Guide dogs being attacked
Author
Discussion

e600

Original Poster:

1,522 posts

183 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
I note from the news that there has been a steep rise in cases of guide dogs being attacked by dogs. The police and other authorities are calling for all dogs to be micro chipped. Which is fine and may lead back to the dog owner if not present at the scene of the attack.

Would in not be better to have a law that insists on dogs being muzzled when in public, then such attacks including those on people/ children simply can't happen.

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
e600 said:
I note from the news that there has been a steep rise in cases of guide dogs being attacked by dogs. The police and other authorities are calling for all dogs to be micro chipped. Which is fine and may lead back to the dog owner if not present at the scene of the attack.

Would in not be better to have a law that insists on dogs being muzzled when in public, then such attacks including those on people/ children simply can't happen.
How many attacks compared to how many dogs out there I wonder.

If implemented, it would be totally unenforceable though.

HowMuchLonger

3,041 posts

224 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
are you really suggesting that all dogs should be muzzled? How would you muzzle a snub nosed dog?

We should also ban all people from driving because some people crash.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
e600 said:
Would in not be better to have a law that insists on dogs being muzzled when in public, then such attacks including those on people/ children simply can't happen.
I think more people are injured by humans each week, so perhaps we should muzzle and handcuff everyone in public. Can't be too careful now.


carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
furiousfurious

http://www.thisisthewestcountry.co.uk/news/cornwal...

'After a short struggle Nigel and the owner of the loose animal, described as a “staffie” or pit bull type breed by the police, managed to shut it inside - but the damage had already been done.'

'Anyone who knows anything about the attack can contact the police on 101 ref GP/13/948.'

confused

What more information do they need? Seems like an open and shut case to me.

We just need something that replaces the Dangerous Dogs Act with something as malleable as section 59 but for dogs?

heners54

286 posts

170 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
I think more reasonably all dogs should be on a lead when in a public place, this is the practice we have adopted with our current rescue dog as he can growl at other dogs in the park (he does it defensively after being attacked, really he's a softie and its all hot air), which sometimes makes other dogs have a go at him. Worst case was a large whippet type dog ran at him and I lifted him up by the harness and put him under my arm, when the dog scrabbled up me still trying to attack I shoved it away till the owned caught up, 'he/she's never like that' 'your dog caused that, he's nasty'. He was under control, under my arm, so do one.

If a dog is on a lead with a harness then it is under control, if it can overpower it's owner when in this position then are they a suitable owner? As said above the dogs behaviour is the responsibility of the owner and they should manage their dog accordingly and choose a suitable breed.

Edited by heners54 on Saturday 6th July 21:11

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
HowMuchLonger said:
How would you muzzle a snub nosed dog?
There are muzzles for dogs such as Boxers. They remind me of WW2 gas masks.

Streaky

HowMuchLonger

3,041 posts

224 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
HowMuchLonger said:
How would you muzzle a snub nosed dog?
There are muzzles for dogs such as Boxers. They remind me of WW2 gas masks.

Streaky
I was thinking more about pugs and shih tzus.

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
It's irresponsible mongs who walk their dogs upon the public highways off the lead in the minor belief that the dog is under their control as it walks alongside them. They haven't a clue that it is the law to have your dog on a lead in a public place.

How does this get solved? Worst case destroy the dog, but probably better to have the owner put down and the dog retrained.

For the record. I am a dog owner and former guide dog puppy walker.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
DrDeAtH said:
It's irresponsible mongs who walk their dogs upon the public highways off the lead in the minor belief that the dog is under their control as it walks alongside them. They haven't a clue that it is the law to have your dog on a lead in a public place.
Is it?

heners54

286 posts

170 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
DrDeAtH said:
It's irresponsible mongs who walk their dogs upon the public highways off the lead in the minor belief that the dog is under their control as it walks alongside them. They haven't a clue that it is the law to have your dog on a lead in a public place.
Is it?
I would agree with that, allowing a dog to walk freely creates opportunities for it to attack another dog/child etc, be that uncharacteristic or not. And as I said earlier having a dog on the lead can help protect the animal in a reversed situation. Is having a scared dog run away on to a carriageway not in part the fault of the owner whatever the circumstances?

9mm

3,128 posts

241 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
heners54 said:
I think more reasonably all dogs should be on a lead when in a public place

Edited by heners54 on Saturday 6th July 21:11
I want to agree with this and then I think of the millions of dogs that are well socialised and are great with other dogs and people. It's unfair to penalise and inconvenience the overwhelming majority.

As always, it's a small percentage of owners and dogs that are the problem and I would suggest a slight adjustment to the proposal which would be that all dogs should be on the lead when on streets or public footways. A nice £250 on the spot fine (dog confiscation if you haven't got the money) would be a good deterrent and it would be easy enough to enforce. I'd combine it with compulsory micro chipping of all dogs, with similarly stiff penalties for non-compliance.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
As an owner of a staffie, it's the damn mongy owners who bring them up to be nasty that are at fault. Ours has never been allowed to act like that & gets bullied by my mum's Yorki, which is funny to watch. I don't argree with muzzling dogs in public, the way ours slobbers & drools when she's hot, she'd probably drown hehe Letting your dog off the lead in the park should always be allowed, you just need to train it. The same as anything else around animals, it always comes back to the owner.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
HowMuchLonger said:
streaky said:
HowMuchLonger said:
How would you muzzle a snub nosed dog?
There are muzzles for dogs such as Boxers. They remind me of WW2 gas masks.

Streaky
I was thinking more about pugs and shih tzus.
Here you go.

Streaky

iphonedyou

10,425 posts

188 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
e600 said:
I note from the news that there has been a steep rise in cases of guide dogs being attacked by dogs. The police and other authorities are calling for all dogs to be micro chipped. Which is fine and may lead back to the dog owner if not present at the scene of the attack.

Would in not be better to have a law that insists on dogs being muzzled when in public, then such attacks including those on people/ children simply can't happen.
I don't see why all dogs should be muzzled because of the actions of a few. Feel free to disagree - and you probably will - but I'm quite sure my Labrador will never attack anybody, or my Golden Retriever before her. And that's why they were, and are never muzzled.

Fubar1977

919 posts

171 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
Vajazzle said:
It's not the dog at fault, it's the bloody owners that need sorting!
Quoted for truth.
Abolishing the old "Dog License" was stupid, Chipping should be mandatory.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
Fubar1977 said:
Chipping should be mandatory.
But my dog can run faster than me already, will it save on food costs? wink

static2010

430 posts

169 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
Hooli said:
As an owner of a staffie, it's the damn mongy owners who bring them up to be nasty that are at fault. Ours has never been allowed to act like that & gets bullied by my mum's Yorki, which is funny to watch. I don't argree with muzzling dogs in public, the way ours slobbers & drools when she's hot, she'd probably drown hehe Letting your dog off the lead in the park should always be allowed, you just need to train it. The same as anything else around animals, it always comes back to the owner.
^^^This^^^
Pretty much sums it up.

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
HowMuchLonger said:
are you really suggesting that all dogs should be muzzled? How would you muzzle a snub nosed dog?

We should also ban all people from driving because some people crash.
There is form for just such an approach!

All manner of laws and restrictions are enacted because of the attitude that you should legislate for the lowest common denominator.
Speed limits, gun control, to name but two, as well as the dangerous dogs laws all required in law because a minority of people abuse the previously less stringent rules/laws.

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Sunday 7th July 2013
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
There is form for just such an approach!

All manner of laws and restrictions are enacted because of the attitude that you should legislate for the lowest common denominator.
Speed limits, gun control, to name but two, as well as the dangerous dogs laws all required in law because a minority of people abuse the previously less stringent rules/laws.
Simple answer: Take it out on the few law abusing idiot minority not the law abiding majority. In all cases.