Petrol v Diesel
Petrol v Diesel
Author
Discussion

The_Burg

Original Poster:

4,853 posts

243 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
Just purchased a 1.6 Focus Zetec, need an estate for the dogs and the car is absolutely spot on. For 2006 car the condition is literally as new.

This is replacing an elderly slightly scabby Passat estate 1.9 115 version.

Now on paper the difference in mpg isn't great. Not that i expect the same from petrol as diesel.

Average on the commute for the Passat is high 50's mpg, generally near 60.
(Slow warm up then steady dual carriageway).

Now the Focus, which is hugely slower i've managed 34.8mpg.

Ok the insurance is near half the price as is the tax but, truly amazed how bad the Focus is.
It's the 100hp version. Is this to be expected or do i need to change my driving style?

Seen some alleged huge improvement with a chip, no more power but increases in driveability and economy.

Worth a bash or is this typical of a modern 'economical' petrol car?

Crafty_

14,067 posts

229 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
1) You posted in the wrong place

2) I'd say at 100hp the car is underpowered.

3) You're not missing the power of the passat, but the torque.

The_Burg

Original Poster:

4,853 posts

243 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
Crafty_ said:
1) You posted in the wrong place

2) I'd say at 100hp the car is underpowered.

3) You're not missing the power of the passat, but the torque.
Oops meant to be General Gassing.

Yes the torque is missing. I've forgotten about changing down for any reason except stall revs.

Still shocked by the peas poor mpg though. I though given the gentle commute it would manage mid 40s.
Last long owned petrol i owned was a Volvo S40 2.0T and got high 30's. Last toy petrol was a T5 which got high 20s so not a huge difference for 240hp to 100!

Chicarito

1,017 posts

180 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
Most MkII Focuses are overweight, underpowered and far too thirsty for what they are. They don't even have the famed Mk 1 Focus ride and handling to redeem them.

There's a reason why they're very, very cheap...

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
I love petrol vs diesel threads.

To summarise:

I like diesel
I like petrol.
Diesel is st
Petrol is st
You're stupid
No, you're stupid
This may continue for a few pages

Thread gets closed as tempers get fraught

The end.


P.s: Petrol is loads better smile

The_Burg

Original Poster:

4,853 posts

243 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
At present in the petrol is st side.

On paper sod all difference but one is much better to drive and cheaper to run.

Clue it isn't the petrol.