Modifying to be illegal?
Modifying to be illegal?
Author
Discussion

NMNeil

5,860 posts

79 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
trails said:
The real question here is if the Gvt has the appetite (and budget) to try and build the processes and frameworks that would enable it to apply the 'stuff' outlined in the proposed legislation to anything other than new vehicles. I suspect (hope) the further they investigate the bigger the can of worms will become...
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.

DodgyGeezer

48,991 posts

219 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.
roflroflrofl

the other problem you'd have with government run places is, quite frankly, incompetence and industrial scale wastage

Digga

48,103 posts

312 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
DodgyGeezer said:
NMNeil said:
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.
roflroflrofl

the other problem you'd have with government run places is, quite frankly, incompetence and industrial scale wastage
You can just see it, with the flexihours, most MOT stations would quickly end up being open 3 days a week from 10-3 with 2 hours for lunch. Just like the EA.

trails

7,213 posts

178 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Digga said:
DodgyGeezer said:
NMNeil said:
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.
roflroflrofl

the other problem you'd have with government run places is, quite frankly, incompetence and industrial scale wastage
You can just see it, with the flexihours, most MOT stations would quickly end up being open 3 days a week from 10-3 with 2 hours for lunch. Just like the EA.
and strikes for better tea biggrin

bigothunter

13,501 posts

89 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
trails said:
Digga said:
DodgyGeezer said:
NMNeil said:
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.
roflroflrofl

the other problem you'd have with government run places is, quite frankly, incompetence and industrial scale wastage
You can just see it, with the flexihours, most MOT stations would quickly end up being open 3 days a week from 10-3 with 2 hours for lunch. Just like the EA.
and strikes for better tea biggrin

EP82

6 posts

223 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
I'm sure its been posted man times previously but you can communicate your objections to these proposals here: https://www.smartsurvey.co.uk/s/ETVHG5/

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
EP82 said:
I'm sure its been posted man times previously but you can communicate your objections to these proposals here: https://www.smartsurvey.co.uk/s/ETVHG5/
Or indeed your support for them, which is what a few friends and I have just done

trails

7,213 posts

178 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
bigothunter said:
Sorry, don't recognise that chap...I'm assuming trade unionist?

aeropilot

40,587 posts

256 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
trails said:
bigothunter said:
Sorry, don't recognise that chap...I'm assuming trade unionist?
Yep, Derek 'Red Robbo' Robinson.


trails

7,213 posts

178 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
Yep, Derek 'Red Robbo' Robinson.
Ta smile

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

284 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Has everybody completed the online "consultation" (cough) questionnaire, then?

NMNeil

5,860 posts

79 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
DodgyGeezer said:
NMNeil said:
It may be uneconomic for the government as the ICE engined car is on it's way out.
Maybe tighten up the MOT, or have government only run testing stations to stamp out the testing fraud.
roflroflrofl

the other problem you'd have with government run places is, quite frankly, incompetence and industrial scale wastage
That used to be my job in Nevada.
Not one of my cases, as I specialized in back street used car lots that had found 'friendly' emissions inspectors, but very similar.
https://www.justice.gov/usao-nv/pr/las-vegas-man-r...

J4CKO

46,821 posts

229 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Just reading this and wondering whether the Sports Cat I spent £500 on and met the MOT requirements will pass, just as KLM flight KL1076 ascends through 3000 feet above me on the way to Amsterdam.

Dont think 737's have Sports Cats, suspect that one ascent used more fuel and emitted more crap than my car will do in two years.

Then you have China, India and whatever belching all manner of crap out but our government want to pick on the small community of car modifiers, they should really perhaps think about all the companies that will affect.

Am all for anything anti social being banned, my car is currently too loud so have fitted an additional silencer.

Anyone who is into banning stuff because they don't have it or don't like it, should really beware as you dont want them getting a taste for it and end up in a sanitized safe space where everything is uniform and there is no scope for expression.

I didn't vote for Brexit but part of that seemed to be around telling the EU to do one with their stupid rulings on matters like Vacuum cleaner power output, hmm you half the power so it produces less emissions, but its st and takes twice as long ffs.

What next, cant build any Lego unless it confirms to the booklet that came with the kit ? Cannot deviate from recipes ? Cant modify clothes ?

Maxdecel

1,917 posts

62 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
.....I didn't vote for Brexit but part of that seemed to be around telling the EU to do one with their stupid rulings on matters like Vacuum cleaner power output, hmm you half the power so it produces less emissions, but its st and takes twice as long ffs.
What next, cant build any Lego unless it confirms to the booklet that came with the kit ? Cannot deviate from recipes ? Cant modify clothes ?
Not forgetting the Vnuk ruling mad Only just dodged that.

trails

7,213 posts

178 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Just reading this and wondering whether the Sports Cat I spent £500 on and met the MOT requirements will pass, just as KLM flight KL1076 ascends through 3000 feet above me on the way to Amsterdam.

Dont think 737's have Sports Cats, suspect that one ascent used more fuel and emitted more crap than my car will do in two years.

Then you have China, India and whatever belching all manner of crap out but our government want to pick on the small community of car modifiers, they should really perhaps think about all the companies that will affect.

Am all for anything anti social being banned, my car is currently too loud so have fitted an additional silencer.

Anyone who is into banning stuff because they don't have it or don't like it, should really beware as you dont want them getting a taste for it and end up in a sanitized safe space where everything is uniform and there is no scope for expression.

I didn't vote for Brexit but part of that seemed to be around telling the EU to do one with their stupid rulings on matters like Vacuum cleaner power output, hmm you half the power so it produces less emissions, but its st and takes twice as long ffs.

What next, cant build any Lego unless it confirms to the booklet that came with the kit ? Cannot deviate from recipes ? Cant modify clothes ?
Perhaps Mercscott and his friends can answer those questions. I suspect not though.

colinbloom

21 posts

63 months

Tuesday 16th November 2021
quotequote all
This Banning culture is really depressing. The world seems to be full of spiteful intolerant people who love anything they consider an inconvenience to be banned, right up to the point where it inconveniences’ them. It’s such a shame that people’s freedoms are being destroyed and it’s so final, such a one way street. Once things are banned, within a generation, society accepts it as the norm and they can never be reversed. Every ban serves to normalise the banning ideology, and so legitimising the next one, albeit with ever decreasing purpose or necessity.
When a new ban is first mentioned, it is often met with outrage, (Newspapers reporting ‘Have you heard what they are trying to do? How dare they!’) But once it’s been in force for a while, society finds it outrageous that it ever used to be allowed!
I know some bans have been right and necessary, I just don’t like the momentum being gained. As J4CKO said “people get a taste for it”. The powers then start rolling out bans willy-nilly and the people roll over.

NMNeil

5,860 posts

79 months

Tuesday 16th November 2021
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Just reading this and wondering whether the Sports Cat I spent £500 on and met the MOT requirements will pass, just as KLM flight KL1076 ascends through 3000 feet above me on the way to Amsterdam.

Dont think 737's have Sports Cats, suspect that one ascent used more fuel and emitted more crap than my car will do in two years.

Then you have China, India and whatever belching all manner of crap out but our government want to pick on the small community of car modifiers, they should really perhaps think about all the companies that will affect.
And another posting along the lines of, "He's polluting more than me, so I should be exempt from the law because my car only pollutes a little bit"


DodgyGeezer

48,991 posts

219 months

Tuesday 16th November 2021
quotequote all
colinbloom said:
This Banning culture is really depressing. The world seems to be full of spiteful intolerant people who love anything they consider an inconvenience to be banned, right up to the point where it inconveniences’ them. It’s such a shame that people’s freedoms are being destroyed and it’s so final, such a one way street. Once things are banned, within a generation, society accepts it as the norm and they can never be reversed. Every ban serves to normalise the banning ideology, and so legitimising the next one, albeit with ever decreasing purpose or necessity.
When a new ban is first mentioned, it is often met with outrage, (Newspapers reporting ‘Have you heard what they are trying to do? How dare they!’) But once it’s been in force for a while, society finds it outrageous that it ever used to be allowed!
I know some bans have been right and necessary, I just don’t like the momentum being gained. As J4CKO said “people get a taste for it”. The powers then start rolling out bans willy-nilly and the people roll over.
spot on

njw1

2,776 posts

140 months

Tuesday 16th November 2021
quotequote all
DodgyGeezer said:
colinbloom said:
This Banning culture is really depressing. The world seems to be full of spiteful intolerant people who love anything they consider an inconvenience to be banned, right up to the point where it inconveniences’ them. It’s such a shame that people’s freedoms are being destroyed and it’s so final, such a one way street. Once things are banned, within a generation, society accepts it as the norm and they can never be reversed. Every ban serves to normalise the banning ideology, and so legitimising the next one, albeit with ever decreasing purpose or necessity.
When a new ban is first mentioned, it is often met with outrage, (Newspapers reporting ‘Have you heard what they are trying to do? How dare they!’) But once it’s been in force for a while, society finds it outrageous that it ever used to be allowed!
I know some bans have been right and necessary, I just don’t like the momentum being gained. As J4CKO said “people get a taste for it”. The powers then start rolling out bans willy-nilly and the people roll over.
spot on
Before we know it we'll be living in a place like that city on Demolition Man where you can't even swear or have a shag.... rolleyes

aeropilot

40,587 posts

256 months

Tuesday 16th November 2021
quotequote all
njw1 said:
DodgyGeezer said:
colinbloom said:
This Banning culture is really depressing. The world seems to be full of spiteful intolerant people who love anything they consider an inconvenience to be banned, right up to the point where it inconveniences’ them. It’s such a shame that people’s freedoms are being destroyed and it’s so final, such a one way street. Once things are banned, within a generation, society accepts it as the norm and they can never be reversed. Every ban serves to normalise the banning ideology, and so legitimising the next one, albeit with ever decreasing purpose or necessity.
When a new ban is first mentioned, it is often met with outrage, (Newspapers reporting ‘Have you heard what they are trying to do? How dare they!’) But once it’s been in force for a while, society finds it outrageous that it ever used to be allowed!
I know some bans have been right and necessary, I just don’t like the momentum being gained. As J4CKO said “people get a taste for it”. The powers then start rolling out bans willy-nilly and the people roll over.
spot on
Before we know it we'll be living in a place like that city on Demolition Man where you can't even swear or have a shag.... rolleyes
Will be like it was living in East Germany 60 years ago...... all we need is someone to build a wall.