Passenger door solenoid not working
Passenger door solenoid not working
Author
Discussion

EggsBenedict

Original Poster:

1,791 posts

195 months

Friday 5th March 2021
quotequote all
Getting the Chim ready for its first year driving in ages. The passenger door won't open from the outside. Which, apart from inconvenience is an MOT fail. What's the likely diagnosis? Is there anything I can test without taking the door completely apart?

phillpot

17,432 posts

204 months

Friday 5th March 2021
quotequote all


Aren't all the workings in the B post, not the door?

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Friday 5th March 2021
quotequote all
Lift flap of carpet on b pillar left of passenger seat back. All bits are in there.

Is it button under m8rror version or push handle on b pillar

EggsBenedict

Original Poster:

1,791 posts

195 months

Saturday 6th March 2021
quotequote all
Button under mirror...

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Saturday 6th March 2021
quotequote all
Ok. It could be the door actuator, so you need to get your multimeter out and start testing those wires in door pillar.

Are you able to do that ?
ie do you have the tools and knowledge to do that or do you need full detailed instructions ?

Tony91

216 posts

161 months

Saturday 6th March 2021
quotequote all
Take the door card off and check the connectors they can get water damage and can oxidise.
Just unplug and clean the contacts to make a good connection.

Classic Chim

12,424 posts

170 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
blaze_away said:
Ok. It could be the door actuator, so you need to get your multimeter out and start testing those wires in door pillar.

Are you able to do that ?
ie do you have the tools and knowledge to do that or do you need full detailed instructions ?
Full detailed instructions please as my n/s solenoid needs replacing I think frown

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
Tony91 said:
Take the door card off and check the connectors they can get water damage and can oxidise.
Just unplug and clean the contacts to make a good connection.
Sorry Tony that's not quite right, All the door wiring is in the B pillar, the only wiring that's in the door behind the door panel is speaker, mirror and window wiring. It does include the wires for the door button but those can be accessed by removing the glass from the door mirror.

Agree he needs to do 'unplug and clean contacts' but in B pillar on solenoids.

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
Classic Chim said:
blaze_away said:
Ok. It could be the door actuator, so you need to get your multimeter out and start testing those wires in door pillar.

Are you able to do that ?
ie do you have the tools and knowledge to do that or do you need full detailed instructions ?
Full detailed instructions please as my n/s solenoid needs replacing I think frown
Well here goes full details......drive to Napton to my lockup and I'll do it and show you, I have some spare (4 of I think) solenoids.

Classic Chim

12,424 posts

170 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
blaze_away said:
Well here goes full details......drive to Napton to my lockup and I'll do it and show you, I have some spare (4 of I think) solenoids.
laugh
Will do thumbup

Tony91

216 posts

161 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
blaze_away said:
Sorry Tony that's not quite right, All the door wiring is in the B pillar, the only wiring that's in the door behind the door panel is speaker, mirror and window wiring. It does include the wires for the door button but those can be accessed by removing the glass from the door mirror.

Agree he needs to do 'unplug and clean contacts' but in B pillar on solenoids.
Yes agreed but if you take out the speaker there is a connector with 2 thin wires that goes to the button check that for continuity

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
Tony91 said:
blaze_away said:
Sorry Tony that's not quite right, All the door wiring is in the B pillar, the only wiring that's in the door behind the door panel is speaker, mirror and window wiring. It does include the wires for the door button but those can be accessed by removing the glass from the door mirror.

Agree he needs to do 'unplug and clean contacts' but in B pillar on solenoids.
Yes agreed but if you take out the speaker there is a connector with 2 thin wires that goes to the button check that for continuity
Yep thats a good un to check.

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
OP (Ben) here is my suggestion on where to start.

When you say 'wont open from outside' do you mean

1. Does It open on the key fob when you unlock the car ?

2. Does it fail to open when you blip the mirror button ?

Tony91

216 posts

161 months

Sunday 7th March 2021
quotequote all
The first thing that I would check is the passenger door curtesy light switch this can cause all sorts of problems for the door opener switch.
I had this on my Chim the push in switch was not being pushed in with the door shut I put a piece of rubber glued into the recess to activate the switch when the door was closed. The switch is a non earth type so needs 2 connectors on it as the switch is not earthed as a convential metal bodied car.

EggsBenedict

Original Poster:

1,791 posts

195 months

Monday 8th March 2021
quotequote all
blaze_away said:
OP (Ben) here is my suggestion on where to start.

When you say 'wont open from outside' do you mean

1. Does It open on the key fob when you unlock the car ?

2. Does it fail to open when you blip the mirror button ?
1. Lol. I'm not sure the alarm button does anything much! It does make the immobiliser turn off. The car is bone stock, complete with crappy alarm! One day it will get the Baker treatment with luck and a following wind.

2. Yes. This is it. It used to open with that button, but not any more. Oddly it's done it before as in the docs I have it failed the MOT on it previously (how I know it's an MOT fail).

I have a multimeter and and I can be competent with it on myh day. Obvs if someone has done something like this before, I'd appreciate the pointers. If not, I'll have a poke about in the B pillar and see what gives.

EggsBenedict

Original Poster:

1,791 posts

195 months

Monday 8th March 2021
quotequote all
blaze_away said:
Ok. It could be the door actuator, so you need to get your multimeter out and start testing those wires in door pillar.

Are you able to do that ?
ie do you have the tools and knowledge to do that or do you need full detailed instructions ?
I have the tools. The knowledge is something I'm looking for. I guess there's lots that I can check, but I'm looking for a 'try here first, and here next' type thing.

Mostly things that go wrong IME have common problems, or a weak point somewhere that follow the 80:20 rule...

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Monday 8th March 2021
quotequote all
1st job then.

We need to establish the door button works.

The door mirror glass needs to come off. If its standard there is a little lever that slides left and right to lock/unlock the glass from the body of the mirror mechanism. Its a little bit of plastic roughly centre just below bottom of the glass.

Slide it left (or maybe right) about 1 cm and glass will unlock for removal. If its had a replacement glass fitted it maybe just glued on.

Once thats off you can see the inner part of the button.

Short the terminals on the button together.

If the solenoid operates then button is the issue. If it doesn't then its time to go in the b pillar.

I will do some tests on mine tomorrow to give more info.

EggsBenedict

Original Poster:

1,791 posts

195 months

Tuesday 9th March 2021
quotequote all
So got the glass off - on mine the tiny lever thing goes left to undo. I've undone the screws to release the back of the mirror housing. The button wires are not exposed at all (i.e. there's no connectors to undo) so shorting them isn't possible without cutting them etc.

So I moved on to looking at the B-Pillar.

Here the plot thickened. Neither actuator worked (so pressing the little button on the door release knob doesn't make the actuator do anything, pressing the outside button doesn't do anything. Removing both and trying them on the driver's side - both work. So it looked like I got two problems, not one. The door lock actuator is 5 wire, the latch is 2.

Looking again, I realised that there were two 5 way plugs in the passenger side door pillar. So I tried them both. One works (again using the knob button), the other doesn't. So that's one problem solved (I think).

Got the multimeter out (although a test bulb would have worked I guess), and put it in the pins of the 2 wire one. Nada. So snipped the wire of the button, shorted these out, and success! The relay clicks and the actuator, well, it actuates!

So now I need a new button. It looks like a bog standard 12mm momentary button switch. I'm sure I've used these before for another project, but can't remember where I got them. Any clues?

Also, I'm guessing that the button switch has a connector on it, but that's inside the door. Looks like the easiest way in is through the speaker hole. It's not obvious how the speakers are fitted in the doors. I have the (I think) standard Pioneer ones. Clues on how to get them out?

phillpot

17,432 posts

204 months

Tuesday 9th March 2021
quotequote all
EggsBenedict said:
So now I need a new button. It looks like a bog standard 12mm momentary button switch. I'm sure I've used these before for another project, but can't remember where I got them. Any clues?
With the demise of Maplins I'd say RS online or there are bound to be some on Ebay

EggsBenedict said:
Also, I'm guessing that the button switch has a connector on it, but that's inside the door. Looks like the easiest way in is through the speaker hole. It's not obvious how the speakers are fitted in the doors. I have the (I think) standard Pioneer ones. Clues on how to get them out?
Pull mesh off and four screws behind?

blaze_away

1,633 posts

234 months

Tuesday 9th March 2021
quotequote all
Well thats good news. I bought some off ebay last year. 12mm

I had same problem faulty button. Replaced and all working fine again

Try "10X Durable 12mm Waterproof Momentary ON/OFF Push Button Mini Round Switch"



Edited by blaze_away on Tuesday 9th March 16:57