MacBook Air or Pro
Author
Discussion

chml

Original Poster:

741 posts

140 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Hi, looking a MacBook for a bit of cloud based bookkeeping, excel and general web browsing. Is it worth paying the extra for the Pro or just pumping for the Air. Also, does anybody know what the education discount is on these as that might be an option for me to purchase via?

Thanks

Stu-nph26

2,159 posts

136 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
I have the latest Air and it’s more than enough for what I need. The webcam is poor which is a bit disappointing atm especially as web conferencing is so popular. My previous Air had a much better webcam but other than that this one is superior. Mrs has a pro looks and feels better but haven’t noticed any performance difference.

UNiDAYS prices below


Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
I bought a new MacBook Air a few weeks ago. The education discount was £100 off so it cost £898.

chml

Original Poster:

741 posts

140 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Brilliant, thanks! Air isn’t available until 4th Jan but the Pro is available straight away... decisions decisions hehe

Troubleatmill

10,210 posts

190 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Get the version with the new M1 chip


You will kick yourself otherwise.

Google it.


Phunk

2,102 posts

202 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
New MacBook Air and Pro are pretty much identical, for your usage you won't see any advantage going for the Pro.

I'm a heavy video editor and I've just ordered the MacBook Air.

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
CAPP0 said:
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.
The MacBook Air now comes with the new M1 chip which is apparently a big improvement over the older model (which I think you have).

Jiebo

1,088 posts

127 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Get the M1 chip Air. It’s a phenomenal achievement for the first iteration and effective has made Intel redundant. It runs cool like an iPad, has long battery life and is faster than many of Intels high end chips.

It Intel released something similar for the PC the amount of circle jerking going on would break the internet.

megaphone

11,723 posts

282 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
CAPP0 said:
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.
Sounds like there is something wrong with it, take it back.

tapandunwrap

122 posts

237 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Get the pro if you;

1) like the touchbar (may don't),
2) want a couple of extra hours battery life
3) want a slightly brighter screen
4) like the form factor better.

otherwise get the Air which is slimmer but very similar performance.

Whatever you do make sure you get the M1 chip. It is an absolute powerhouse and stays cool with over 2x the battery life.

Upgraded a fortnight ago and it is a dream. Glad i waited.

RFC1

1,111 posts

228 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
Also both even cheaper again from the EDU store, if you can qualify for it.......

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Monday 14th December 2020
quotequote all
megaphone said:
CAPP0 said:
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.
Sounds like there is something wrong with it, take it back.
Hmm, I hadn't considered that. This is my third Mac, so I'm used to how they work & perform. The other two were perfect but this one is really quite frustrating.

geeks

11,900 posts

170 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
Stu-nph26 said:
I have the latest Air and it’s more than enough for what I need. The webcam is poor which is a bit disappointing atm especially as web conferencing is so popular. My previous Air had a much better webcam but other than that this one is superior. Mrs has a pro looks and feels better but haven’t noticed any performance difference.

UNiDAYS prices below

Webcam is equally poor on the pro and the new ones apparently aren't any better which I think is a pretty big oversight!

eps

7,169 posts

300 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
geeks said:
Stu-nph26 said:
I have the latest Air and it’s more than enough for what I need. The webcam is poor which is a bit disappointing atm especially as web conferencing is so popular. My previous Air had a much better webcam but other than that this one is superior. Mrs has a pro looks and feels better but haven’t noticed any performance difference.

UNiDAYS prices below

Webcam is equally poor on the pro and the new ones apparently aren't any better which I think is a pretty big oversight!
Although the resolution isn't improved the image sensor is, so not more pixels, but better definition - especially in lower light.

jw673

159 posts

147 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
CAPP0 said:
megaphone said:
CAPP0 said:
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.
Sounds like there is something wrong with it, take it back.
Hmm, I hadn't considered that. This is my third Mac, so I'm used to how they work & perform. The other two were perfect but this one is really quite frustrating.
Try uninstalling Chrome to see if it improves things. The issue is not specific to M1 Macs - Is Chrome Killing Your MacBook?.

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
jw673 said:
CAPP0 said:
megaphone said:
CAPP0 said:
I damaged my previous MBA which was only a couple of years old and had to buy another. The on-paper specs were much lower for the current Air but I was assured in the shop (John Lewis) that the increased performance of the lower-spec processors was now much better and I wouldn't notice any difference.

Complete bks. This machine, a Core i5 with 8GB RAM and SSD, which is about 2 months old, is like some old Windows donkey compared to my previous MBA. It frequently takes ages to wake up (my old one was instanced every time), it hangs on Safari pages for seemingly-endless amounts of time, it just runs like a dog. I'm hardly a heavy user, I use Office, Outlook, Safari, Chrome and not much else other than occasionally listening to music or viewing PDFs. I'm certainly not editing video or anything like that. Unless you are doing nothing more than a bit of web-based stuff, you need the Pro now I'm afraid.
Sounds like there is something wrong with it, take it back.
Hmm, I hadn't considered that. This is my third Mac, so I'm used to how they work & perform. The other two were perfect but this one is really quite frustrating.
Try uninstalling Chrome to see if it improves things. The issue is not specific to M1 Macs - Is Chrome Killing Your MacBook?.
Thanks, that's interesting. I've just had a poke around and I do indeed have traces of Keystone dotted about, so I've just followed the removal instructions - will give it a few days and report back.

geeks

11,900 posts

170 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
eps said:
geeks said:
Stu-nph26 said:
I have the latest Air and it’s more than enough for what I need. The webcam is poor which is a bit disappointing atm especially as web conferencing is so popular. My previous Air had a much better webcam but other than that this one is superior. Mrs has a pro looks and feels better but haven’t noticed any performance difference.

UNiDAYS prices below

Webcam is equally poor on the pro and the new ones apparently aren't any better which I think is a pretty big oversight!
Although the resolution isn't improved the image sensor is, so not more pixels, but better definition - especially in lower light.
It's still pretty crap though

chml

Original Poster:

741 posts

140 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
Sounds like the Air is the way to go then - had heard good things about the M1 chip and seems to be reaffirmed based on some of the above yes

rat840771

2,028 posts

196 months

Tuesday 15th December 2020
quotequote all
Chrome killed my new Air, both safari and chrome would hang for ages. Deleted chrome and it’s been fine since