RE: New 550hp BMW M4 CS promises 'iconic M feeling'

RE: New 550hp BMW M4 CS promises 'iconic M feeling'

Author
Discussion

Rudolf Hucker

2 posts

9 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Its about 500kg too heavy.....

Mr Tidy

22,606 posts

128 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
And about 20% too big!

I'd really rather have a smaller M2 (and a manual gearbox).

CG2020UK

1,576 posts

41 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
And about 20% too big!

I'd really rather have a smaller M2 (and a manual gearbox).
I don’t think it’s comparable until the M2 CS comes along.

This M4 CS is just a different level of performance and the current M2 is more mini M4 compared to the previous gen were the M2 was the better car.

cerb4.5lee

30,944 posts

181 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Rudolf Hucker said:
Its about 500kg too heavy.....
hehe

What decade are you still in?! biggrin

BMW have only ever made one light(ish) M car, and that was the E30 M3 back in the 80's. However that still only had a poxy 4 cylinder NA engine in it though!(I'd personally take the E30 325i for its 6 cylinder engine over the E30 M3 for example).

HighwayStar

4,334 posts

145 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
And about 20% too big!

I'd really rather have a smaller M2 (and a manual gearbox).
Funny that… that’s what the M2 is for. wink

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
hehe

What decade are you still in?! biggrin

BMW have only ever made one light(ish) M car, and that was the E30 M3 back in the 80's. However that still only had a poxy 4 cylinder NA engine in it though!(I'd personally take the E30 325i for its 6 cylinder engine over the E30 M3 for example).
E46 M3 CSL was under 1400kg IIRC! Peak M3 IMHO (possibly the E92 GTS but it was already getting a bit porky)

Edited by pheonix478 on Thursday 9th May 00:30

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
HighwayStar said:
Mr Tidy said:
And about 20% too big!

I'd really rather have a smaller M2 (and a manual gearbox).
Funny that… that’s what the M2 is for. wink
To be fair the G42 is the new 3 series. The M2 is way bigger than the E30/36/46 M3. It's basically the same size and weight as a V8 E90 M3.

otolith

56,436 posts

205 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
pb8g09 said:
Can you spec it without the lipstick?
BMW must be familiar with the idiom “to put lipstick on a pig”

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
otolith said:
pb8g09 said:
Can you spec it without the lipstick?
BMW must be familiar with the idiom “to put lipstick on a pig”
Someone needs to tell BMW they're supposed to apply the lipstick on the outside to look prettier. Not shove it up their arse.

Edited by pheonix478 on Thursday 9th May 03:20

nismo48

3,799 posts

208 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Ashok said:
Voice activated ventilation - oh FFS. Just make it lighter and prettier please!
Does it get rid of Fart smells wink

Bladedancer

1,298 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Rusty Old-Banger said:
Ken_Code said:
Bladedancer said:
Not really. I prefer proper 223 rem in rifle form rather than an SMG made from a tin can.
What on Earth does that mean?


Some people get a little excited talking about it.
Well done someone finally got it.
In case it needs further explanation, it was a jab at the "M3 > M4" but my miscalculation was the fact that I forgot that Brits will only get references to cars and football and not much else biggrin It might be a sign I'm working too long with Americans.

Edited by Bladedancer on Thursday 9th May 09:36

GeniusOfLove

1,457 posts

13 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
Well done someone finally got it.
In case it needs further explanation, it was a jab at the "M3 > M4" but my miscalculation was the fact that I forgot that Brits will only get references to cars and football and not much else biggrin It might be a sign I'm working too long with Americans.

Edited by Bladedancer on Thursday 9th May 09:36
Or playing too many computer games hehe

greggy50

6,179 posts

192 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Looks a great package but the price seems properly mental.

I have just picked up a brand new M2 with the plus pack for £59k after discount which is half the price of this.

Bladedancer

1,298 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
GeniusOfLove said:
Bladedancer said:
Well done someone finally got it.
In case it needs further explanation, it was a jab at the "M3 > M4" but my miscalculation was the fact that I forgot that Brits will only get references to cars and football and not much else biggrin It might be a sign I'm working too long with Americans.

Edited by Bladedancer on Thursday 9th May 09:36
Or playing too many computer games hehe
So brits don't play those? Dang, most of my mates must be the statistical error then.

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
GeniusOfLove said:
Bladedancer said:
Well done someone finally got it.
In case it needs further explanation, it was a jab at the "M3 > M4" but my miscalculation was the fact that I forgot that Brits will only get references to cars and football and not much else biggrin It might be a sign I'm working too long with Americans.

Edited by Bladedancer on Thursday 9th May 09:36
Or playing too many computer games hehe
So brits don't play those? Dang, most of my mates must be the statistical error then.
Logic fail.

CKY

1,437 posts

16 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
...my miscalculation was the fact that I forgot that Brits will only get references to cars and football and not much else biggrin
Yep - as a matter of fact, this was me the other night:


estoril m3

19 posts

158 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Did you mean M Brooklyn GREY... or have they introduced a NEW M Brooklyn GREEN...????

Terminator X

15,181 posts

205 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
greggy50 said:
Looks a great package but the price seems properly mental.

I have just picked up a brand new M2 with the plus pack for £59k after discount which is half the price of this.
It's half the car though tbf.

TX.

greggy50

6,179 posts

192 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
greggy50 said:
Looks a great package but the price seems properly mental.

I have just picked up a brand new M2 with the plus pack for £59k after discount which is half the price of this.
It's half the car though tbf.

TX.
Having driven both the new M4 Comp and M2 back to back I would strongly disagree unless the CS completely transforms the way the M4 drives.

The M2 and M4 are now very similar underneath (hence the weight) other than the M2 having a shorter wheelbase and being RWD only.

Even the M4 CSL suspension bits are effectively a bolt on part to the M2 (if you wanted)

Personally, I am going to do an Evolve remap to circa. 600bhp (comes with a warranty) and fit coilovers but probably in spring next year once I have had a few months to get used to it...


Edited by greggy50 on Thursday 9th May 17:30

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Thursday 9th May
quotequote all
greggy50 said:
Having driven both the new M4 Comp and M2 back to back I would strongly disagree unless the CS completely transforms the way the M4 drives.

The M2 and M4 are now very similar underneath (hence the weight) other than the M2 having a shorter wheelbase and being RWD only.

Even the M4 CSL suspension bits are effectively a bolt on part to the M2 (if you wanted)

Personally, I am going to do an Evolve remap to circa. 600bhp (comes with a warranty) and fit coilovers but probably in spring next year once I have had a few months to get used to it...


Edited by greggy50 on Thursday 9th May 17:30
My money would 100% go on the M2 also. I haven't driven the newest one but my only gripe about the previous one was the ride was atrocious and felt like it had no suspension at all, I guess if you're talking about coilovers on a brand new car, the new one isn't much better?