Range Rover 2dr Classic or not to Classic...
Range Rover 2dr Classic or not to Classic...
Author
Discussion

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Hey all,

Have finally managed to find some time to start my Range Rover classic restoration project.

The very first car i owned was when i was 9. It was a cheap 2 door Range Rover in Bahama Gold. I developed it into an offroader and finally chopped it up after rolling it end over end off roading when i was about 15.

I loved that car so when an identical car that had been sitting in a field for years came up for sale during covid i bought it as a "maybe one day" project

My question to the PH braintrust is what should i do with the engine. The 3.5V8 in it is scrap as it was literally full of water. So the good news is i can start from scratch if i want to.

Obviously these early Range Rovers attract a premium now so im concious of that. However the reality is that i would probably never sell it. The restoration plan is not to make it concours but to restore it to a nice useable standard. As such i dont want to drain the piggy bank too much, so i want to use one of the spare engines that i currently have in the workshop. It will probably get used very little and will be more of a garage queen once finished. It has to be a petrol V8 and manual like my original one.

The choices

A completly original 3.5 Rover V8 (Great for originality but woefully underpowered)
A 4.6 Rover V8 (I would need to convert this to carbs as i dont like the rover EFI)
A full race spec 4.7 TVR AJP V8 (seems like a waste and probbaly wouldnt suit the car??)
A 4.2 Supercharged V8 From a modern Range Rover (Great engine but will cost me a fair amount to do a manual gearbox conversion)

I think i want to go the supercharged route but will this ruin the classic apeal?

I will post some pictures up when im next in the workshop.

Appreciate any input.

Edited by itsallyellow on Sunday 8th November 13:33

jamesson

3,722 posts

252 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
I have no advice to offer but I do want to wish you all the best with your project. I love old Range Rovers and look forward to seeing your progress on this. smile

LightweightLouisDanvers

3,036 posts

74 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
"I think i want to go the supercharged route but will this ruin the classic apeal?"

I think so. Put a proper Rover V8 in it.

A.J.M

8,401 posts

217 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
If you plan to never sell it then surely the best option is what your heart desires it to be.

Is it a 70s Suffix A-F model? Or a later one.

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
A.J.M said:
If you plan to never sell it then surely the best option is what your heart desires it to be.

Is it a 70s Suffix A-F model? Or a later one.
1981 Suffix F. However the matching number engine block is beyond repair so the 3.5 i have would be a replacement.

A lot of people have urged me to keep it Rover.

mattdavies

360 posts

188 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
I have been looking at A range Rover classic, I would use the 4.6 but put a modern injector system using a modern ECU. This in my opinion would give you good reliability and power.

edit - I actually read the opening post

Edited by mattdavies on Monday 9th November 10:39

A.J.M

8,401 posts

217 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
From that list and wanting to keep it manual.

The 4.6 but with some mods would be my shout.

The 3.5 won’t make you happy.
The TVR engine probably isn’t going to be suited for the weight of the car, you may need to thrash it to get the best from the engine.
4.2 is a decent engine, but to get a manual conversion will be expensive and you have also said you don’t want to spend silly money on the car.

I’d get the 4.6 worked on for better cam, manifolds etc and get some more power from it.

Maybe later you could save up for a 4.2 and manual but this way you can drive the car and enjoy it.

RustyNissanPrairie

874 posts

26 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
If it s going to be a garage queen and have little use I d go with a 3.5.
Is the original block deffo beyond repair?

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
RustyNissanPrairie said:
If it s going to be a garage queen and have little use I d go with a 3.5.
Is the original block deffo beyond repair?
I guess not really. Just seems crazy to spend money on machining an old 3.5 block when i have more than 10 of them sitting in the workshop!

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
A.J.M said:
....I d get the 4.6 worked on for better cam, manifolds etc and get some more power from it.
This thumbup

A manual gearbox with possibly one of the Holley injection kits that looks like a carb. Decent cam and attention to the exhaust.

The less mechanical changes that you need to make will keep the project moving - too much change could bring it to a grinding halt.

Bowks

1,507 posts

236 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Why not go with the Rover V8 and something like an Emerald ECU? I run this in my TVR and it has transformed the car.

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Bowks said:
Why not go with the Rover V8 and something like an Emerald ECU? I run this in my TVR and it has transformed the car.
The RV8 makes sense to me as carbed simple truck engine. I think if im going to go to the effort of building a harness and using a stand alone ecu i would rather go down the supercharged AJ route.

Im not a fan of the RV8 but the fact its the engine the car should have and originaly ran on carbs is making some sence to me.

The silly thing is that the easiest of all the options is the AJP, Its literally sitting there on the floor with a complete wiring harness and ECU connected to a 4x4 tko600 literally ready to go. All i would need to do is make the engine ang gearbox mounts work. The AJP works fine in a 4x4 application as i have one in my Bowler. However the sound and high reving nature just seems wrong in Range Rover classic. (unless i built it as a dakar rally replica and fitted a roll cage etc) but that wasnt the idea of this project...... Although now ive mentioned it???




Not somthing i need as i already have the bowler..... But that does look cool and would be a much easier restoration job!

CQ8

792 posts

258 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Sounds like a great project, bookmarked!

I've got a 1991 RR CSK project in my barn, it used to be my daily driver. It has the 3.9l injected Rover V8 and a manual box. It suits the car and I've never felt like I've needed more power. So my vote is to stick with a the Rover V8 of some description, it does suit the car. If you go for a 4.6l, I don't know how much you'll have to change in terms of brakes, suspension, gearbox etc to cope with the extra power and torque. Maybe all the stock 1981 stuff would be fine, just something to consider.

I've also had a Cerbera with the 4.2/4.5 V8, I didn't really like the engine to be honest and I don't think it's a good option for your RR Classic. Just my opinion though. It's your car, fit the engine you'll enjoy the most.

I wouldn't bother with the Supercharged 4.2. Fantastic engine but way too much power and like you say, figuring out the manual option will be time consuming and costly.

jon-yprpe

468 posts

119 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Prob best to post in the Range Rover Classic thread in Classics…

I have a 3dr with a 4.6….although now 4.8 at about 275bhp at fly. Some quick pointers…

You need a Gems 4.6 not Thor.
You need to change the front timing cover to an ‘intermediate’ one. I can give you the part no.
Need to change the manifolds and modify exhaust system…but easy enough to get one made, speak to Rich fabrications.
Run an aftermarket ECU etc - mine is Ms2
I run standard axle, but everything else is upgraded.

But standard 4.6 is about 220bhp….not massively up on the 3.9/4.2 so I can’t see you’re going to be breaking because of a massive power increase.


Jader1973

5,240 posts

231 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
The answer is obviously an LS of some sort.

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Definitely wouldnt fit an LS, Hatefull heavy things! When we were racing against the LS equipped Moslers the lightness of the AJP and free revving nature negated the 200bhp deficiet very nicely. Also more reliable in race trim. The LS7's seemed to lunch themselves all the time!

Im up in the workshope with the car tommorow starting the strip down process. I will get some pictures. I think i might be coming around to the idea of just putting the 3.5 i have in there for now. Would be easy to then upgrade to a high spec rover unit later on. I do have a 5.0 John eales supercharged Rover engine sitting in my P38 JE560. That hasnt moved for over 12 years now so maybe that could be an option. Or maybe that needs restoring at some point due to its rarity......

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
jon-yprpe said:
Prob best to post in the Range Rover Classic thread in Classics

I have a 3dr with a 4.6 .although now 4.8 at about 275bhp at fly. Some quick pointers

You need a Gems 4.6 not Thor.
You need to change the front timing cover to an intermediate one. I can give you the part no.
Need to change the manifolds and modify exhaust system but easy enough to get one made, speak to Rich fabrications.
Run an aftermarket ECU etc - mine is Ms2
I run standard axle, but everything else is upgraded.

But standard 4.6 is about 220bhp .not massively up on the 3.9/4.2 so I can t see you re going to be breaking because of a massive power increase.
Thanks for this, very informative. Would i need an engine managemnt system? Could i not just run a 4.6 or 5.0 as a completly dump engine like the original? Coil, dizzy and carbs?

Agree that all the other componets will be fine up to about 350bhp, will porbably swap the 10 spline axles for 24's anyway. Brakes will be fine. Not sure the original 4 speed box will be any good but swapping to an R380 is easy enough.

I have a spair one of these as well. A Tremec TKO 600 with a custom LT230 transfer box. This one with an adapter to fit the AJP bellhousing. Simple job to mount it to the Superchanged AJ or a Rover if i want. In fact its a bellhousing adapter away from fitting it to anything.





RustyNissanPrairie

874 posts

26 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
^ all seems a bit sacrilegious for a 2door hence the 3.5suggestion…….but you do seem to have a lot of nice bits and bobs lying about!

itsallyellow

Original Poster:

3,903 posts

251 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
RustyNissanPrairie said:
^ all seems a bit sacrilegious for a 2door hence the 3.5suggestion .but you do seem to have a lot of nice bits and bobs lying about!
Yes and this is my main concern. Fitting the 3.5 is obviously the cheapest and easiest route

Mr Tidy

31,921 posts

158 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Since you describe the 3.5 as being woefully underpowered in your first post I think you'd be disappointed if you fitted one of those!

The TVR option doesn't sound like it would suit a Range Rover, the 4.2 S/C sounds like a lot of work to fit with a manual box, so maybe the 4.6 Rover engine is the best compromise for some sort of originality and a decent increase in power?