3 to the ID. Buzz. “We are involved in a very early stage”, he said, adding that it the firm is currently working on a “successor platform” as we speak. “We are not alone in a group, so we are talking with Audi Sport, we are talking to Cupra and say, ‘let's do it together’”. Not only should that mean VW’s stablemates don’t tread on each other’s toes (which happens from time to time), but it'll hopefully mean R has a better canvas on which to create its performance EV.

What an electric R model looks like is something that the performance arm is still working on. Jost disclosed that it’d feature bigger brakes and potentially more aggressive styling, while the rest remains a closely guarded secret. Probably because there’s still the best part of a decade to go until the company moves entirely from dino juice to electrons.

I asked him whether we could see some limited-edition, hardcore offerings akin to the GTI Clubsport S as possible run-out models to the current combustion line-up. His response: “No plan so far to be honest. [...] Of course, we are thinking about all that stuff all the time. But, at the end of the day, we are a company and we have a clear task to support the Volkswagen brand to be emotional in a positive sense and to bring also money to the company.”

That’s a no, then. What did come as a surprise, however, is that R isn’t shutting the door on the internal combustion engine as soon as you might think - “the ICE world is extremely successful right now, so we also have to take a look at how fast is it going, infrastructure, what does the customer really wants and don't [want]. I'm not talking only about Europe, but also in the US, south America, Asia and so on.”

“Why not sell [ICE] cars, let's say for the next five years? Because we know exactly what we are doing and earn good money with that and [they] bring emotion to the brand. And [the company could] then go directly to, let's say the electric performance models. Both options are valid. They have their pros and cons I would say, and we haven't decided on that. One thing is for sure we will have a strong R BEV model in the future, [but] the way to zero isn't 100% defined.”


Author
Discussion

350Matt

Original Poster:

3,911 posts

309 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
Sounds like VW are hedging their bets a bit

see what their transport minister comes up with I'd say

hopefully a realisation that 100% BEV is not the answer for everyone and forcing its adoption will put Europe on the back foot

DonkeyApple

70,339 posts

199 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
It's sensible business. The bulk of cars sold remain ICE and VW would go bust if they stopped selling them. The generic utility stuff is easy to steadily switch to EV in a market such as the U.K. over the next decade but the affordable fun stuff is much harder due to the current limitations of battery tech. Impressive 0-60 stuff is all well and good for the adverts but something like a hot Golf is about hooning wherever and whenever the mood or opportunity is there and not being tied to hypermiling on main roads or having to own a driveway.

Something like a hot petrol Golf would be an ideal fun and affordable car for anyone wanting to pick up an ICE before 2035 and to cherish and turn into a shed over the following 10-15 years.

nismo48

7,147 posts

237 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
It's sensible business. The bulk of cars sold remain ICE and VW would go bust if they stopped selling them. The generic utility stuff is easy to steadily switch to EV in a market such as the U.K. over the next decade but the affordable fun stuff is much harder due to the current limitations of battery tech. Impressive 0-60 stuff is all well and good for the adverts but something like a hot Golf is about hooning wherever and whenever the mood or opportunity is there and not being tied to hypermiling on main roads or having to own a driveway.

Something like a hot petrol Golf would be an ideal fun and affordable car for anyone wanting to pick up an ICE before 2035 and to cherish and turn into a shed over the following 10-15 years.
+1 well put wink

AshD

238 posts

279 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?

otolith

69,280 posts

234 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
Heavy, 4wd, two pedal, doesn’t make a noise worth hearing - surely the R brand is an easy one to electrify.

Gorilla Boy

7,820 posts

203 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
otolith said:
Heavy, 4wd, two pedal, doesn’t make a noise worth hearing - surely the R brand is an easy one to electrify.
My thoughts exactly, just need a way to make the DSG "fart" noise as it changes gears.

anonymous-user

84 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
AshD said:
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?
Of the 930 Golf Rs for sale on AutoTrader, just 151 are manual. Doesn’t suggest they were that popular to me.

bodhi

14,688 posts

259 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
ajap1979 said:
AshD said:
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?
Of the 930 Golf Rs for sale on AutoTrader, just 151 are manual. Doesn’t suggest they were that popular to me.
Maybe people are less keen to sell the manual ones?

anonymous-user

84 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
bodhi said:
ajap1979 said:
AshD said:
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?
Of the 930 Golf Rs for sale on AutoTrader, just 151 are manual. Doesn’t suggest they were that popular to me.
Maybe people are less keen to sell the manual ones?
Haha, alright then, just have a look at How Many Left. Seem that they were averaging 6k manuals a year compared to 8.5k DSG cars. That’s actually closer than I thought it would be, but I also suspect most of the manual “sales” were because that was the cheapest way into one.

whp1983

1,393 posts

169 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
AshD said:
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?
Everyone says they want a manual….. but then don’t buy one…. The yanks do (despite their reputation for not driving a stick!)

DonkeyApple

70,339 posts

199 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
The Americans aren't some special breed of human that doesn't talk a load of wk about what they want and then only ever buy what the finance monkey tells them they can have. They fundamentally invented the whole concept of talking arse while renting what they're allowed.

The simple reality is that there are 250 million more of them than Brits. wink

otolith

69,280 posts

234 months

Sunday 26th March 2023
quotequote all
The small proportion of Americans who can “drive stick” have a different attitude to it than the vast majority of brits to whom it’s the default.

big_rob_sydney

3,671 posts

224 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
Somewhere in this discussion, there is also a place for what the fuel companies intend on doing strategy wise. I can quite imagine that they had been thinking electric was the way to go, and then all of a sudden, these groups within Germany have piped up, potentially throwing investment decisions worth tens of billions into chaos.

Will they all of a sudden make drastic changes to their strategy at this point? With so much money on the line? Maybe they'll be thinking which of them (they or their competitors) are more advanced in synthetic fuels, and then decide either to push forwards with synthetic, or actually to fight hard against it, because they dont want a competitor to have an advantage.

Securing a viable supply chain is vital. I do wonder what the ICE manufacturers are doing in that space, because there wouldn't be much point making an ICE car, if there wasn't enough fuel to run it.

Pierre-kma6q

12 posts

128 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
otolith said:
Heavy, 4wd, two pedal, doesn’t make a noise worth hearing - surely the R brand is an easy one to electrify.
Exactly, if there is a brand that will loose nothing by going full EV, it is VW.

DonkeyApple

70,339 posts

199 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
big_rob_sydney said:
Somewhere in this discussion, there is also a place for what the fuel companies intend on doing strategy wise. I can quite imagine that they had been thinking electric was the way to go, and then all of a sudden, these groups within Germany have piped up, potentially throwing investment decisions worth tens of billions into chaos.

Will they all of a sudden make drastic changes to their strategy at this point? With so much money on the line? Maybe they'll be thinking which of them (they or their competitors) are more advanced in synthetic fuels, and then decide either to push forwards with synthetic, or actually to fight hard against it, because they dont want a competitor to have an advantage.

Securing a viable supply chain is vital. I do wonder what the ICE manufacturers are doing in that space, because there wouldn't be much point making an ICE car, if there wasn't enough fuel to run it.
I don't think they'll be doing anything just because a few minted folk within the EU might be allowed to buy a car that burns methanol. wink

Just what kind of volume of this synthetic stuff do you think is possible?

The U.K. burns 55bn litres of real fuel a year alone. EV sales haven't yet made any significant inroads into that volume and eFuels won't ever even be noticed

Shell and BP both own two of the largest charger companies in the U.K. and across the EU, have optioned up the big car park landlords and done deals with the energy firms on the utility side. But no one is rushing as it'll be decades before EVs have a significant impact and synthetic fuels are of zero volume relevance so the involvement from the oil companies is just PR and you can expect tonnes of that going forward. Lots and lots of adverts and promotions about how everything they do is great. biggrin

Just relax, join the smart people and enjoy burning real petrol for the next twenty years+ if that's what you enjoy.

DonkeyApple

70,339 posts

199 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
Pierre-kma6q said:
otolith said:
Heavy, 4wd, two pedal, doesn’t make a noise worth hearing - surely the R brand is an easy one to electrify.
Exactly, if there is a brand that will loose nothing by going full EV, it is VW.
Apart from going bust if they do that while 90% of their customers and target demographic are buying ICE. biggrin

What this article really boils down to is they will be making R badges EVs but also keep selling ICE with R badges for as long as they are legally allowed and for as long as customers will buy them.

All of this we already knew as it's rather obviously common sense but we will start to see more of this PR pivot from banging on and on and on about EVs while selling pretty much only ICE to making noises about how they still sell ICE because the consumer pivot due to cost of living is permanent.

EdIsNotDead

4,217 posts

245 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
ajap1979 said:
bodhi said:
ajap1979 said:
AshD said:
So if the UK is so significant in sales terms WTF don’t they put 3 pedals in the new R?

After all the US get a manual in it.

Does VW not wonder that one of the reasons the Mk 7/7.5 was so popular, because it came with a manual.

And now they’ve dropped the Up GTi.

What is it about VW dropping the properly fun cars?
Of the 930 Golf Rs for sale on AutoTrader, just 151 are manual. Doesn’t suggest they were that popular to me.
Maybe people are less keen to sell the manual ones?
Haha, alright then, just have a look at How Many Left. Seem that they were averaging 6k manuals a year compared to 8.5k DSG cars. That’s actually closer than I thought it would be, but I also suspect most of the manual “sales” were because that was the cheapest way into one.
I have a mk5 Ed30, manual.

Most 'young'uns' on the dedicated forums/FB pages look for DSG versions when asking what's for sale. It just seems to be the way these days.

I'll just hang onto mine as long as I can.

otolith

69,280 posts

234 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
Apart from going bust if they do that while 90% of their customers and target demographic are buying ICE. biggrin

What this article really boils down to is they will be making R badges EVs but also keep selling ICE with R badges for as long as they are legally allowed and for as long as customers will buy them.

All of this we already knew as it's rather obviously common sense but we will start to see more of this PR pivot from banging on and on and on about EVs while selling pretty much only ICE to making noises about how they still sell ICE because the consumer pivot due to cost of living is permanent.
Hmm, but surely the buyer of a 40k-50k new car like the Golf R, who despite that profligacy has a miserly eye on the cost of living, will be looking for something electric for the tax breaks and lower running costs?

DonkeyApple

70,339 posts

199 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
otolith said:
Hmm, but surely the buyer of a 40k-50k new car like the Golf R, who despite that profligacy has a miserly eye on the cost of living, will be looking for something electric for the tax breaks and lower running costs?
Only some of those people would be getting the real tax breaks and lower running costs.

The £40k bit is a red herring as the relevant price is the monthly. So using the monthly figure you're going to have a customer split between those with driveways and access to BIK v those with no BIK advantage and no driveway. The VW brand tends to more target the latter as the Audi badge is more for the former? There's going to be a reasonable split between the two either way.

Dave Hedgehog

16,362 posts

234 months

Monday 27th March 2023
quotequote all
60k 1800kg golf r incoming