gearbox - does this sound terminal?
gearbox - does this sound terminal?
Author
Discussion

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
just left work, forgot phone, nipped back. on crusing into the car park i noticed a whine from the front end but thought i'd investigate during the drive home.

nothing doing, can't get it in gear. clutch feels fine and can get 1st/3rd if i rev slightly and force it. reverse is a no no and i've parked front end in.

currently waiting for an illuminous orange van to come and tell me it's fecked. am i going home on a flatbed?


trickywoo

14,145 posts

259 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Despite you saying the clutch feels fine I think that may be the problem. Doesn't sound like a gearbox failure.

Is it hydraulic? If so whats the fluid level like?

Could also be a linkage issue.

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
i thought clutch as when i pulled away the first time i had no power in 2nd gear, as though i was slipping the clutch.

no idea on levels, i checked the linkeage and it is tight and secure. i'm sitting in the warm and will let the RAC man fault find.

bit of a pisser as i only need a car for the next 4 weeks. at least there's a clio breakers up the road and plenty of garages nr work.

not looking forward to getting up at 5am for the train for the rest of the week frown

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
i havent the heart to launch a full rant, but the gearbox is no more. arse.

i might pop into my french mate's house on the way to the station to slag of all things french, leaving the car here whilst i get an idea of cost or if its even worth it.

eldar

25,268 posts

225 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
shirt said:
i thought clutch as when i pulled away the first time i had no power in 2nd gear, as though i was slipping the clutch.
(
Sounds like clutch slip... Could you smell burning clutch?

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
no. rac man reckons its definitely the box as you can't run through the gears with the engine off.

currently sat on the train home frown

Jw Vw

4,922 posts

192 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Ah not good mate. Gearbox is likely to cost a bomb. Bloody French flimsy rubbish!

HereBeMonsters

14,180 posts

211 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
shirt said:
no. rac man reckons its definitely the box as you can't run through the gears with the engine off.
This would also be the case if the clutch was engaged and stuck on, no?

What car is it?

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
mk2 clio, 1.6rsi (or, more fittingly, arse).

you can , with much effort, select 1st & 3rd. reverse just crunches.

we've a knowledgeable chap in the office whose dad owns a garage. there's a clio breaker up the industrial estate advertising a gearbox on fleabay for £180 and I could have a new clutch fitted for roughly the same outlay. I'll investigate
tomorrow and also see what the breaker will offer for the car. doubt a new box is a cost effective solution tbh.

its been a cheap commer unto now, I'm just pissed off as I finish work in 2wks, emigrate in 6, but need a car until the day I leave.

Fleckers

2,880 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
time to price up gearbox V hire car


shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
it'll more likely be a mix of train and begging parents to lend me one of their cars.

i fell asleep on the train and woke up wondering what the hell I was doing there. most confusing!

also now can't make a funeral later in the week frown

HereBeMonsters

14,180 posts

211 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
shirt said:
also now can't make a funeral later in the week frown
Where are you? If you're close you can borrow one of mine.

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
a kind offer thank-you, but I'm in the darkest reaches of civilisation - otherwise known as hull.

the deceased is the mother of a very close friend. I got home too late to call him, not sure what arrangements have been made tbh. I'll attend via the train or hire car if I can.

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Wednesday 16th March 2011
quotequote all
does anyone know if the box from a megane 1.6 16v will fit a clio with the same engine?

shirt

Original Poster:

25,394 posts

230 months

Wednesday 16th March 2011
quotequote all
been ringing around and the aforementioned colleague has been doing the same.

i can get a new box for £90-125 [depending which speedo sender type mine is, as these things go i reckon the odds are it won't be the cheap one!].

fitting will be £150 plus I need to get it to the garage - will probably beg my dad to drive down with his A frame.

so - £240-275 for a new box. sounds ok but....

it needs a new front screen - £90 insurance claim
a new front fog - £20 from ebay
either a ball joint or steering arm to cure a knock - ?

so i'm looking at £400ish to get the car fully sorted. there's nothing else wrong at all with it, bodywork and interior very near mint, 100k miles. has to be worth £8-900?

given those figures, and that i'd be pushed to get £150 from the scrappy/breaker as is, i'm erring towards paying the money and getting it done. what say the Ph sages?