G31 540i from 530d
G31 540i from 530d
Author
Discussion

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
I have a now oldish G31 530d x drive on 82000 miles. I do like it - it is fast (having been re mapped) and a great long distance and winter spacious hack. More than anything I’ve got itchy feet and am wondering about a change more for the sake of mitt ham anything else and at the back of my mind is that I should have bought a 540i instead as it might have been a little less boring. I hate the new 5 series. So my question is (again!) is that will a change to a late model g31 540i be a huge improvement in driving pleasure? I’ve had a b58 before in an M140i before I had an M2C and an X3M. I have a 981 Spyder for summer and a late model (2015) ‘classic’ defender 110 for hauling stuff (bikes, kids, too, trailers) around. So - will I love the 540i x drive touring in a way that I just ‘appreciate’ the 530d?

SlowV6

733 posts

170 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Watching B57 vs B58 story with interest..

Wilmslowboy

4,773 posts

237 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Watching this thread with interest, I just bought a used G31 530d, have to say in terms of performance a big step up from 520d I had before (and a good match for the 530e, I also had before).

As you suggested they are a bit dull, but that's kind of the point....hours driven in comfort with no drama.


v8notbrave

942 posts

44 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Do u need to love it? You have a fun car, so appreciate it for what it is. 540i quite rare so will be relatively pricey, 82k your is too high for a premium value but not really run in yet. So cost to change will be a lot for what I presume is marginal gains???

I love my pauper g31 520d on 160k now, it does what it says on the tin. Great cruiser, great at family duties and surprisingly chuckable on a b road. I agree the newer one is a bit too big and techy so I think the g31 is one of the last great cars. Mines departing next year and I'll miss it.....

530e are surprisingly good value for a late model one

scz4

2,857 posts

272 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
I have one of the very last F11 530d's (Feb 2017) which is now on 85k miles and considering changing in the next year, it's such a great workhorse though.

I guess the question is do you still need a 5 series sized car, it's never going to be that entertaining regardless of the engine (and I've owned a 540i V8 and 550i V8).

B58 is of course a great engine, but it won't offer much difference in performance with the drop in torque.

Can you downsize to a M340i/d? Would imagine that's a more enjoyable driving package.

Maxus

1,257 posts

212 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Billy_Whizzzz said:
So - will I love the 540i x drive touring in a way that I just appreciate the 530d?
Whilst getting the new car would be exciting, I think you'd miss the 530d competence in a short space of time.

Not quite the same but we have a 640d GC and an M240i and i've recently tested an X5 30d v a 50e. Whilst the B58 petrol is a superb engine, for application in bigger cars I personally prefer the B57 diesel. Low down torque, easier to waft around in, performance not too far apart and the economy benefit. This was particularly prevelant in the X5 where the B58 felt it needed a bit more effort to get going.

You've got other cars to love. A 530d is perfect as a brilliant everyday tool. Get a newer one of those.




resolve10

1,265 posts

76 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
I had a similar dilemma to you with a 435d I owned, but the key difference was that was my only car. As a second car with a fun weekend car I think it would be just about perfect.

I can't see the benefit of a 540i engine when the 30d engines are so competent and frugal for what they are. If anything I think you'd start to resent the extra running costs of a 540i and regret the change.

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Thanks all. I think I’d get £15k for my 530d and it could cost say another £20k (35k) for a late low mileage 540i. So marginal gains for quite a lot more. Will probably keep the 530 for another decade but every few years have a wobble and think I should go for something shinier! The reason I got it in the first place was that running the X3M alongside the 981 spyder felt too extravagant. And yes, I do like the 530d a lot. It’s like an old friend!

scz4

2,857 posts

272 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
As I mentioned above, I have 2017 F11 530d and have the same from wobble time to time.

Problem is to move to a 2019 or2020 540i I'd need to put £15k to 20k in, just doesn't make financial sense. Rather buy another MX-5.

I've done 55k miles in 6 years and it's been absolutely fantastic. In that time, other than consumables it's only needed two rear air bags, TPMS sensors replaced and just last week a wheel bearing.

Don't need to worry about chucking the bikes in the back, runs to the tip etc. It's got a tow bar, I have set of winter wheels, those would be another £2k.




Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
scz4 said:
As I mentioned above, I have 2017 F11 530d and have the same from wobble time to time.

Problem is to move to a 2019 or2020 540i I'd need to put £15k to 20k in, just doesn't make financial sense. Rather buy another MX-5.

I've done 55k miles in 6 years and it's been absolutely fantastic. In that time, other than consumables it's only needed two rear air bags, TPMS sensors replaced and just last week a wheel bearing.

Don't need to worry about chucking the bikes in the back, runs to the tip etc. It's got a tow bar, I have set of winter wheels, those would be another £2k.



F11 is peak 5 series for me - better looking than G31

steve_n

444 posts

233 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
I've briefly driven a 540i G31 and the B58 carries the weight well. As a long term keeper I prefer RWD over xDrive. It's simpler, less to go wrong, less hassle with tyres and you really don't need it. A set of CrossClimates and you're far more capable in inclement conditions than xDrive on summer tyres.

I really wanted a 540i but at the time I was buying they were a bit much. Ended up with a super rare manual 535i. I've been through the whole thing replacing virtually everything. It owes me way too much money, so I'll just keep it. And it's my favourite looking one too.


Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
steve_n said:
I've briefly driven a 540i G31 and the B58 carries the weight well. As a long term keeper I prefer RWD over xDrive. It's simpler, less to go wrong, less hassle with tyres and you really don't need it. A set of CrossClimates and you're far more capable in inclement conditions than xDrive on summer tyres.

I really wanted a 540i but at the time I was buying they were a bit much. Ended up with a super rare manual 535i. I've been through the whole thing replacing virtually everything. It owes me way too much money, so I'll just keep it. And it's my favourite looking one too.

Wow lovely with the manual. Let me know if you want to sell!

48Valves

2,814 posts

240 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
I did 100k in my G31 540

It’s a fantastic car, it was great at covering long distances at good speeds in comfort.

In no way was it exciting. It was relatively fast but didn’t necessarily feel it. And it wasn’t the most dynamic or best handling car.

hungry_hog

2,921 posts

219 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
I have a g31 540i.

It s a quick and comfortable car but you really feel the weight and size. If you are looking for a fun car it isn t really it. It s more of a cruiser.

I had a w205 c63 before and that car feels agile, this one with the four wheel drive and size feels more like a fast comfy sofa.

It would probably be cheaper to keep what you have and buy something like a Cayman for pleasure.

The g31 are quite hard to find and good specced ones will be high 20s I think.

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
hungry_hog said:
I have a g31 540i.

It s a quick and comfortable car but you really feel the weight and size. If you are looking for a fun car it isn t really it. It s more of a cruiser.

I had a w205 c63 before and that car feels agile, this one with the four wheel drive and size feels more like a fast comfy sofa.

It would probably be cheaper to keep what you have and buy something like a Cayman for pleasure.

The g31 are quite hard to find and good specced ones will be high 20s I think.
thanks. Good advice. I have a Boxster Spyder for pleasure. So think I’m staying with what I have

DickP

1,180 posts

181 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
Hi,

How prevalent are the heater matrix issues that warrant taking the whole dash out to fix?

Ed.Neumann

1,347 posts

39 months

Friday 30th October
quotequote all
Maxus said:
Whilst getting the new car would be exciting, I think you'd miss the 530d competence in a short space of time.
Agreed.

Maxus said:
Whilst the B58 petrol is a superb engine, for application in bigger cars I personally prefer the B57 diesel. Low down torque, easier to waft around in, performance not too far apart and the economy benefit.
Spot on.


I swapped my F11 530d Touring after 190k miles, I put on 100k in 3 years and it replaced a previous 530d touring, and before that was a 335i touring.


I thought I wanted to go back to petrol, going from 30,000 miles a year to 12k or so, and the B58 was the obvious choice.

I tried the 540i and liked it, but I did find it.......hmmm? Not sure, like it sort of didn't suit that car as well as the 530d.
I actually tried a 530i too, and if anything that was better, you could really feel the weight difference.



In the end I bought an E43 estate, it didn't feel lighter, or faster, if anything it felt heavier, but, it felt more torquey when not giving it the beans, and it did feel a bit more agile when pressing on.

But.....I would swap for a RWD G31 530d again tomorrow if I could be arsed with the rigmarole of buying and selling. Not even selling, but buying a car that is now maybe 5 years old or more just feels like a chore. I am sure there are some great cars out there, but there are also some real dogs too, and it seems at the moment the dealers can't even afford to prep them properly.


Stick with what you have, it is probably the best all round family car you can buy, regardless of price.




Edited by Ed.Neumann on Friday 30th October 17:53

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,678 posts

174 months

Friday 30th October
quotequote all
Ed.Neumann said:
Maxus said:
Whilst getting the new car would be exciting, I think you'd miss the 530d competence in a short space of time.
Agreed.

Maxus said:
Whilst the B58 petrol is a superb engine, for application in bigger cars I personally prefer the B57 diesel. Low down torque, easier to waft around in, performance not too far apart and the economy benefit.
Spot on.


I swapped my F11 530d Touring after 190k miles, I put on 100k in 3 years and it replaced a previous 530d touring, and before that was a 335i touring.


I thought I wanted to go back to petrol, going from 30,000 miles a year to 12k or so, and the B58 was the obvious choice.

I tried the 540i and liked it, but I did find it.......hmmm? Not sure, like it sort of didn't suit that car as well as the 530d.
I actually tried a 530i too, and if anything that was better, you could really feel the weight difference.



In the end I bought an E43 estate, it didn't feel lighter, or faster, if anything it felt heavier, but, it felt more torquey when not giving it the beans, and it did feel a bit more agile when pressing on.

But.....I would swap for a RWD G31 530d again tomorrow if I could be arsed with the rigmarole of buying and selling. Not even selling, but buying a car that is now maybe 5 years old or more just feels like a chore. I am sure there are some great cars out there, but there are also some real dogs too, and it seems at the moment the dealers can't even afford to prep them properly.


Stick with what you have, it is probably the best all round family car you can buy, regardless of price.




Edited by Ed.Neumann on Friday 30th October 17:53
Great advice and good to hear. I realise spending 20k extra to get the same car I already have but with a B58 isn t going to thrill me and really won t give me more and actually might give me less. There is something so right about a b57 engined G31




Edited by Billy_Whizzzz on Friday 30th October 20:32