Power Bank as a UPS and off-peak "arbitrage"
Power Bank as a UPS and off-peak "arbitrage"
Author
Discussion

clockworks

Original Poster:

7,821 posts

176 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
We have a 23KWh house battery, which isn't quite big enough at this time of year (heat pump).
Gets charged up overnight at 6.6p per KWh.
No gateway, just an EPS socket for power when the grid goes down (3 power cuts so far this year).

Also got a small traditional UPS to keep the router online, but it starts beeping after an hour or so of no grid, and then needs plugging into the EPS socket via an extension lead.

I was looking into a UPS solution that can keep the router, WiFi Mesh master unit, Mini PC running Home Assistant, and the Synology NAS (all located in the understairs cupboard) going during a power cut. Bonus if it can take some of the load off the house battery (recharge from the grid overnight, run the kit off the battery during the day).

We've already got a Bluetti Elite100 (1KWh), so I've been testing the idea with that. It's not really big enough to last 24 hours, but it does work. UPS changeover seems fast enough.

Looking at 2KWh units, the Anker Solix S2000 seems ideal, around £850. Sub 10ms UPS, work mode scheduler, Home Assustant integration, etc. Anything else out there that's cheaper?
The Anker is built for efficiency, rather than peak output, which seems to suit this application.

Edited to add:
A proper gateway for the house battery would be nice, but due to the house wiring and layout, that'll cost £3k

cliffords

4,721 posts

54 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
Good heavens what on earth are you talking about.

Mammasaid

5,665 posts

128 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
Ignore the dinosaur.

Coincidentally, Andrew Til was discussing something very similar today, might be worth a watch.


bunchofkeys

1,312 posts

99 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
There were a couple of threads recently that looked into what you're asking. I cannot remember which one exactly, but take a look at the Stockpile, Solar or Portable battery conversations.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
cliffords said:
Good heavens what on earth are you talking about.
I understand it.

Genuine question; you clearly don't, so why did you take the time to reply, particularly in that tone?

You need to accept that sometimes people will talk about things you don't understand; that's not their fault and doesn't mean they shouldn't post.

clockworks

Original Poster:

7,821 posts

176 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
Ignore the dinosaur.

Coincidentally, Andrew Til was discussing something very similar today, might be worth a watch.

Watching one of his earlier videos is what gave me the idea, and that one got me looking at Anker products.

Condi

20,569 posts

202 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
It's not going to be worth it from a cost saving perspective. 2kwh saves you about 40p a day (assuming a full round trip).

Does it matter if the router stops working? If the power is out for the rest of the house then your PC won't work anyway. I have a very small UPS on my NAS which just means if the power cuts out for 5 mins it doesn't crash, but you'd get more benefit from adding some capacity to your house battery.

clockworks

Original Poster:

7,821 posts

176 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Condi said:
It's not going to be worth it from a cost saving perspective. 2kwh saves you about 40p a day (assuming a full round trip).

Does it matter if the router stops working? If the power is out for the rest of the house then your PC won't work anyway. I have a very small UPS on my NAS which just means if the power cuts out for 5 mins it doesn't crash, but you'd get more benefit from adding some capacity to your house battery.
I'd expect to use just over a KW per day, saving 30 to 40p. Financial payback in around 8 years. This helps justify the cost.

Having Internet during an extended power cut is pretty much essential for us, along with coffee.
During storm Goretti we had multiple power outages over the course of 3 days. This was 2 weeks before the house battery was installed. We got by with a 500WH Jackery power bank and V2L from my Kia. Would've been intolerable without those. A fair bit of juggling to keep stuff running though.

Working Internet and wifi means tablets and phones still work, and can be used for streaming TV etc. as well.

We've already added a second house battery, at a cost of £300 per usable KWh. A power bank will cost a little under £400 per usable KWh, and give us an independent power source.
Adding more house battery capacity would tricky, as we'd have to rejig everything to make space for it.

Edited to add:

We have pretty much zero mobile signal here, so broadband is our only option.



Edited by clockworks on Saturday 7th November 14:40

OutInTheShed

14,977 posts

57 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Probably the cheapest way forwards is to invest in lowering power consumption?

Simplify what you need to keep alive for a long time.

You might be able to use a laptop instead of the mini PC?
Do you need full monty mesh during a power cut?
Could you use a lower power NAS? How badly do you even need the NAS?

If your real basic needs are some kind of internet and wifi calling, you could use a lower power wifi router.
It might be nice to have high speed data to the far corner of the garden, but do you really need that in a power cut?

If you can run everything from 12V, then a couple of hundred quid gets you quite a lot of battery.
100Ah is under £200 now.

clockworks

Original Poster:

7,821 posts

176 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
Probably the cheapest way forwards is to invest in lowering power consumption?

Simplify what you need to keep alive for a long time.

You might be able to use a laptop instead of the mini PC?
Do you need full monty mesh during a power cut?
Could you use a lower power NAS? How badly do you even need the NAS?

If your real basic needs are some kind of internet and wifi calling, you could use a lower power wifi router.
It might be nice to have high speed data to the far corner of the garden, but do you really need that in a power cut?

If you can run everything from 12V, then a couple of hundred quid gets you quite a lot of battery.
100Ah is under £200 now.
Yes, during a long power cut the NAS and mini PC can be shut down, as they wouldn't be needed until the grid got restored. The Mini PC is my Home Assistant server, and the NAS is mostly for Time Machine backups and CCTV recording.
Only planning on keeping the master Mesh node alive, as it has better coverage than the BT Hub's WiFi.
The other mesh nodes are ethernet backhaul to a switch in the loft.

The idea for using a 2KWh portable battery is to give us some extra off-grid power, combined with a UPS for the essentials.
In a real emergency, it could be moved elsewhere in the house, topped up from the car, or even recharged somewhere unaffected by the power cut. Multi-purpose and flexible

cobra kid

5,629 posts

271 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Sounds like a bloke I worked with who put bricks in his cisterns to save water usage. A weird obsession with every penny.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Sounds like a bloke I worked with who put bricks in his cisterns to save water usage. A weird obsession with every penny.
This isn't like that at all.

unzippy

490 posts

269 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Funk said:
cliffords said:
Good heavens what on earth are you talking about.
I understand it.

Genuine question; you clearly don't, so why did you take the time to reply, particularly in that tone?

You need to accept that sometimes people will talk about things you don't understand; that's not their fault and doesn't mean they shouldn't post.
Is it half term - kids allowed on the PC?

clockworks

Original Poster:

7,821 posts

176 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Sounds like a bloke I worked with who put bricks in his cisterns to save water usage. A weird obsession with every penny.
Thing is, this isn't about "saving pennies".

It's several steps that, added together, save £thousands.

Our total energy bill for the house and two cars (at today's prices) would've been around £4800 - electricity, heating oil and petrol.

Switching to a heatpump, getting a house battery, and running two EVs, has dropped that to under £1400 a year - a saving of close to £300 a month.

Yes, it involves some up-front cost - around £11k for the heatpump and batteries. It'll all pay for itself in under 4 years.
The portable power bank idea is the next step.

noyb1966

46 posts

10 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
unzippy said:
Is it half term - kids allowed on the PC?
It seems like it biggrin

clifford's humour is wasted on him.

biggiles

2,194 posts

256 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
If you want it to run 24 hours+, don't run any 240v units. Use the power unit's 12v feed to power the router/ONT/wifi.