RE: Driving with Google Glass to be illegal
RE: Driving with Google Glass to be illegal
Friday 2nd August 2013

Driving with Google Glass to be illegal

Govnt ban looms for eyeware, but won't the 'Glassholes' be safer than today's texting twits?



The interactive eyewear that is Google Glass hasn't even gone on sale yet, but the Government is aiming to ban the use of it while driving.

A spokesperson from the Department for Transport has told Stuff Magazine: "We are aware of the impending rollout of Google Glass and are in discussion with the Police to ensure that individuals do not use this technology while driving. It is important that drivers give their full attention to the road when they are behind the wheel and do not behave in a way that stops them from observing what is happening on the road."

Is this as distracting as a mobile?
Is this as distracting as a mobile?
It's now ten years since the mobile phone ban came in, and the justification for the potential outlawing of Glass is similar. The issue is around compromising driver concentration, but some have argued Glass is probably more hands-free than a lot of Bluetooth devices and arguably less distracting than a sat-nav or other infotainment.

On sale next year for an estimated £1000, Glass allows you to perform Google searches and scour social media, which if done while driving would surely distract from the road ahead. But then it could also be used to provide directions that wouldn't need the extended eye-flick down to the screen while voice activation would let you reprogramme more safely. Here's where the divide lies; when does Glass go from a driver's tool to a distraction?

Furthermore, outlawing Google Glass for drivers will prevent the development of interesting apps like GlassTesla, which seems a shame.

On one hand we're glad that the potential problem is being recognised, but we're also concerned that the Government will be blind to the positive uses. As Stuff says, 'Glassholes' might be a lot safer than today's texting morons.

Source: Stuff

Author
Discussion

Vipers

Original Poster:

33,525 posts

259 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Seems obvious to me that it will be banned, now just waiting for all the comments why it's safe!




smile

16v stretch

990 posts

188 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
When they start looking like a regular pair of glasses, how would enforcement take place?

Beanoir

1,327 posts

226 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Seems a silly idea to me, until cars drive themselves (a sad day that will be) products like this just seem a bit pointless given the obvious dangers.

contractor

922 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
It will be interesting to see how the law is worded here. I know that watching a TV in the car while driving is banned but what about those cars with integrated head up displays.

I know this is more akin to a smartphone in terms of functionality, but using a smartphone is not covered by under existing mobile phone law if it is not held in the hand during use.

Surely it would be easier to just cover it under existing due care legislation?

KeithR

212 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
FFS! How is it any less distracting than simply talking to your passenger? So in order to drive safely, we must be completely transfixed to the road without talking like possessed robots?!

What a nanny state we live in today!

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Doubtful that new legislation will be passed.

Existing law covers driver not in proper control or careless driving (known as DWDCA on this forum).


Dazed & Confused

209 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
KeithR said:
What a nanny state we live in today!
Not sure if serious....

If, in the unlikely event that you really are the Daily Mail in human form, I suppose you'd be totally happy for me to be behind you in the fast lane while I'm playing Angry Birds....

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 2nd August 11:15

Monty Zoomer

1,459 posts

188 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
KeithR said:
FFS! How is it any less distracting than simply talking to your passenger? So in order to drive safely, we must be completely transfixed to the road without talking like possessed robots?!

What a nanny state we live in today!
What?


otolith

69,785 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
AR glasses could be a fantastic tool for making driving better in all kinds of ways. Luddite knee jerk reaction wins out rolleyes

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
KeithR said:
FFS! How is it any less distracting than simply talking to your passenger? So in order to drive safely, we must be completely transfixed to the road without talking like possessed robots?!

What a nanny state we live in today!
Maybe sarcasm.
Maybe that the poster doesn't understand what the glasses are and has mistaken them for a Bluetooth headset.

Dazed & Confused

209 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
otolith said:
AR glasses could be a fantastic tool for making driving better in all kinds of ways. Luddite knee jerk reaction wins out rolleyes
Yes - because it wouldn't be abused at all now, would it. I mean the internet is provided at work so that people can be more productive, yet Pistonheads' comments sections still seem to fill up quite nicely between 9 and 5....

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 2nd August 11:26

Dazed & Confused

209 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Double post - sorry. Stupid IE8.

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 2nd August 11:26

KeithR

212 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
KeithR said:
FFS! How is it any less distracting than simply talking to your passenger? So in order to drive safely, we must be completely transfixed to the road without talking like possessed robots?!

What a nanny state we live in today!
Perhaps I should have actually read the article and found out more about what Google Glass actually does before commenting. Most definitely distracting then and probably not for driving.

I'll just leave quietly now.

otolith

69,785 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Dazed Confused said:
otolith said:
AR glasses could be a fantastic tool for making driving better in all kinds of ways. Luddite knee jerk reaction wins out rolleyes
Yes - because it wouldn't be abused at all now, would it. I mean the internet is provided at work so that people can be more productive, yet Pistonheads' comments sections still seem to fill up quite nicely between 9 and 5....
Here's an idea - prosecute people who abuse it.

thescamper

920 posts

257 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
ash73 said:
Mobile phone use is a blight to road safety. Until we have driveless cars the only answer is to block all connectivity in moving vehicles, except calls to emergency services, imho.
Really! My mobile rings, I answer it, I have a conversation with someone, I end the call without my hands leaving the steering wheel. How is that any different to talking to my passenger.

Lets not ban mobile phone use, lets just enforce the hands free bit. If you are caught with your phone in hand then its automatically DWDCA not just a poxy fine.

Dazed & Confused

209 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
otolith said:
Here's an idea - prosecute people who abuse it.
Great idea - I can see no difficulties with enforcing this whatsoever! A plan without drawbacks!

snorky

2,322 posts

282 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
pointless....the police cant stop morons using their phones how will they stop this?

BOBBY G

483 posts

241 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
ash73 said:
Is PH taking the position this will be the lesser of two evils and therefore should be tolerated? I must be misinterpreting this, surely? It's not a line of sight issue, it's an attention issue.

Mobile phone use is a blight to road safety. Until we have driveless cars the only answer is to block all connectivity in moving vehicles, except calls to emergency services, imho.
Agreed.

otolith

69,785 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Dazed & Confused]
otolith said:
Here's an idea - prosecute people who abuse it.
Great idea - I can see no difficulties with enforcing this whatsoever! A plan without drawbacks!
Legacy of the Blair government's attitude to legislation.

It is already illegal to drive without due care and attention. It was illegal to do so even before the mobile phone ban. It's usually bloody obvious from behind when someone is distracted by yakking on the phone. If you can't tell that's what they are doing, what's the issue?

theJT

333 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
So I'm driving along, and I'm wearing a pair of these things, and they're updating me on traffic in real time, and showing an AR overlay of the road ahead saying "turn left in 100 yards!" with a convenient translucent arrow...

That's just better than sat-nav as we have it now. Obviously this has the possibility to be abused, but then so does more or less anything. So does my radio. So does the damn GLOVEBOX. I know someone who crashed on a totally empty road because he was trying to get something out of there whilst driving. He lost his licence, as he bloody should have, and didn't need any fancy technology to do it.

We have a law that requires you to drive with "due care and attention" I don't see why we need another. I don't need to be told not to use this thing to play facebook games or look at holiday photos whilst I'm driving. I know not to do that, because I'm not a complete idiot. If I were to do that and then crash, I'd expect to have the book thrown at me - as should everyone else.

We don't NEED a million and one stupid specific laws banning this and banning that. Why can't we just assume that people aren't stupid and can make rational choices, and then we can arrest the ones that can't behave like adults and take their licences away!