N55 idle weirdness
N55 idle weirdness
Author
Discussion

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,666 posts

244 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Driving home last night, 2011 535i, came to a stop, went to get going again and realised the engine had stopped. Had the radio on so didn't notice and no lumpiness or shaking. Restarted, set off. All normal. Car driving absolutely fine. Next junction, same thing happened. And it kept happening until I got home. It basically won't idle for more than a second or two. When you restart the car, you have to get quickly into drive or reverse and set off and then it is normal but if you leave it any longer, the revs just die off. No drama, no misfiring or lumpiness, it's as if you have just the shut the engine down.

Went out to the car this morning and started it from cold and it idled fine. Didn't have time to leave it going for ages but it did get warm enough to move from cold start idle over to warm idle. All fine. I did however get a warning on start up to the effect of 'high 12v battery discharge'. I get this every now and then if the alarm has gone off but I did not hear that last night or recently. Could it be battery related?

I scanned with bimmerlink and there are no codes relating to the engine at all.

I have a mental list of tests to do including the battery, MAF, MAP, maybe do a smoke test. But I would think that any vac issue or sensor issue would normally result in a very grumpy idle.

danb79

13,960 posts

103 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
Driving home last night, 2011 535i, came to a stop, went to get going again and realised the engine had stopped. Had the radio on so didn't notice and no lumpiness or shaking. Restarted, set off. All normal. Car driving absolutely fine. Next junction, same thing happened. And it kept happening until I got home. It basically won't idle for more than a second or two. When you restart the car, you have to get quickly into drive or reverse and set off and then it is normal but if you leave it any longer, the revs just die off. No drama, no misfiring or lumpiness, it's as if you have just the shut the engine down.

Went out to the car this morning and started it from cold and it idled fine. Didn't have time to leave it going for ages but it did get warm enough to move from cold start idle over to warm idle. All fine. I did however get a warning on start up to the effect of 'high 12v battery discharge'. I get this every now and then if the alarm has gone off but I did not hear that last night or recently. Could it be battery related?

I scanned with bimmerlink and there are no codes relating to the engine at all.

I have a mental list of tests to do including the battery, MAF, MAP, maybe do a smoke test. But I would think that any vac issue or sensor issue would normally result in a very grumpy idle.
Could be cam/crank sensor; they don't always give codes unfortunately

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,666 posts

244 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
danb79 said:
Could be cam/crank sensor; they don't always give codes unfortunately
Thanks Dan. Good point. I seem to remember having a crank sensor issue on another car that only showed itself when warm. Any way of testing these, or is it just a case of replacing them?

Looks like both sensors are cheap enough

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/19913520?_gl=1*wkm...

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/938027?_gl=1*av4w7...

danb79

13,960 posts

103 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
danb79 said:
Could be cam/crank sensor; they don't always give codes unfortunately
Thanks Dan. Good point. I seem to remember having a crank sensor issue on another car that only showed itself when warm. Any way of testing these, or is it just a case of replacing them?

Looks like both sensors are cheap enough

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/19913520?_gl=1*wkm...

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/938027?_gl=1*av4w7...
Go OE BMW or not at all squire; don't know who makes them, but you need to stick with that. Sensors like these, same with MAFs etc all need to be OE / whoever makes them; or you'll end up doing the job twice

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,666 posts

244 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
danb79 said:
Gad-Westy said:
danb79 said:
Could be cam/crank sensor; they don't always give codes unfortunately
Thanks Dan. Good point. I seem to remember having a crank sensor issue on another car that only showed itself when warm. Any way of testing these, or is it just a case of replacing them?

Looks like both sensors are cheap enough

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/19913520?_gl=1*wkm...

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/938027?_gl=1*av4w7...
Go OE BMW or not at all squire; don't know who makes them, but you need to stick with that. Sensors like these, same with MAFs etc all need to be OE / whoever makes them; or you'll end up doing the job twice
The dilemma is that OE from BMW looks to nearer £300-500 for the pair. Which makes it much harder to just throw them on and hope. Hence why ideally I'd be able to diagnose in some way first.

Actually, now I'm digging more, it seems Hella is OE for the crank sensor. I'd just assumed it was the same for the cam sensor but seems that is VDO/continental.

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/vdo/1737404?_gl=1*4fi8v7...

I guess that and the Hella crank sensor should be reasonably safe bet?



Edited by Gad-Westy on Tuesday 10th November 19:37

danb79

13,960 posts

103 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
danb79 said:
Gad-Westy said:
danb79 said:
Could be cam/crank sensor; they don't always give codes unfortunately
Thanks Dan. Good point. I seem to remember having a crank sensor issue on another car that only showed itself when warm. Any way of testing these, or is it just a case of replacing them?

Looks like both sensors are cheap enough

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/19913520?_gl=1*wkm...

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/hella/938027?_gl=1*av4w7...
Go OE BMW or not at all squire; don't know who makes them, but you need to stick with that. Sensors like these, same with MAFs etc all need to be OE / whoever makes them; or you'll end up doing the job twice
The dilemma is that OE from BMW looks to nearer £300-500 for the pair. Which makes it much harder to just throw them on and hope. Hence why ideally I'd be able to diagnose in some way first.

Actually, now I'm digging more, it seems Hella is OE for the crank sensor. I'd just assumed it was the same for the cam sensor but seems that is VDO/continental.

https://www.autodoc.co.uk/vdo/1737404?_gl=1*4fi8v7...

I guess that and the Hella crank sensor should be reasonably safe bet?



Edited by Gad-Westy on Tuesday 10th November 19:37
You could try it; but it's well known that aftermarket sensors tend tom cause more issues... If that's who make them then try it

E39s were well known for it; cam/crank sensor issues; warm start issues but no EML/codes etc - fit aftermarket sensor and it makes it worse; go OE (Siemens and VDO IIRC) and no issues after that

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,666 posts

244 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all
Not had much chance to look too deep into this yet but I did just check battery voltage. 14.5v at idle (seems okay), 11.8v ignition on, engine off. That seems a little low to me. I haven't quite got my head around it could/would cause it to struggle to maintain idle when warm. I'll try to get a vac test done this weekend and go from there.

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,666 posts

244 months

Yesterday (05:59)
quotequote all
Hopefully sorted. Fitted a new battery yesterday. While in there, I cleaned both intake sensors and the MAF sensor. Took it out for 20 minutes after and it behaved perfectly. Fingers very crossed!

danb79

13,960 posts

103 months

Yesterday (09:35)
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
Hopefully sorted. Fitted a new battery yesterday. While in there, I cleaned both intake sensors and the MAF sensor. Took it out for 20 minutes after and it behaved perfectly. Fingers very crossed!
Fingrs crossed; always nice when it's an easy fix smile

BananaMonkey

7 posts

4 months

Yesterday (19:15)
quotequote all
I had a 2012 F11 535i and a 2005 645Ci - less so on the 5 but the cam/crank sensor on the 6 caused all sorts of issues. Just for peace of mind I d replace it with OE as Dan says - a particularly memorable moment was going round the M25 anti clock in the outside lane passing the Leatherhead junction and it just cut out. Speaking to a specialist it can cause all sorts of seemingly unrelated errors