When does whiplash fraud become a matter for the Police?
Discussion
About a month ago a friend was involved in a very; very minor road traffic collision. She rolled back at a set of traffic lights as the lights were changing and her Nissan Micra nudged a Mercedes Sprinter van. Witnesses say the van was moving forward and both drivers were at fault but the van driver has told his insurers the car was in reverse and he was stationary. There was no damage to either vehicle involved at the scene (no photographs as it was a busy road and only details were exchanged) but now the van needs a new bumper, valance, radiator and bonnet. 
The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.
Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?

The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.

Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?
Liquid Knight said:
Pothole said:
his makes no sense. What do you mean?
They're considering paying out. The longer they wait the higher the claim appears to get with "doctors" bills and "legal consultation" fees being added on every bloody week. They want to cut and run. Liquid Knight said:
About a month ago a friend was involved in a very; very minor road traffic collision. She rolled back at a set of traffic lights as the lights were changing and her Nissan Micra nudged a Mercedes Sprinter van. Witnesses say the van was moving forward and both drivers were at fault but the van driver has told his insurers the car was in reverse and he was stationary. There was no damage to either vehicle involved at the scene (no photographs as it was a busy road and only details were exchanged) but now the van needs a new bumper, valance, radiator and bonnet. 
The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.
Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?
I think your friend was mistaken.
The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.

Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?
Surely, the van driver moved forward, striking your stationary friend thereby causing extreme neck trauma. He hit your friend from behind, he = 100% responsible.
After all, that is basically what he is doing to your friend - adjusting the truth to suit his own ends and make your friend responsive/get an easy pay out.
Dangerous Dan said:
Liquid Knight said:
About a month ago a friend was involved in a very; very minor road traffic collision. She rolled back at a set of traffic lights as the lights were changing and her Nissan Micra nudged a Mercedes Sprinter van. Witnesses say the van was moving forward and both drivers were at fault but the van driver has told his insurers the car was in reverse and he was stationary. There was no damage to either vehicle involved at the scene (no photographs as it was a busy road and only details were exchanged) but now the van needs a new bumper, valance, radiator and bonnet. 
The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.
Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?
I think your friend was mistaken.
The driver of the van has also put in a claim for a suspected whiplash injury.

Her insurance company are stood fast and ready to cave in. If this case is passed on for the Police to investigate as fraud will it go anywhere?
Surely, the van driver moved forward, striking your stationary friend thereby causing extreme neck trauma. He hit your friend from behind, he = 100% responsible.
After all, that is basically what he is doing to your friend - adjusting the truth to suit his own ends and make your friend responsive/get an easy pay out.
Streaky
Liquid Knight said:
(no photographs as it was a busy road and only details were exchanged)
Personally I wouldn't care how busy the road was: I'd be taking at least one picture of the (lack of) damage to both vehicles. It would take a few seconds, and could have provided vital evidence.Edited by Dr Mike Oxgreen on Sunday 30th December 08:52
ging84 said:
no damage, no injuries
why were details exchanged if it really was as minor as this?
why were details exchanged if it really was as minor as this?
accident description said:
She rolled back at a set of traffic lights as the lights were changing and her Nissan Micra nudged a Mercedes Sprinter van...
Female ignorance/panic + intimidating angry builder = spurious whiplash claim. BINGO![/sweeping generalisation]In answer to the thread title:
when the quantum of the proposed payout is greater than the legal and admin costs of arguing about it, or when a member of one of the legal teams involved notices discrepancies in significant material facts?
The bar is set pretty high, and it's usually cheaper (and less hassle) to just put it on the production line and pay out at the end of the process
.
A neighbour was claiming £30k for 'injuries' in a car accident, and only a member of one of the legal teams spotting that the car which caused the accident wasn't physically capable of being driven due to a mechanical failure a few days before meant that the matter was referred to the police. Six people were sent to prison on the back of this muppetry, and had this 'error' not been spotted then all eight people involved in this fake accident would have been significantly better off financially...
The bar is set pretty high, the above is an example. Don't make silly fundamental errors in your evidence and you'll be fine
!
when the quantum of the proposed payout is greater than the legal and admin costs of arguing about it, or when a member of one of the legal teams involved notices discrepancies in significant material facts?
The bar is set pretty high, and it's usually cheaper (and less hassle) to just put it on the production line and pay out at the end of the process
. A neighbour was claiming £30k for 'injuries' in a car accident, and only a member of one of the legal teams spotting that the car which caused the accident wasn't physically capable of being driven due to a mechanical failure a few days before meant that the matter was referred to the police. Six people were sent to prison on the back of this muppetry, and had this 'error' not been spotted then all eight people involved in this fake accident would have been significantly better off financially...
The bar is set pretty high, the above is an example. Don't make silly fundamental errors in your evidence and you'll be fine
!Dr Mike Oxgreen said:
Liquid Knight said:
(no photographs as it was a busy road and only details were exchanged)
Personally I wouldn't care how busy the road was: I'd be taking at least one picture of the (lack of) damage to both vehicles. It would take a few seconds, and could have provided vital evidence.Edited by Dr Mike Oxgreen on Sunday 30th December 08:52
Streaky
Edited by streaky on Sunday 30th December 16:52
Steve H said:
More like, what's good for the goose...............
No doubt this and 90% of all whiplash claims are fraud but as the insurance industry are putting their heads in the sand about it I don't imagine there will be much police interest.
Could you make up your mind please. No doubt this and 90% of all whiplash claims are fraud but as the insurance industry are putting their heads in the sand about it I don't imagine there will be much police interest.
I thought people believed that insurers don't like paying out. Or that they do?
Perhaps you don't understand the basics despite them being recited time and time again on this forum. A claim is a civil matter between drivers. One driver alleges they suffered loss (injury) and documents it with medical evidence. The other driver may well dispute it, and asks their insurer to deal with the matter.
If the insurer refuses to pay out on the basis of this evidence, then the third party has the right to have the matter heard by a binding neutral authoriy, ie a Judge at a Court, to rule on who is or isnt right in the dispute. Regrettably at the moment, things are a little biased andone sided - a judge is likely to find on the balance of probabilities, the claim for injury is proven - the result of which is, an insurer is "compelled" under the Road Traffic Act to pay out, on receipt of an unsatisfied judgement against an identified driver on a vehicle they cover. So they pay before hand, to save £10k legal fees that the third party would incur in issuing proceedings and obtaining a judgement . They would prefer to settle early for say £5k, rather than £15k.
If you dont like it, tough - the system is one sided, biased, and its AMC's, Medical Experts, Engineers, and Judges who perpetuate the whole damn thing, not insurers.
streaky said:
As has been pointed out several times in 'minor bump' threads, damage can occur under the skin and not be evident of the surface.
Streaky
That's a very good point. Streaky
I'll get her to take the car to a Nissan dealer. Maybe ask them (in their expert opinions) to take the bumper off and inspect it for any possible damage providing photographic evidence that the bumper has not been tampered with before (photo's of mucky screws and fixings etc). If the lack of damage to her car can be proven it could be enough to show the damage done to the van happened in a separate incident. There's no way structural damage could occur to a two Ton van without causing significant damage to her 800Kg Micra.
I'll also ask to see if there was CCTV at the traffic lights and/or properties surrounding it. We only need one second of footage of the van driving away unscathed to drop this guy where he belongs.
I'll keep you posted.
Jujuuk68 said:
Steve H said:
More like, what's good for the goose...............
No doubt this and 90% of all whiplash claims are fraud but as the insurance industry are putting their heads in the sand about it I don't imagine there will be much police interest.
Could you make up your mind please. No doubt this and 90% of all whiplash claims are fraud but as the insurance industry are putting their heads in the sand about it I don't imagine there will be much police interest.
I thought people believed that insurers don't like paying out. Or that they do?
Perhaps you don't understand the basics despite them being recited time and time again on this forum. A claim is a civil matter between drivers. One driver alleges they suffered loss (injury) and documents it with medical evidence. The other driver may well dispute it, and asks their insurer to deal with the matter.
If the insurer refuses to pay out on the basis of this evidence, then the third party has the right to have the matter heard by a binding neutral authoriy, ie a Judge at a Court, to rule on who is or isnt right in the dispute. Regrettably at the moment, things are a little biased andone sided - a judge is likely to find on the balance of probabilities, the claim for injury is proven - the result of which is, an insurer is "compelled" under the Road Traffic Act to pay out, on receipt of an unsatisfied judgement against an identified driver on a vehicle they cover. So they pay before hand, to save £10k legal fees that the third party would incur in issuing proceedings and obtaining a judgement . They would prefer to settle early for say £5k, rather than £15k.
If you dont like it, tough - the system is one sided, biased, and its AMC's, Medical Experts, Engineers, and Judges who perpetuate the whole damn thing, not insurers.
Civil cases aren't "likely" to be decided on the balance of probabilities, that IS how they are decided - it's how the system works, nobodies liberty is at stake so the most likely scenario wins. Given that the insurance companies aren't fighting (the majority) of whiplash cases it's hardly likely that the police wouldn't take them on as fraud when they have to prove the same case beyond reasonable doubt to get a win.
The civil system isn't one sided, it's designed to be entirely neutral (unlike the criminal with it's presumption of innocence). On a case by case basis, the insurance companies find it easier to settle than to fight but the whole compensation industry relies on this which perpetuates the entire problem and increases our premiums.
If they had the foresight to fight a few more cases there would be a lot less of them in future.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




k and insurance company will agree 50/50 eventually which is why peeps make whiplash claims.