What the championship table would look like...
Discussion
Muzzer said:
Thanks!Bloody hell i didn't think it would have been such a difference.
Is there any going back from this?
Edit to say - i don't mean the stewrads descisions being reversed. It seems that the sport has turned a corner where every move is analysed and acted upon by the stewards. Now its been done once, surely it has to be done everytime.
Edited by danrc on Friday 17th October 10:05
danrc said:
Edit to say - i don't mean the stewrads descisions being reversed. It seems that the sport has turned a corner where every move is analysed and acted upon by the stewards. Now its been done once, surely it has to be done everytime.
Sadly not every move. I think one of the main criticisms of the stewards' decisions is that they are not universally and consistently applied.The other criticism of course is that most of them should not have been applied at all.
Muzzer said:
Personally I don't see any problem with the Valencia/France penalties (or lack of in Valencia's case) Belgium is very hard to come to a clear conclusion, however, the penalty was too harsh IMO, I remain undecided with the Bourdais incident until I see the in-car view, or one from the inside of the corner, as a result the point difference isn't that big.All IMO of course
IMHO the only reason Bourdais got penalised was because Massa isn't good enough to overtake someone, jeez, there was at least 5 times when the leaders came up to the pits to overtake someone and Massa was the only one that f'd up, ridiculous!!
I like Bourdais and I think unfortunately he'll be without a drive next year which is a real shame as next year will suit him perfectly and SV has got so much press this year.
I like Bourdais and I think unfortunately he'll be without a drive next year which is a real shame as next year will suit him perfectly and SV has got so much press this year.
mchammer89 said:
Muzzer said:
Personally I don't see any problem with the Valencia/France penalties (or lack of in Valencia's case) Belgium is very hard to come to a clear conclusion, however, the penalty was too harsh IMO, I remain undecided with the Bourdais incident until I see the in-car view, or one from the inside of the corner, as a result the point difference isn't that big.All IMO of course
there you go.
ZeeTacoe said:
No penalty. Hamilton made a silly mistake but did nothing wrong. Racing incident.Penalty Massa. Massa makes a mistake, Hamilton takes advantage, Massa causes an avoidable accident (not deliberately in my eyes).
No penalty. Bourdais stays exactly where CW told the drivers to stay, Massa makes the pass but turns in too early. Racing incident.
All IMO of course but I'd be interested to hear certain other peoples views of these incidents based on that video.
ZeeTacoe said:
mchammer89 said:
Muzzer said:
Personally I don't see any problem with the Valencia/France penalties (or lack of in Valencia's case) Belgium is very hard to come to a clear conclusion, however, the penalty was too harsh IMO, I remain undecided with the Bourdais incident until I see the in-car view, or one from the inside of the corner, as a result the point difference isn't that big.All IMO of course
there you go.
kevin ritson said:
Dogsey said:
No penalty. Bourdais stays exactly where CW told the drivers to stay, Massa makes the pass but turns in too early. Racing incident.
Yes but as we have already seen, Charlie Whiting is a liarForums | General Motorsport | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff