BMW 450 GS Trophy
Discussion
Having recently attended the BMW Off Road Skills course in Wales where I chose the 450 trophy for 2 days I'm considering getting one.
Interested to hear from owner's reviews generally .
My usage would like be 50/50 road/green lanes and I'm not the most experienced of off road riders.
TIA
Interested to hear from owner's reviews generally .
My usage would like be 50/50 road/green lanes and I'm not the most experienced of off road riders.
TIA
I’d recommend YouTube, and Advrider.com, both have got plenty of owner videos and comments. Might struggle for owner reviews in here, I don’t recall anyone having posted up that they have one (although I might be wrong).
My thoughts, having recently bought a bike for similar purposes to you (albeit 25% light trail, 75% road) was that the 450GS felt very much like a road bike to sit on, spoked wheels were either unavailable or a £1500 option, and that the overall price was high for a bike built by TVS in India.
My thoughts, having recently bought a bike for similar purposes to you (albeit 25% light trail, 75% road) was that the 450GS felt very much like a road bike to sit on, spoked wheels were either unavailable or a £1500 option, and that the overall price was high for a bike built by TVS in India.
H40405J said:
I d recommend YouTube, and Advrider.com, both have got plenty of owner videos and comments. Might struggle for owner reviews in here, I don t recall anyone having posted up that they have one (although I might be wrong).
My thoughts, having recently bought a bike for similar purposes to you (albeit 25% light trail, 75% road) was that the 450GS felt very much like a road bike to sit on, spoked wheels were either unavailable or a £1500 option, and that the overall price was high for a bike built by TVS in India.
Thank you kindly . My thoughts, having recently bought a bike for similar purposes to you (albeit 25% light trail, 75% road) was that the 450GS felt very much like a road bike to sit on, spoked wheels were either unavailable or a £1500 option, and that the overall price was high for a bike built by TVS in India.
I've watched a good few videos on YouTube but you never quite know how biased they might be.
May I ask what bike you bought ?
Esquire said:
Thank you kindly .
I've watched a good few videos on YouTube but you never quite know how biased they might be.
May I ask what bike you bought ?
I bought an ex demo Kawasaki KLE500. It’s excellent and rides very well on the gravel trails of the Ridgeway but was specific to my use case (25% light gravel trails, will service at home, a good low seated touring bike for gf to take to Alps next year) so wouldn’t necessarily recommend it.I've watched a good few videos on YouTube but you never quite know how biased they might be.
May I ask what bike you bought ?
Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it’s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I’d go as light as possible as you’ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
H40405J said:
I bought an ex demo Kawasaki KLE500. It s excellent and rides very well on the gravel trails of the Ridgeway but was specific to my use case (25% light gravel trails, will service at home, a good low seated touring bike for gf to take to Alps next year) so wouldn t necessarily recommend it.
Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
Cheers. Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
Did think about the CRF but thought It'd be even less of a road bike than the GS.
I also didn't mind the new clutch on the GS.
Riding off road would be gravel and some muddy trails in all likelihood.
Think I need to go and maybe ride some bikes .
The KTM range also seem quite interesting
H40405J said:
I bought an ex demo Kawasaki KLE500. It s excellent and rides very well on the gravel trails of the Ridgeway but was specific to my use case (25% light gravel trails, will service at home, a good low seated touring bike for gf to take to Alps next year) so wouldn t necessarily recommend it.
Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
I think that's good advice/info. Having owned a number of the bikes listed including currently Tuareg and CRF300L, there's no perfect option. I keep chopping and changing but think I now have a good balance - Tuareg for when it's mostly dry and less challenging lanes and tours involving long road sections, CRF for snottier stuff, generally more local. I had an enduro too but felt I wasn't really riding it hard enough to justify.Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
The BMW 450 looks decent enough but I really don't see why in that space one wouldn't get the KTM390 Adventure R or CFMoto450 for less money. And the CFMoto I had was better than it had any right to be on trickier green lanes.
GM182 said:
I think that's good advice/info. Having owned a number of the bikes listed including currently Tuareg and CRF300L, there's no perfect option. I keep chopping and changing but think I now have a good balance - Tuareg for when it's mostly dry and less challenging lanes and tours involving long road sections, CRF for snottier stuff, generally more local. I had an enduro too but felt I wasn't really riding it hard enough to justify.
The BMW 450 looks decent enough but I really don't see why in that space one wouldn't get the KTM390 Adventure R or CFMoto450 for less money. And the CFMoto I had was better than it had any right to be on trickier green lanes.
I did mention the KTM to a friend of mine who questioned their reliability over the BMW . The BMW 450 looks decent enough but I really don't see why in that space one wouldn't get the KTM390 Adventure R or CFMoto450 for less money. And the CFMoto I had was better than it had any right to be on trickier green lanes.
I take your point on the KTM though. Feels like it's more their space over the BMW in that category
H40405J said:
Depends very much on what your 50% off road involves. If it s the Ridgeway on a sunny weekend at pottering speed (like mine is) then any good adventure bike will do. 450GS, KLE, CFMoto 450MT, Himalayan 450 will all be decent options. Plenty from the next class up do this well too, Tenere, KTM 7/890, CFMoto 800/1000MTX, Tuareg and will be much nicer road bikes than the 450GS.
If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
Don't forget tyres. In my limited experience on a Himalayan 411, 50/50 tyres (Continental TKC80) have considerable limitations in mud (accentuated by inexperience If that 50% off road is more along the lines of a Welsh green lane in February then I d go as light as possible as you ll spend a lot of time picking it up. Either buy a cheap used CRF300 or Voge 300 Rally and treat it as a disposable item or a proper enduro bike.
), and a proper knobbly (Michelin Tracker) on the front is awful on the road.Based on limited experience, and bearing in mind that I was 72 years old before I ventured off-tarmac
, I'm not sure that there is a one-bike solution for a novice. I'd buy something light and cheap that you don't mind throwing at the scenery for the lanes, and suffer its limitations on the road. Then I'd buy one of the smaller capacity, or at least lighter, adventure bikes for daily use, and travelling and easy tracks here and abroad, and transfer the skills learned on the trail bike.@Esquire, where in the country are you? I have some YT green laning channels bookmarked, and one of them might give you an idea of what your local lanes are like.
Edited by gareth_r on Friday 30th October 12:08
gareth_r said:
Don't forget tyres. In my limited experience on a Himalayan 411, 50/50 tyres (Continental TKC80) have considerable limitations in mud (accentuated by inexperience
), and a proper knobbly (Michelin Tracker) on the front is awful on the road.
You also have to be honest with yourself, how much off road riding will you actually do. I have got a set of Anakee Adventures to go on my Himi. Much as I love the lanes, I do a lot more miles on tarmac and to make my life worse there just to be faster/braver off road is nonsensical. As such, I avoid lanes with deep mud and grass at this time of year.
), and a proper knobbly (Michelin Tracker) on the front is awful on the road.Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


