T5 5th gear upgrade
T5 5th gear upgrade
Author
Discussion

Chimp871

Original Poster:

837 posts

134 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
With the engine out and box split off is it recommended to do the 5th gear mod? I've no problems with 5th gear but whilst it's out it'll be easy if it's a highly recommended mod.

FarmyardPants

4,256 posts

235 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
Get the Quaife big gear upgrade, semi straight-cut so racy sounding but sorts the problem for good. Gearboxman.com. APM did mine, sent off my old box and they recycle your old housings, looks new from underneath. Job jobbed.

Chimp871

Original Poster:

837 posts

134 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all

phazed

22,292 posts

221 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
I believe that’s what I had on mine, commonly called the fifth gear upgrade which stops fifth gate falling off its shaft.

Mine dropped out into the bottom on my box luckily not causing any damage at all!

The one of my friends T5 dropped off the shaft and minced the whole box up which was written off!

Definitely a worthwhile upgrade. From memory mine was done by John Reid/Read.

ukkid35

6,361 posts

190 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
Fitting Paul Cangialosi's 5th gear stabilizer is well worth doing

However, it's not that straightforward as you need to check preload by spinning the countershaft, and that can't really be done with the mainshaft in situ

Unfortunately removing the mainshaft is tricky because you need to get 5th gear off the shaft, and it is a press fit

The first time I fitted the stabilizer I didn't remove the mainshaft but still managed to get the preload about right

Subsequently I have done full rebuilds with a new 5th gear, and then I was able to follow the recommended procedure

Here you can see both boxes have the stabilizer fitted



And here you can see the 5th gear before being pressed in to place



Anytime you take the gearbox out you should check and adjust input shaft preload - without fail

Otherwise you risk this happening



Both the Countershaft and Input shaft are destroyed



The Countershaft is not a problem, they are cheap and easy to find in the US, I paid just $100 for an Indian made part



You will be very lucky indeed to find a new or used input shaft, they are TVR specific (the Cossie one is different) and just don't exist any more

gruffalo

7,951 posts

243 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
FarmyardPants said:
Get the Quaife big gear upgrade, semi straight-cut so racy sounding but sorts the problem for good. Gearboxman.com. APM did mine, sent off my old box and they recycle your old housings, looks new from underneath. Job jobbed.
I will second this except I had mine done by Grantura engineering.

The shift is better than the standard gear set as well.

Jhonno

6,191 posts

158 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
FarmyardPants said:
Get the Quaife big gear upgrade, semi straight-cut so racy sounding but sorts the problem for good. Gearboxman.com. APM did mine, sent off my old box and they recycle your old housings, looks new from underneath. Job jobbed.
I will second this except I had mine done by Grantura engineering.

The shift is better than the standard gear set as well.
Quaife CR box in mine.. Bloody love it.

Chimp871

Original Poster:

837 posts

134 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
ukkid35 said:
Fitting Paul Cangialosi's 5th gear stabilizer is well worth doing

However, it's not that straightforward as you need to check preload by spinning the countershaft, and that can't really be done with the mainshaft in situ

Unfortunately removing the mainshaft is tricky because you need to get 5th gear off the shaft, and it is a press fit

The first time I fitted the stabilizer I didn't remove the mainshaft but still managed to get the preload about right

Subsequently I have done full rebuilds with a new 5th gear, and then I was able to follow the recommended procedure

You will be very lucky indeed to find a new or used input shaft, they are TVR specific (the Cossie one is different) and just don't exist any more
Was watching his video , from 8 mins onwards shows float and drag.
.
https://youtu.be/SbD7MP_52gc

The 5th gear seems to slide off on this model , it is mandatory to remove main shaft to check 5th gear float?

If the main shaft has to come out then I'll probably use a pro.



Edited by Chimp871 on Sunday 30th June 20:21

ukkid35

6,361 posts

190 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2019
quotequote all
Chimp871 said:
If the main shaft has to come out then I'll probably use a pro.
The first time I fitted the stabilizer I didn't remove the mainshaft but still managed to get the preload about right

The reason the gearbox failed about a year later was because the circlip holding the 5th gear on the mainshaft opened up, and the 5th gear slid up the mainshaft



Once I'd taken the damaged 5th gear off and removed the mainshaft, I was then able to check the countershaft preload properly and it was fine

ukkid35

6,361 posts

190 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2019
quotequote all
FarmyardPants said:
Get the Quaife big gear upgrade, semi straight-cut so racy sounding but sorts the problem for good. Gearboxman.com. APM did mine, sent off my old box and they recycle your old housings, looks new from underneath. Job jobbed.
That's good value at £1,500 for the gearset, but it probably costs double that once the gearbox build and fit is added

I think it requires a modification to the gearbox case as well (edit: I think it's the tail housing that needs modification)

I expect that will be the only option if you can't find an input shaft to replace a damaged one



Edited by ukkid35 on Thursday 4th July 08:18

phazed

22,292 posts

221 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2019
quotequote all
The Gearbox Man has a selection of good used gear sets as availability is practically zero.

Be aware that it is difficult to tell if a set is perfect. I had a set fitted which whined and had to be replaced, a pita!

tangerinedream

147 posts

117 months

Thursday 25th July 2019
quotequote all
I assume this is the gearboxman updated quaife gearbox? £2,400 (inc VAT) for an exchange. Pricey, but a permanent fix, yes?

https://www.gearboxman.co.uk/gearboxman-heavy-duty...

FarmyardPants

4,256 posts

235 months

Thursday 25th July 2019
quotequote all
APM did mine and IIRC it was a lot less than that including labour, try asking Andy for a quote.