Creeping lacquer failure on BMW alloys
Creeping lacquer failure on BMW alloys
Author
Discussion

Pupp

Original Poster:

12,969 posts

302 months

Tuesday 29th September
quotequote all
X3 not yet 3 yrs old (30k miles), only ever hand washed by me using decent products, both rear wheels with the dreaded spider leg corrosion rapidly spreading out from the centre caps. At last service I asked whether could be put forward as a warranty issue and was told ‘no one available today to assess, you’ll need to book it in specifically…’ Yesterday, tried to do just that to be told this time ‘no point as it’s wear and tear so won’t be adjudged a manufacturring defect and won’t be covered…’ (without seeing the car or images etc). Escalated to BMW UK who also seemed uninclined to want to intervene but grudgingly opened a complaint.

Anyone been down this road?

CSK423

837 posts

237 months

Tuesday 29th September
quotequote all
Its a bit of a lottery. If it's from the centre out it's generally due to the centre cap rubbing and opening up the lacquer.

However if you have kerb damage elsewhere on the wheel, they tend not to be too interested in helping even if it's not associated with what you described.

A friendly local dealer that you use regularly for servicing can usually push your case hard otherwise it's all very transactional and computer says no stuff.

danb79

13,770 posts

102 months

Tuesday 29th September
quotequote all
Pupp said:
X3 not yet 3 yrs old (30k miles), only ever hand washed by me using decent products, both rear wheels with the dreaded spider leg corrosion rapidly spreading out from the centre caps. At last service I asked whether could be put forward as a warranty issue and was told no one available today to assess, you ll need to book it in specifically Yesterday, tried to do just that to be told this time no point as it s wear and tear so won t be adjudged a manufacturring defect and won t be covered (without seeing the car or images etc). Escalated to BMW UK who also seemed uninclined to want to intervene but grudgingly opened a complaint.

Anyone been down this road?
When my Dad had his previous X3M he went through 3 sets of wheels in 3 years under warranty because of the milking and lacquer failure…

His current X3 he has fully powder coated wheels. Zero issues

Diamond cut finish needs to die it’s death IMO

ian332isport

228 posts

261 months

Tuesday 29th September
quotequote all
Pupp said:
X3 not yet 3 yrs old (30k miles), only ever hand washed by me using decent products, both rear wheels with the dreaded spider leg corrosion rapidly spreading out from the centre caps. At last service I asked whether could be put forward as a warranty issue and was told no one available today to assess, you ll need to book it in specifically Yesterday, tried to do just that to be told this time no point as it s wear and tear so won t be adjudged a manufacturring defect and won t be covered (without seeing the car or images etc). Escalated to BMW UK who also seemed uninclined to want to intervene but grudgingly opened a complaint.

Anyone been down this road?
Have these wheels previously had tyres changed?

It's usually where the tyre fitter clatters the wheel onto the balancing machine and damages the lacquer.

VeeTenM

893 posts

144 months

Tuesday 29th September
quotequote all
get them powder coated, phuck all that diamond cut ste

Pupp

Original Poster:

12,969 posts

302 months

Wednesday 30th September
quotequote all
ian332isport said:
Pupp said:
X3 not yet 3 yrs old (30k miles), only ever hand washed by me using decent products, both rear wheels with the dreaded spider leg corrosion rapidly spreading out from the centre caps. At last service I asked whether could be put forward as a warranty issue and was told no one available today to assess, you ll need to book it in specifically Yesterday, tried to do just that to be told this time no point as it s wear and tear so won t be adjudged a manufacturring defect and won t be covered (without seeing the car or images etc). Escalated to BMW UK who also seemed uninclined to want to intervene but grudgingly opened a complaint.

Anyone been down this road?
Have these wheels previously had tyres changed?

It's usually where the tyre fitter clatters the wheel onto the balancing machine and damages the lacquer.
Yes, the rears have been changed and I suppose it’s possible that’s the cause. The tyre guys were careful as far as I could see and it’s not unreasonable to have to change tyres.

Anyways, thanks for the responses; we’ll see what BMW make of it.

sam.rog

1,586 posts

108 months

Wednesday 30th September
quotequote all
Diamond cut finish will do this.
Only fix is to use a finish that’s appropriate for a wheel.
Get them powder coated.