RE: Maximum bruiser for the money | Six of the Best
RE: Maximum bruiser for the money | Six of the Best
Saturday 25th January 2025

Maximum bruiser for the money | Six of the Best

Big power, big pace, big presence - big value


Jaguar XFR, 2011, 67k, £13,995

The concept of a car as ‘bruiser’ is an interesting one as we all instinctively know what it means (essentially something mean-looking and powerful, like a modern prop forward or a comic book Yakuza) but because carmakers aren’t partial to any description that evokes violence, it isn’t one that gets used too often when a car is new. But secondhand - and post speccing - is a different matter; you know what the original buyer was after, usually building on something with a V8 and chest-prodding attitude. The XFR was actually more svelte than some, and could be Q-car-ish on smaller wheels. But in black on 20s with the hawk-stare headlights (and let’s not forget the sound it makes) there is no question about its level of intent. Especially if you light up the tyres on every roundabout. A steal at £14k. 

See the full ad

Vauxhall VXR8, 2009, 46k, £18,995

Of course, if any Jaguar is too subtle, you could always buy the Antipodean version. No mainstream car measures up to the VXR8’s absurdist tendencies, from the 6.0-litre V8 under the hood to the ram-raided Halfords styling. Even the slightly crude undertow is all part of the charm: it’s about maximum mindset wallop. Having said that, the understandable Australian obsession with continent-crushing ability means it can easily be driven in a more leisurely manner. But most interactions with the manual ‘box is a call to arms and you’ll need to be quite a chilled-out PHer not to obsessively keep the V8 on the boil. There are prettier, faster and much more complicated cars to come, but perhaps none quite so good at rattling your funny bone. Also a lot of car for a fiver under £19k. 

See the full ad

Kia Stinger GT S, 2022, 9k, £34,250

If your response to the VXR8 is ‘okay sure, great - but I’m a grown-up’ then probably you’ll quite like the flagship Stinger. Its status as a seldom-seen connoisseurs' choice hardly needs reiterating in these pages, although if you haven’t had the pleasure yet, it’s the palpable sense of old-school heft that really describes the car’s charm. Don’t be fooled by the size of the 3.3-litre V6’s output either: the GT has plenty of hustle to go with its chunky kerbside presence. Obviously you won’t be dousing the touch paper in quite so much petrol, but with plenty of pliancy and thoughtful control weights, satisfaction is virtually guaranteed. They can be had for much cheaper than £34k, too, but that amount gets you one with just 9k on the clock. Expect it to last longer than you do. 

See the full ad

Alpina B5, 2018, 45k, PH Auction

Obviously if raw speed is a concern - and you don’t mind paying for it - big-shouldered options proliferate in the PH classifieds. And in the current crop of auctions: fresh to a new round of gavel banging is this Alpina B5, a gem by any reckoning. You’ll likely recall that it’s the 4.4-litre N63 and not the M5’s S63 doing the pushing, but this is a good thing because it makes the car as smooth as Guinness strained through Fred Astaire’s socks. Also, it has 608hp and will crack 200mph. So if your ideal bruise is the one delivered to a McLaren owner’s ego, then look no further. Also, if you don’t like pearlescent white or the idea of a 5 Series saloon, there’s always the option of this wagon in the classifieds. Either ticks the mega-horsepower all-rounder box and then some. 

See the full listing

Mercedes-AMG C63 Final Edition, 2022, 2k, £82,995

If rear doors are less of a concern and you’re hoping to attract admiring glances (chiefly from other PHers), our go-to bruiser would probably still be the previous generation C63. Partly because the memory of it turning up (in black, all V8 snarl and knuckle-dragging wheels) at PH’s old underground car park lived long in the memory - and partly because this example is not only a Final Edition, but also gets the Brabus PowerXtra upgrade that ushers peak power beyond 600hp. Perhaps the C63 never lived up to some of its rivals in terms of handling finesse, but when it came to winning friends and influencing people, a Graphite Grey AMG with a Brabus blow-off valve is going to take you places few others can reach. Certainly not its half-mast replacement. 

See the full ad

Aston Martin DBX707, 2024, 6k, £199,950

Finally, if money is absolutely no concern and it simply must be an SUV, we’re going to suggest skipping the usual suspects (while tipping a hat at all the affordable, peril-chancing Range Rover Sport SVRs you could buy) and point you towards the DBX 707. With the possible exception of the new Defender OCTA - which is bonkers for different reasons - Aston’s flagship is both the best performance SUV to drive and the most assertive in the looks department. Sure, its maker might have overdone it with the stick-on sills and spoilers, but that’s all part of the powered-up fun. In a straight line, it pulls up trees; around corners, it beggars belief - what more do you want? Only the Vanquish is better at being a cutting-edge Aston, and you’ll need £150k more in the bank for one of those. 

See the full ad


Author
Discussion

chirurgus

Original Poster:

512 posts

245 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
The Jaguar is the pick of the bunch in terms of fulfilling the brief. That said, earlier, much less expensive versions of the C63 are readily available and are fantastic fun as well as extremely rapid on track.

The Alpina with its chintzy chrome tat, boot spoiler and plethora of shiny, large-font badges looks more like a leathery tart in leopard print than it does a bruiser. The estate version...sorry, wagon linked is far more appealing.

The Holden originals of the Vauxhall and their variants are commonplace in Sydney and typically they are driven recklessly by a mono-browed, mullet-coiffured stereotype in a singlet. That rather puts me off what I suspect may be an entertaining car.

Edited by chirurgus on Saturday 25th January 01:11

Chestrockwell

2,947 posts

186 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
That Alpina could have been prepped a bit better, would have cost £2 using the hoover at the local petrol garage to clear up the footwell

Having said that, I'd still pick the Alpina, definitive bruiser

Chestrockwell

2,947 posts

186 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
chirurgus said:
The Alpina with its chintzy chrome tat, boot spoiler and plethora of shiny, large-font badges looks more like a leathery tart in leopard print than it does a bruiser. The estate version...sorry, wagon linked is far more appealing.



Edited by chirurgus on Saturday 25th January 01:11
I disagree regarding the chrome. It's refreshing to see a car that doesn't have a blacked out grill etc. Not saying that's what you prefer however I think it would have looked like a drug dealers car if it was de chromed

wistec1

794 posts

70 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
The Alpina is the stand out pick for me even if the wheels have had some curb rash. The stinger and the VXR both winked at me and I would have to overdose on some brave pills to buy the Jag.

chirurgus

Original Poster:

512 posts

245 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
I disagree regarding the chrome. It's refreshing to see a car that doesn't have a blacked out grill etc. Not saying that's what you prefer however I think it would have looked like a drug dealers car if it was de chromed
I prefer chrome kidney grills to black on a grown up car like a 5 series, but I think the chrome fog light surrounds and fake wing vents make the whole effort look cheap. Wedding-car white compounds the problem. The estate version in dark blue with silver wheels and a dark brown interior would be close to perfect family transport for me.

Edited by chirurgus on Saturday 25th January 04:11

Billy_Whizzzz

2,620 posts

172 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Alpina wagon is gorgeous. But not at that price. And the white saloon in the ad - reminds me why buying private is a minefield. Keenes wheels, dirty carpets, road rash… not a good look

Prolex-UK

5,581 posts

237 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Had a 21 plate Stinger for 2 years and it's a great car.

Likes a drink but that's what you expect with over 350bhp

No issues to report.

Fitted white line ARBs and K&N air filters yellow stuff pads modification wise

7 year warranty is a plus.

6k miles or 6 months service intervals are a pain but bearable

Its Just Adz

18,850 posts

238 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Bloody hell that Alpina is prepped so badly.
I mean come on, spend a few quid getting the chips done and wheels refurbished, at least run a hoover through it.
It's not a £800 banger, I bet the reserve is top dollar.

Anyway, I think the Vauxhall and the C63 would be my choice from the list. Proper hooligan cars.
Jag actually looks good too.

Aston doesn't interest me one bit.

KingGary

1,082 posts

29 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Definitely the Jag. My brother has the face lifted one with slightly more power. It’s a beast.

I’ve got a supercharged Monaro which is about a wild as it gets and it gets lots of attention wherever it goes. I don’t really like the VXR8s though.

GreatScott2016

2,507 posts

117 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
On aesthetics alone, it would be the Jag for me by a country mile. Sadly, I wouldn’t look twice at any of the others, although I might just hear them approaching hehe

CDP

8,041 posts

283 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Billy_Whizzzz said:
Alpina wagon is gorgeous. But not at that price. And the white saloon in the ad - reminds me why buying private is a minefield. Keenes wheels, dirty carpets, road rash… not a good look
That estate looks grim. Matt grey with a charcoal interior.

Blue, green or burgundy with tan leather wood, silver wheels and restrained chrome please.

wolfie28

1,142 posts

173 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
C63 please. Zero interest in the rest.

TheRainMaker

7,882 posts

271 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
The XFR is an epic car, I loved mine.


cerb4.5lee

44,498 posts

209 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Its Just Adz said:
Anyway, I think the Vauxhall and the C63 would be my choice from the list. Proper hooligan cars.
Jag actually looks good too.

Aston doesn't interest me one bit.
I'm totally with you on all you say here. thumbup


cerb4.5lee

44,498 posts

209 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
wolfie28 said:
C63 please. Zero interest in the rest.
The C63 would be top for me as well. Although the VXR8 does really appeal to me though, and I've always respected the XFR for it's Q car/understatedness.

Deessee

68 posts

168 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
chirurgus said:
I prefer chrome kidney grills to black on a grown up car like a 5 series, but I think the chrome fog light surrounds and fake wing vents make the whole effort look cheap. Wedding-car white compounds the problem. The estate version in dark blue with silver wheels and a dark brown interior would be close to perfect family transport for me.

Edited by chirurgus on Saturday 25th January 04:11
The side vents are functional on the 5 Series

cerb4.5lee

44,498 posts

209 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
It might just be me, but I've never really understood the poring over that Alpina's get to be honest. I'm a BMW M car fan though, so I don't think that they're aimed at me really in fairness.

Box Fresh

18,084 posts

229 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Jag for me.

Alpina’s can look great, not that one though.

zsdom

1,828 posts

149 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
I’d have all bar the Merc & Aston

Water Fairy

6,587 posts

184 months

Saturday 25th January 2025
quotequote all
Only the top 2 seem value to me. The others, whilst desirable, are a lot of money.