Analogue or digital dashboard?
Analogue or digital dashboard?
Author
Discussion

lrdisco

Original Poster:

1,729 posts

116 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
I’ve got both at the moment but I think as we go towards an EV future analogue will be something that we look back at with sadness that it’s gone.
I can see some top end cars going back to it as imho it looks classy.

silentbrown

10,836 posts

145 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
By 'analog' do you mean physical needles in dials, or simply displays that look like them?

I certainly don't miss mechanical speedos where the needles would oscillate madly and typically overread by a good 10 percent.


Box Fresh

18,084 posts

229 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Well digital is the future for mainstream.
What I’m surprised about though is lack of replicating traditional dashboards using digital. I loved the BMW e39 era of orange and black. Perfection.

fflump

3,490 posts

67 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Revs, speed, temp, fuel.
Pretty much all I need.


andy43

13,174 posts

283 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
fflump said:
Revs, speed, temp, fuel.
Pretty much all I need.

Not ideally positioned to view them from the Bentley’s back seat though? wink

Baldchap

9,624 posts

121 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
I don't care as long as the information is there and reliable.

The removal of things like temperature gauges and the like is what troubles me. Sadly, most drivers seem to ignore everything but the speedo.

The Boy has a Fiesta ST and sometimes the digital rev counter and speedo don't load their needles. Never had that in any of my cars though, thankfully.

Riley Blue

23,205 posts

255 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
fflump said:
Revs, speed, temp, fuel.
Pretty much all I need.
Oil pressure is handy too.

Robertb

3,838 posts

267 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
I like the mixed arrangements like the 991 and 992.1. Not entirely sure about the digital dash on the 992.2.

Teslas with no display at all in front of the driver are borderline dangerous without HUD.

MitchT

17,117 posts

238 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Prefer the analogue dials on the F32 4 Series to the digital dashboard. They're so elegant and with such great clarity that they can't be improved on. That said, the digital ones look good and in the grand scheme of things it's not a dealbreaker.




J77wck

332 posts

36 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
I didn't like digital until I had one in my Jag, now I don't mind.

LuS1fer

43,503 posts

274 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Vauxhall's lovely 7 dial dash from the 1970s



My last Insignia had decent analogue dials, carrying on the tradition but integrating an electronic panel.

My current MX5



My 1985 Corvette C4. I loved this, at the time though the daft 85mph graphic speedo was supplemented by a digital numeric readout above that. Very space age at that time.


andy43

13,174 posts

283 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
My current MX5

That’s all the dashboard you’d ever need.

RichFN2

4,330 posts

208 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
My only experience with a digital dash is my current car which I have owned since July, but I must admit I do prefer it.

Probably the best feature is how the VAG virtual cockpit works with the infotainment display when using the sat nav. It just makes things that little bit easier.

Donbot

4,194 posts

156 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Digital for speed, analogue for revs.

mac96

6,447 posts

172 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Box Fresh said:
Well digital is the future for mainstream.
What I’m surprised about though is lack of replicating traditional dashboards using digital. I loved the BMW e39 era of orange and black. Perfection.
Current Mustangs have several options, including replicating 60s dash!
The whole point of a digital dash is to be able to customise displays. Without that I'd much rather have traditional.

kambites

71,459 posts

250 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Digital displays are just functionally better if they're done well, IMO... however, I guess it's the same as the difference between an analogue and a digital watch; there is no logical reason to prefer an analogue watch, but I'd imagine the majority of people (including myself) do?

Zilla

71 posts

132 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
Hi-Res Digital displays due to the abilty to switch between multiple displays depending on what you are doing.

Eg. Track focusing on revs, temps, braking feel etc. Touring focusing on speed, fuel consumption, weather etc.

Most digital displays allow you to modify what is being displayed so you can have the data that you find most important to you personally.

Roboticarm

1,673 posts

90 months

Saturday 8th February 2025
quotequote all
I like the setup in my focus ST, standard Speedo, rev counter, fuel and water temp front and centre. With a small screen giving the choice of additional display, I have digital Speedo most of the time but like that I can choose mpg, range etc instead.
The st also has gauges on top of dash centre for boost, oil pressure and oil temp

I find the latter 3 really useful, I never put my foot down until the oil is up to temp

I'm less worried about the display more the interaction and what's shown.
What I do like is a tactile interaction with the controls, temp and climate controls I can operate without looking because they are buttons or dials etc I don't want a massive, less good version of an iPad that I have look at to use

There is something brilliant about watching a mechanical rev counter move though

Edited by Roboticarm on Saturday 8th February 11:54