Moving Traffic Offence, Hammersmith and Fulham, with video
Moving Traffic Offence, Hammersmith and Fulham, with video
Author
Discussion

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Here's one for you...

On 10th June I was travelling in Hammersmith (Butterwick, for those who might know it). I was heading from the A4 towards Fulham, so had to swing right at some traffic lights, across a box junction, and underneath the A4, heading at that moment, in a westerly direction.

I was in the nearside lane.

The video of the incident is here (I'm in the red C1)...

http://www.viewmypcn.co.uk/Default.aspx?r=7b60cf97...

The silver BMW Compact and the dark Focus in front of me at the box junction had both been in the lane to my offside at the lights. When the lights turned green, my exit to the box junction was clear. However, both the BMW and the Focus moved across out of lane in front of me and took my space. To avoid a collision, I had to concede the position and let them in front of me. As a result, I ended up stuck in the box junction.

Now, I know no moving traffic offence was committed (well, not by me but certainly by the BMW and Focus).

Interestingly, I had thought there might be a camera of the junction, as it seemed an obvious hot spot. As such, I wrote to Hammersmith & Fulham via email on the 12th June asking if my VRN was subject to any PCNs. They replied the same day saying there were none.

Today, I receive an email from H&F rejecting my 'appeal' and attach a letter with a valid PCN number. I looked online using the PCN number and found the above video.

It's obvious my asking effectively 'farmed' the offence.


Gone Bananas

24 posts

165 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
I shall be reading with interest the advice you get on this. I had the same thing happen to me yesterday in London. You don't deserve a ticket, i hope you manage to get off the penalty charge.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Was your exit from the box clear ? (ignoring what the other two vehicles were doing).

http://yellowboxjunction.co.uk/Yellow-Box-Junction...

SegueUK

71 posts

162 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
From what he's saying, it was until they cut him up.

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
marshalla said:
Was your exit from the box clear ? (ignoring what the other two vehicles were doing).

http://yellowboxjunction.co.uk/Yellow-Box-Junction...
Yes, it was. The allegation is defective for the simple reason that the exit was clear when I entered. It is also defective because neither the video evidence nor the photographs show me entering the box junction.

There was not a PCN issued originally because of this.

A PCN was issued AFTER I wrote to them asking if they had issued a PCN for a moving traffic offence against my VRN.

You may be wondering why I did this; it is because I moved recently, the V5 has not yet been updated and any PCN would go to my old address to which I have no access. I thought it better to be proactive and approach them, rather than defend a PCN that has gone beyond its appeal date and is into debt collection. Sadly, they used it as a reason to go hunting and to look for an 'offence'.

Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Firstly, absolutely incredible that you get a fine for being in a yellow box. I've generally never heard of this before. Perhaps only down in England are not Scotland?

Secondly, I hehe at you looking at the camera.

Thirdly, I would completely agree with challenging your ticket. Madness. Can't believe some Monkey sits there and manually looks at people "breaking the law" complete waste of time and man power IMO.

Terminator X

21,023 posts

235 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
If you're moving you're ok though even if it is just creeping along. Were you stopped at all as I can't tell from the linked stills?

TX.

PS This sort of thing (from CCTV operators) is right at the scum end of traffic offences imho and is the main reason why we should all do everything possible to stop further automatic monitoring of the motorist (CCTV, ANPR, black boxes etc).

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
If you look above the stills, there's a 'video' button. View the video and make your own mind up!

Terminator X

21,023 posts

235 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Mr Trophy said:
Firstly, absolutely incredible that you get a fine for being in a yellow box. I've generally never heard of this before. Perhaps only down in England are not Scotland?

Secondly, I hehe at you looking at the camera.

Thirdly, I would completely agree with challenging your ticket. Madness. Can't believe some Monkey sits there and manually looks at people "breaking the law" complete waste of time and man power IMO.
4.5k posts on here and you don't realize that this is how they generate income?!

TX.

SegueUK

71 posts

162 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
I don't see how they can get you for that, isn't the rule specifically you should not enter the yellow box if your exit isn't clear?

When you entered the box your exit was clear, it was only after that it was blocked off by something beyond your control. It's like prosecuting you for entering a yellow box to turn right, about as legal as well.

I think the people over at www.pepipoo.com would have a field day with it, especially video. I think their success rate with PCNs is much higher than NIP/FCN etc as councils are more likely to back down than the courts!

Good luck!

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
It's a fishing exercise: they think I think I've committed an offence. They think that because on the 12th June I sent them an email saying:

10 Pence Short said:
I have recently moved address and the DVLA address details may be out of date, so I will not receive postal PCNs. I believe I may have been seen supposedly committing a moving traffic offence. Please advise if a PCN has been issued against the above vehicle.

BMWBen

4,906 posts

232 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Appeal.

They will reject.

Appeal again.

They will reject.

Go to the TFL adjudicator.

You will win.

Terminator X

21,023 posts

235 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
If you look above the stills, there's a 'video' button. View the video and make your own mind up!
Well you were stationary for <10s, is that really considered to be stopped? Perhaps it is. For next time just reverse backwards and forwards slightly as you're then moving which is no offence afaik.

TX.

PS FYI from the ticketfighter website:

"The offence as stated in the regs ... is “no person shall cause a vehicle to enter the box junction so that the vehicle has to stop within the box junction due to the presence of stationary vehicles” It is therefore committed when you enter the box. So if circumstances afterwards change, such as a vehicle changing lanes and blocking your exit, the ticket is invalid"

"The authority must have video evidence of your vehicle when it enters the box ... and stopped and this evidence must show also that the exit was not clear when you entered"

http://ticketfighter.co.uk/yellow-box-junctions/

skeggysteve

5,724 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
It looked like you couldn't see the exit of the yellow box due to the box van to your right but as the traffic was moving it seems only right to assume that there wouldn't be a problem.

Interesting that a blue car also stopped in the yellow box before you did but the CCTV operator didn't zoom in on them. So why did they zoom in on you?

Also interesting that they have all this technology just to hand out fines!

Sadly I think your right Dan, you alerted them and they took advantage. But I hope you fight it and win.

Like the number plate!

Piersman2

6,676 posts

230 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
It's a fishing exercise: they think I think I've committed an offence. They think that because on the 12th June I sent them an email saying:

10 Pence Short said:
I have recently moved address and the DVLA address details may be out of date, so I will not receive postal PCNs. I believe I may have been seen supposedly committing a moving traffic offence. Please advise if a PCN has been issued against the above vehicle.
^^^^ Madness!! laugh

I have an image of a donkey jumping around behind everyone else shouting: "Pick me, pick me!" smile

CoolHands

23,720 posts

226 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
you keep saying its a fishing exercise but I disagree. I imagine its simply the time delay between your enquiry and the lawbreakers ( wink ) being sorted. You're emails crossed in the post, as it were.

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
It looked like you couldn't see the exit of the yellow box due to the box van to your right.

Like the number plate!
Thanks, Steve. smile

I could see the exit when the lights turned green, as I could see past the van when I was stationary (out of shot). I've used the junction a couple of times before and knew the box junction was a bh, so I made sure I entered it only when the exit was clear. It was just the BMW and Focus that fecked my plans.

s p a c e m a n

12,167 posts

179 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
This is what pisses me off about the cameras, how are you supposed to get through that junction without stopping? If you stop before entering then everyone will just cut across into your lane and you will not have a clear exit until the lights change. It should only be an offence if you are stationary in the box when the lights change.

SmoothCriminal

5,983 posts

230 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Dont want to play devils advocate but Looking at the video your exit wasn't even clear when you enter the box junction even if the focus wasn't there you'd still be in the box and to me looks like the bm was in your lane to start with.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Here's one for you...

On 10th June I was travelling in Hammersmith (Butterwick, for those who might know it). I was heading from the A4 towards Fulham, so had to swing right at some traffic lights, across a box junction, and underneath the A4, heading at that moment, in a westerly direction.

I was in the nearside lane.

The video of the incident is here (I'm in the red C1)...

http://www.viewmypcn.co.uk/Default.aspx?r=7b60cf97...

The silver BMW Compact and the dark Focus in front of me at the box junction had both been in the lane to my offside at the lights. When the lights turned green, my exit to the box junction was clear. However, both the BMW and the Focus moved across out of lane in front of me and took my space. To avoid a collision, I had to concede the position and let them in front of me. As a result, I ended up stuck in the box junction.

Now, I know no moving traffic offence was committed (well, not by me but certainly by the BMW and Focus).

Interestingly, I had thought there might be a camera of the junction, as it seemed an obvious hot spot. As such, I wrote to Hammersmith & Fulham via email on the 12th June asking if my VRN was subject to any PCNs. They replied the same day saying there were none.

Today, I receive an email from H&F rejecting my 'appeal' and attach a letter with a valid PCN number. I looked online using the PCN number and found the above video.

It's obvious my asking effectively 'farmed' the offence.
My information comes from when such niceties were part of my role, this around 1999/2000. It may well have changed but I don't see why.

The 'don't enter box junction unless your exit is clear' is not the offence. It is what the HC has suggested as a method of avoiding the commission of the offence. The offence is being stationary in a box junction. From what I can see you were, quite clearly, stationary.

Whether you have the defence of force majeur is rather moot as 'they' might suggest that you should have realised that another vehicle might obstruct you. You could, perhaps, use the HC suggestion but it is not a defence.