Flat Tyre Monitor and downstream disasters
Flat Tyre Monitor and downstream disasters
Author
Discussion

Possum19

Original Poster:

64 posts

52 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all

Christmas is fast approaching and to get into the spirit my 125k F31 320d has decided to switch on practically all of it's dash lights.

According to the car the culprit is an FTM, which one it cannot say. Clearly picking between 4 is too much for it's tiny brain to handle. The knock on effect is that the ABS, traction control, cruise control and driving modes which are all now disabled, just in time for the first frost.

A quick diagnostic check at Halfords (the only place with availiblity and they did do it for free) to check I wasn't going to die on my commute home confirmed the FTM was caput, but also that the car was throwing a drive shaft pick up ring error.

None of this is terribly surprising considering the car's advanced age, just like my TV it is 14 years old this year, and the fact it spent a torturous few years in the freezing salty wasteland that is Aberdeenshire. The first quote I've had back was over £900 which seems a little steep at 50% of the car's value, but did include a new drive shaft as well as the ring and sensor...

Has anyone gto any experience with this issue and the cost of getting it fixed? Bitter experience suggests that a cheap sensor replacement leads to more and more expensive issues appearing as work continues.

My last car was the very definition of the sunk cost fallacy and I'd like to avoid that scenario again, however the car generally runs beautifully and had a new timing chain 30k ago so the usual time bomb has been defused, albeit after it went off. I don't really want to buy a new car but my concern is that the insidious salt and potential rusting hiding underneath, plus the spectre of death by diesel soot may mean it's time to pull the plug.

Is this the beginning of the end? Is the FTM a portent of doom? Shared experiences, tough love advice or tarot card readings all very welcome.

danb79

13,960 posts

103 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all
Possum19 said:
Christmas is fast approaching and to get into the spirit my 125k F31 320d has decided to switch on practically all of it's dash lights.

According to the car the culprit is an FTM, which one it cannot say. Clearly picking between 4 is too much for it's tiny brain to handle. The knock on effect is that the ABS, traction control, cruise control and driving modes which are all now disabled, just in time for the first frost.

A quick diagnostic check at Halfords (the only place with availiblity and they did do it for free) to check I wasn't going to die on my commute home confirmed the FTM was caput, but also that the car was throwing a drive shaft pick up ring error.

None of this is terribly surprising considering the car's advanced age, just like my TV it is 14 years old this year, and the fact it spent a torturous few years in the freezing salty wasteland that is Aberdeenshire. The first quote I've had back was over £900 which seems a little steep at 50% of the car's value, but did include a new drive shaft as well as the ring and sensor...

Has anyone gto any experience with this issue and the cost of getting it fixed? Bitter experience suggests that a cheap sensor replacement leads to more and more expensive issues appearing as work continues.

My last car was the very definition of the sunk cost fallacy and I'd like to avoid that scenario again, however the car generally runs beautifully and had a new timing chain 30k ago so the usual time bomb has been defused, albeit after it went off. I don't really want to buy a new car but my concern is that the insidious salt and potential rusting hiding underneath, plus the spectre of death by diesel soot may mean it's time to pull the plug.

Is this the beginning of the end? Is the FTM a portent of doom? Shared experiences, tough love advice or tarot card readings all very welcome.
Get these: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/127851603395

Replace all 4; recalibrate when you're driving and all should be sorted

shakindog

516 posts

181 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all
Does it definitely have sensors in the wheels as some bmw’s use the abs system as the part of tpms system measures rolling radius and other things to work it all out.
So could be due to the abs ring issue

Mr Tidy

31,927 posts

158 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all
Just a thought but how healthy is your battery?

I've had three BMWs that threw up a random selection of warning lights when their batteries were on their last legs!

MarkJS

2,191 posts

178 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
shakindog said:
Does it definitely have sensors in the wheels as some bmw s use the abs system as the part of tpms system measures rolling radius and other things to work it all out.
So could be due to the abs ring issue
Good point. It wasn’t till after 2014 when all models with that spec carried the TPMS valves so could well be the older system on the OP’s car. Very easy to tell though.

swanny71

3,615 posts

240 months

Sunday 15th November
quotequote all
Easy to tell if the car has TPMS sensors - silver/metal valve stems.

The OP doesn’t say if Halfords found one TPMS sensor was the fault or if it was the TPMS receiver - I’ve had this on a 2014 BMW and the fix is cheap & easy. About £100 for a new receiver, plug and play no coding required.

TPMS in BMW speak is RDCi if you’re looking for info/solutions on the internet.

Or put car details in here for diagrams and part numbers.
https://www.realoem.com/bmw/enUS/select

c3m

333 posts

182 months

Sunday 15th November
quotequote all
I just installed 4 new TPMS valves on my F30 LCI. Schrader 3151 are the OE for the F30 LCI, they work perfectly, show temperature and pressure.

The Autodoc page shows all BMW part numbers https://www.autodoc.co.uk/schrader/16009702

Possum19

Original Poster:

64 posts

52 months

swanny71 said:
Easy to tell if the car has TPMS sensors - silver/metal valve stems.

The OP doesn t say if Halfords found one TPMS sensor was the fault or if it was the TPMS receiver - I ve had this on a 2014 BMW and the fix is cheap & easy. About £100 for a new receiver, plug and play no coding required.

TPMS in BMW speak is RDCi if you re looking for info/solutions on the internet.

Or put car details in here for diagrams and part numbers.
https://www.realoem.com/bmw/enUS/select
No they didn't say if it iwas the sensor or reciever, just that it was the rear nearside throwing the error. My concern is the drive shaft pick up ring error, which I believe if not fixed could rub and break any new sensor that is put on. Apparently this is quite a cheap part, but I worry that the issues could run into the drive shaft which could then also need replacing, the car does have a bit of a rust problem (front wings) Probably kicked off by its time in Scotland...

Anyway, it'll be into my preferred garege soonish for a proper check, but thank you for your input it all helps me not go in "blind"!

Possum19

Original Poster:

64 posts

52 months

c3m said:
I just installed 4 new TPMS valves on my F30 LCI. Schrader 3151 are the OE for the F30 LCI, they work perfectly, show temperature and pressure.

The Autodoc page shows all BMW part numbers https://www.autodoc.co.uk/schrader/16009702
On a scale of 0 "can't change own washer fluid" to 10 " rally mechanics rebuilding a rolled WRC car in 30mins" how hard is this to do and are any specialist tools needed? Thanks!

Possum19

Original Poster:

64 posts

52 months

Mr Tidy said:
Just a thought but how healthy is your battery?

I've had three BMWs that threw up a random selection of warning lights when their batteries were on their last legs!
Seems fine as far as I can tell, starts no problem and no other issues coming up for now

Marshall878

189 posts

25 months

Possum19 said:
On a scale of 0 "can't change own washer fluid" to 10 " rally mechanics rebuilding a rolled WRC car in 30mins" how hard is this to do and are any specialist tools needed? Thanks!
well to start you'd need to be able to remove/install tyres and rebalance if replacing those. Tyre shop would do it for not alot of money.

drdino

1,337 posts

173 months

Indirect TPMS uses differential speed amongst the wheels to highlight a flat tyre, this in turn uses the wheelspeed sensors. If you don't have any RDC faults pointing to a TPMS sensor (direct system) then you likely have the indirect one. ABS errors also point to a wheelspeed sensor issue (most common cause), a TPMS sensor issue on its own will not cause the cascade of errors you described.

TLDR: get a Bluetooth OBD reader and pull codes from your vehicle using Bimmerlink.

Possum19

Original Poster:

64 posts

52 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
drdino said:
Indirect TPMS uses differential speed amongst the wheels to highlight a flat tyre, this in turn uses the wheelspeed sensors. If you don't have any RDC faults pointing to a TPMS sensor (direct system) then you likely have the indirect one. ABS errors also point to a wheelspeed sensor issue (most common cause), a TPMS sensor issue on its own will not cause the cascade of errors you described.

TLDR: get a Bluetooth OBD reader and pull codes from your vehicle using Bimmerlink.
It's a creaky old bd (2012) so has the FTM (RPA / Indirect System) with a magnetic encoder ring integrated into the wheel bearing at each hub I believe. I'm waiting on a quote from my garage split by level of fix needed (sensor only, pick up ring, entire drive shaft...) so we'll see.

The car is probbaly only worth £2k on a good day, but had had the timing chain done and some other suspension and wheel bearings oveer the last 3 years so I'm torn as to whether it has life left or it's time to move on. My last car broke my wallet, heart and sanity with ongoing problems. Top tip, don't buy a Mazda 6 diesel...

Skye5

159 posts

1 month

Tuesday
quotequote all
Possum19 said:
drdino said:
Indirect TPMS uses differential speed amongst the wheels to highlight a flat tyre, this in turn uses the wheelspeed sensors. If you don't have any RDC faults pointing to a TPMS sensor (direct system) then you likely have the indirect one. ABS errors also point to a wheelspeed sensor issue (most common cause), a TPMS sensor issue on its own will not cause the cascade of errors you described.

TLDR: get a Bluetooth OBD reader and pull codes from your vehicle using Bimmerlink.
It's a creaky old bd (2012) so has the FTM (RPA / Indirect System) with a magnetic encoder ring integrated into the wheel bearing at each hub I believe. I'm waiting on a quote from my garage split by level of fix needed (sensor only, pick up ring, entire drive shaft...) so we'll see.

The car is probbaly only worth £2k on a good day, but had had the timing chain done and some other suspension and wheel bearings oveer the last 3 years so I'm torn as to whether it has life left or it's time to move on. My last car broke my wallet, heart and sanity with ongoing problems. Top tip, don't buy a Mazda 6 diesel...
Isn't what you are describing a wheel speed sensor, ie usually part of the ABS system? that would explain why is affects so many other systems.

ABS sensors are pretty cheap and the reluctance rings on the hub or driveshaft don't really wear out, but they can sometimes need a good clean.

Could that be the problem?

Edited by Skye5 on Tuesday 17th November 09:00