Apollo Documentary Thread
Discussion
I realise cross posting can be an issue but sometimes it is very difficult to decide where to post a thread for widest coverage. That is why I put the James Burke documentary topic in two areas - Planes and TV.
I expect response will be low now because of teh narrower coverage the Planes forum gets.
What are we supposed to do in these circumstances?
I am surprsied at how keen the TV thread was closed when we often have multiple threads on other topics - such as the riots or other TV programmes. There are two Big Brother threads in the TV area alone.
If the mods are going to be zealous in stopping multiple thtreads, at least be consistent.
I expect response will be low now because of teh narrower coverage the Planes forum gets.
What are we supposed to do in these circumstances?
I am surprsied at how keen the TV thread was closed when we often have multiple threads on other topics - such as the riots or other TV programmes. There are two Big Brother threads in the TV area alone.
If the mods are going to be zealous in stopping multiple thtreads, at least be consistent.
As you say Eric consistency, we always try to be consistent that's why your cross post was closed, I'm not aware that we make any acceptations.
The Rule of Posting No. 15 clearly states, you will not
"Cross-post across the forums."
If you see any cross posts then please use the report button, and we close or delete.
The Rule of Posting No. 15 clearly states, you will not
"Cross-post across the forums."
If you see any cross posts then please use the report button, and we close or delete.
Eric,
If you want me to be consistent, then I'll delete the thread, as we normally do.
I gave you and your subject matter some personal respect and simply locked one and pointed to the other; rather than a simple delete.
But consistency is clearly more important. So please advise which one to delete and I'll be happy to do so.
If you want me to be consistent, then I'll delete the thread, as we normally do.
I gave you and your subject matter some personal respect and simply locked one and pointed to the other; rather than a simple delete.
But consistency is clearly more important. So please advise which one to delete and I'll be happy to do so.
Big Al. said:
As you say Eric consistency, we always try to be consistent that's why your cross post was closed, I'm not aware that we make any acceptations.
The Rule of Posting No. 15 clearly states, you will not
"Cross-post across the forums."
If you see any cross posts then please use the report button, and we close or delete.
I'm not that concerned about it - but we sometimes do seem to to have multiple threads on similar subjects - as I mentioned, the Riots and Big Brother being current examples.The Rule of Posting No. 15 clearly states, you will not
"Cross-post across the forums."
If you see any cross posts then please use the report button, and we close or delete.
Eric Mc said:
I'm not that concerned about it - but we sometimes do seem to to have multiple threads on similar subjects - as I mentioned, the Riots and Big Brother being current examples.
There may well be threads on similar topics, we do not allow the same topic posted by the same member posted in different forums. i.e Cross Posts.Hope that clarifies.
As Kinky says you can have the post in either forum, last count it looks like the TV forum is more popular with 148,751 posts where as Planes has 84,516 saying that quantity doesn't always equate to quality.
You try and be nice and help people ......
Eric Mc said:
Maybe you could close down the Planes one and re-open the TV one?
If I restarted a new thread on the same topic - but not a direct copy - does that still qualify as a cross post?
Deleted thread as requested, and yes, it would be a cross-post so will be deleted on sight to be consistent.If I restarted a new thread on the same topic - but not a direct copy - does that still qualify as a cross post?
PaulHogan said:
So when two (or more) different people start similar threads what causes some to be locked (and/or deleted) and some allowed to continue? [which was why I indicated that some consistency would be a good idea, above]
PH techies are currently in the process of setting a mods tool that will allow us to merge such thread.At present we tend to leave the one open that is in the most appropriate forum and with the most replies.
Forums | Website Feedback | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff