ST1100 Pan or Deauville 700 for my 41+m round trip commute?
ST1100 Pan or Deauville 700 for my 41+m round trip commute?
Author
Discussion

CHLEMCBC

Original Poster:

2,059 posts

48 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
As above, the Burgman is going to cost too much to bother fixing so I need a winter commuter. These Hondas seem to be good value and will likely be tediously reliable, so which is best?

My commute is 2.5 miles of 30 mph village and 60 mph B road to the M6, then 15 miles to an urban expressway for a mile then more 30mph city roads for a couple of miles and back.

Are Dullvilles really boring? Is the Pan stupidly top heavy? I'm used to filtering with luggage so that's not much of an issue.

Jazoli

9,707 posts

281 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Can you not stretch to a R1200RT or ST1300? the ST1100 PE's are very very old now and will be probably knackered.

You can pick up a NC700/750 for a couple of grand, they are a ready made commuter.

Xcore

1,548 posts

121 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Pan, atleast it’s remotely interesting.

ssray

1,382 posts

256 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Out of the two st1100, very stable, much quicker than the nt700 and handles quite well

Steve_H80

634 posts

53 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
I would get whichever is cheaper/lowest miles - it's a commuting tool, not a toy.

CHLEMCBC

Original Poster:

2,059 posts

48 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Jazoli said:
Can you not stretch to a R1200RT or ST1300? the ST1100 PE's are very very old now and will be probably knackered.

You can pick up a NC700/750 for a couple of grand, they are a ready made commuter.
I can stretch, I just don't want to. I paid too much for the Burgman because I'm often a tt with money. I'm trying to be better this time.

the cueball

1,927 posts

86 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
I've been using the Pan Euro for my everyday bikes for 15 years or so.

Only needed 2 in that time.

1st one was over 150k miles, took me around Europe 3 times and many trips around the UK.

Currently one is only 26k miles and in near perfect condition.

Great for the morning commute, winter hack, training, shopping, touring, whatever.

Silky V4 and decent weather protection.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
A half decent ST1100 is definitely the better option but, given their age, ensuring you get a half decent one will be a challenge.

stang65

605 posts

168 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Jazoli said:
You can pick up a NC700/750 for a couple of grand, they are a ready made commuter.
I'd imagine the lack of shaft drive will be a significant downside of an NC during winter commutes. Whilst I don't mind a chain not having to get involved in cleaning, adjusting etc. through the depths of winter must be a plus point when doing 400 miles a week.

CHLEMCBC

Original Poster:

2,059 posts

48 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
stang65 said:
Jazoli said:
You can pick up a NC700/750 for a couple of grand, they are a ready made commuter.
I'd imagine the lack of shaft drive will be a significant downside of an NC during winter commutes. Whilst I don't mind a chain not having to get involved in cleaning, adjusting etc. through the depths of winter must be a plus point when doing 400 miles a week.
Yes, I should have mentioned I'd prefer a shaft having run chains through winters before... As BMWs were mentioned above I did start looking at F800s with a belt. I know a couple of people who commute on them and say good things. Any opinions, anyone? There seems to be plenty around at £2-2500

The other factor, though is that I've just moved teams on a 3 month (possibly more) secondment which will only require me to be in the office 2 days a week, so the total monthly mileage will be significantly reduced. (I should have made clear the 42 miles is a round trip figure, too, so it was "only" 200 miles a week before this week.)

Marquezs Stabilisers

2,606 posts

92 months

Wednesday 11th November
quotequote all
I test rode a Deauville as a potential bike when I was an instructor. It was so dull I cried, it was leagues more boring than even an NC or a big Forza.

the cueball

1,927 posts

86 months

Wednesday 11th November
quotequote all
There is a reason they're called Dullvilles I guess...

916

31 posts

114 months

Wednesday 11th November
quotequote all
I’ve had a couple of NT700’s through the years. They are great functional motorbikes.

However when I’ve had one I’ve also had a sports bike or at least another bike with more power at the same time to get my kicks.

They are superb for communiting and touring if you just sit on motorways or A roads. I got rid of my first one, that I think I bought from new as I started touring two up with my then girlfriend (now wife) and for those who think the Deauville is slow, we’ll try it two up, it’s awful. I was getting overtaken by pretty much everything. Sold it and bought a FJR1300.

Anyway if it’s just for commuting only, it is a good solid choice. My tip would be make sure it has the standard pannier lids, not the optional large/wide ones as these extend past the mirrors and bars and will be a pain for filtering.

Also the way the panniers open with the two latches is a known trouble spot so worth double checking.

I never had any problems with either of mine.
finally just my two pence worth, I wouldn’t rule out a bike with a chain as an all year commuter.
There’s an almost misconception about chains rusting away during a winter with salted roads, which to be fair they did 20/25 years ago.
However modern chains are so much better than they used to be and a little care will see them lasting through multiple years.

Cheers.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Thursday 12th November
quotequote all
the cueball said:
There is a reason they're called Dullvilles I guess...
I can't comment on the 700 but I hired a NC750X recently and it was the worst, most boring, enjoyment sapping, poor performing pile of st I've ever ridden. Personally, however much it looks on paper to be a great commuting bike, I'd pick just about anything else.

Marquezs Stabilisers

2,606 posts

92 months

Thursday 12th November
quotequote all
916 said:
finally just my two pence worth, I wouldn t rule out a bike with a chain as an all year commuter.
There s an almost misconception about chains rusting away during a winter with salted roads, which to be fair they did 20/25 years ago.
However modern chains are so much better than they used to be and a little care will see them lasting through multiple years.
Agree. Commuted for thousands of miles for years all year round on a Ducati Multistrada, so a big V Twin thumping at it. Chains weren't an issue with a Scottoiler fitted.