Any windscreen preservation technique tips ?
Any windscreen preservation technique tips ?
Author
Discussion

Newc

Original Poster:

2,162 posts

205 months

Yesterday (16:19)
quotequote all
One of the Newcettes is having her third windscreen replacement in 12 months. These are all cracks from stones being thrown up from in front. She commutes on mostly 50-60 mph A-road / dual carriageways with some short B road stretches, but the damage has occurred at random places, not a specific road.

Are there any good defensive techniques she could adopt to reduce this ? She's not hooning along 2mm off the back bumper of the car in front, but the traffic is moving along smartly and leaving a 4-chevron gap will just mean someone pulls into it and closes the distance anyway.

Jaybee1981

62 posts

142 months

Yesterday (16:25)
quotequote all
I think the most most obvious reason youve already addressed.
Only other things i can think of is staying our of lanes that are obviously covered in crap or if the state of the roads she use are very poor.

I'd still be looking at point one tho. 3 times is crazy.

Red9zero

10,442 posts

80 months

Yesterday (16:25)
quotequote all
I have seen companies putting PPF on windscreens. Might be worth trying.

Every day a journey

2,711 posts

61 months

Yesterday (16:30)
quotequote all
If she WAS following at 2mm behind the car in front there would not be the space for stones to fly up so I would encourage her to adopt this approach.

Will also help if she's driving a BMW or Audi as that would be expected of them.

Snow and Rocks

3,082 posts

50 months

Yesterday (16:35)
quotequote all
One of my friends is always complaining about this and has had several new windscreens fitted over the past decade or so.

I do twice his annual mileage and have never needed a new windscreen.

The only difference is that he constantly drives much closer to the car in front. Not close enough that it would annoy anyone or be dangerous but it seems to be enough to make a difference.

I hang well back and if the odd car slots in, who cares, two or three car lengths is irrelevant over the course of a journey. Much more chilled out way to drive.

Haltamer

2,632 posts

103 months

Yesterday (16:53)
quotequote all
Red9zero said:
I have seen companies putting PPF on windscreens. Might be worth trying.
That was my first thought - I’m sure there is / I may have seen a similar offering to that which they use on Le Mans Cars / F1 Helmets, with multiple layers that can be peeled off when the outermost layer is buggered?

Newc

Original Poster:

2,162 posts

205 months

Yesterday (16:59)
quotequote all
Every day a journey said:
If she WAS following at 2mm behind the car in front there would not be the space for stones to fly up so I would encourage her to adopt this approach
clap

Jaybee1981 said:
Only other things i can think of is staying our of lanes that are obviously covered in crap or if the state of the roads she use are very poor.
Yeah good point, I might drive it with her and see if there are particular debris collection spots to be avoided.

Snow and Rocks said:
I do twice his annual mileage and have never needed a new windscreen.

The only difference is that he constantly drives much closer to the car in front.
Yes same for me, one screen in last 15 years. I don't think she's that close but maybe she could be consistently one or two metres further back. I'll put on my best back seat driver hat and go out with her.


Robertb

3,418 posts

261 months

Yesterday (17:00)
quotequote all
Luck of the draw I think. My daughter lost a screen to a conker last autumn which was annoying!

For what its worth, my Merc CLS with ACC seems less chippy than the last one I had without it, because it leaves a big old gap.

But yes, the windscreen PPF would seem like a good solution if it works. Its not cheap though, albeit probably a lot less than a new OE screen fitted by someone who knows what they're doing.

gotoPzero

19,957 posts

212 months

Yesterday (17:45)
quotequote all

I would suggest a dash camera.

HTH.

vikingaero

12,313 posts

192 months

gotoPzero said:
I would suggest a dash camera.

HTH.
Not sure how a dashcam will help. If my car flicks a stone up and it damages your windscreen, then how I am liable because I haven't been negligent. Unfortunately windscreen damage is one of the hidden costs of motoring like punctures and supermarket dings.

Does the OP's daughter drive a MINI or other cars with very upright windscreens that are prone to damage?

But the only way to minimise damage is to hang back as much as you can.

Glassman

24,530 posts

238 months

vikingaero said:
Does the OP's daughter drive a MINI or other cars with very upright windscreens that are prone to damage?
Is this from experience or is there evidence to support it? Asking respectfully because I've seen this mentioned before once or twice and as far as I know, Mini windscreens are not a fast moving stock item.

vikingaero

12,313 posts

192 months

Glassman said:
vikingaero said:
Does the OP's daughter drive a MINI or other cars with very upright windscreens that are prone to damage?
Is this from experience or is there evidence to support it? Asking respectfully because I've seen this mentioned before once or twice and as far as I know, Mini windscreens are not a fast moving stock item.
Definitely from experience. Had about 5 screens on 2 MINIs. And it seems a common problem on MINI forums.

Rowe

414 posts

145 months

She either needs to be closer or further away than her normal positioning.

Glassman

24,530 posts

238 months

I would say it's bad luck, not helped by the condition of our roads. Also, frequency/mileage; the more you drive the greater the chance.


Gary29

4,885 posts

122 months

I'm my 26 year driving career, I've needed three replacement windscreens. Two within a week of each other on the same car, just bad luck I guess, or the grim reaper fancied his chances with me.

And one when a tree fell on my car.

Luck of the draw more than anything else I think.

the-norseman

15,095 posts

194 months

Dont drive the car?

georgeyboy12345

4,246 posts

58 months

What car is it?

georgeyboy12345

4,246 posts

58 months

the-norseman said:
Dont drive the car?
This is the best advice. This will definitely decrease the possibility of stone chips and cracks.

SuperPav

1,275 posts

148 months

georgeyboy12345 said:
This is the best advice. This will definitely decrease the possibility of stone chips and cracks.
Not sure, judging by the poster two posts up, there is every likelihood a tree will come crashing down and smash the windscreen if the car is parked. Best not to have a car at all. That’ll show those pesky windscreens!

gotoPzero

19,957 posts

212 months

vikingaero said:
gotoPzero said:
I would suggest a dash camera.

HTH.
Not sure how a dashcam will help. If my car flicks a stone up and it damages your windscreen, then how I am liable because I haven't been negligent. Unfortunately windscreen damage is one of the hidden costs of motoring like punctures and supermarket dings.

Does the OP's daughter drive a MINI or other cars with very upright windscreens that are prone to damage?

But the only way to minimise damage is to hang back as much as you can.
Of course it will.

Firstly, allows Mr OP to look at how his kid is driving - not just going off what he is told.
Secondly if a vehicle is dropping stones, for example, thats their problem. I see it all the the time a wagon with a load of MOT on the back dropping constant streams of limestone off the back.