Theft - likely sentence?
Discussion
A friend of a friend has recently got himself into a bit of trouble with a bad gambling habit, and via processing false wage advances for his staff has managed to relieve his employers of something approaching £45k - he was a store manager, and so was in charge of payroll processing, and noticed that nobody at H/O followed up on a genuine advance that wasn't paid back. Things have obviously now been tightened up!
This is all now out in the open, and I believe he has been charged with theft (not sure if it is theft from an employer/position of trust).
It will be his first offence, he is attending GA meetings and has been for three months or so now, and has admitted everything. There is an offer of restitution from his parents, but this has been refused and he's off to court.
What sort of sentence is he likely to get, and is it within Magistrates sentencing powers or will he end up facing a Judge? He thinks he could well spend some time in jail, but I would have though it more of a certainty!
TIA for any advice, and it really isn't me!
This is all now out in the open, and I believe he has been charged with theft (not sure if it is theft from an employer/position of trust).
It will be his first offence, he is attending GA meetings and has been for three months or so now, and has admitted everything. There is an offer of restitution from his parents, but this has been refused and he's off to court.
What sort of sentence is he likely to get, and is it within Magistrates sentencing powers or will he end up facing a Judge? He thinks he could well spend some time in jail, but I would have though it more of a certainty!
TIA for any advice, and it really isn't me!
Looked at that last night. What I don't understand is this
Type £20,000 - £125,000 or less than £20,000 High Degree Trust
Starting Point 2 years
Range 12 months - 3 years
Type £125,000 plus or £20,000 plus high Degree Trust
Starting Point 3 years
Range 2 years - 6 years
The range starts at a lower value than the starting point? I just thought I'd ask on here for some real world ideas. I guess it might be decided he's in a position of "High degree Trust".
Type £20,000 - £125,000 or less than £20,000 High Degree Trust
Starting Point 2 years
Range 12 months - 3 years
Type £125,000 plus or £20,000 plus high Degree Trust
Starting Point 3 years
Range 2 years - 6 years
The range starts at a lower value than the starting point? I just thought I'd ask on here for some real world ideas. I guess it might be decided he's in a position of "High degree Trust".
MrsThatcher said:
I heard of a similar case recently. A guy swindled £40k from a well known highstreet bank.. Got caught and the bank got most of its money back...
Did 2 years for it.
Thanks - just asking because, as I said, the chap concerned thinks he might do time, whereas I think he needs to be taking a few things to court with him!Did 2 years for it.
10 Pence Short said:
It looks like 18 months to 3 years, depending on the circumstances. I would have thought making good the stolen money would help, unless they were insured for such loss and have already been paid out.
His employers have refused such an offer, deciding instead to go through the courts. The sum is large in isolation, but they are a big company and prefer to make an example of him.Rollcage said:
Looked at that last night. What I don't understand is this
Type £20,000 - £125,000 or less than £20,000 High Degree Trust
Starting Point 2 years
Range 12 months - 3 years
Type £125,000 plus or £20,000 plus high Degree Trust
Starting Point 3 years
Range 2 years - 6 years
The range starts at a lower value than the starting point? I just thought I'd ask on here for some real world ideas. I guess it might be decided he's in a position of "High degree Trust".
The judge takes the starting point then adjusts up or down depending on mitigating or aggravating factors. So theft from a vulnerable person's life savings may be more serious than walking into a jewellers and stealing a Rolex. I do not know if a gambling addiction would be treated as a mitigating factor, however.Type £20,000 - £125,000 or less than £20,000 High Degree Trust
Starting Point 2 years
Range 12 months - 3 years
Type £125,000 plus or £20,000 plus high Degree Trust
Starting Point 3 years
Range 2 years - 6 years
The range starts at a lower value than the starting point? I just thought I'd ask on here for some real world ideas. I guess it might be decided he's in a position of "High degree Trust".
Rollcage said:
His employers have refused such an offer, deciding instead to go through the courts. The sum is large in isolation, but they are a big company and prefer to make an example of him.
The two things aren't connected, in that he canpay it back and still be prosecuted.Is your friend trying to say they'd rather be £45k down and see him imprisoned, rather than level and see him imprisoned?
In these cases, the employer usually sues to recover the money if the employee has any assets. As 10P says, this is separate from the prosecution. Making an example of the employee is sensible, pour encourager les autres. The OP almost suggests that the employee is being hard done by, but I suspect that few would agree.
Breadvan72 said:
In these cases, the employer usually sues to recover the money if the employee has any assets. As 10P says, this is separate from the prosecution. Making an example of the employee is sensible, pour encourager les autres. The OP almost suggests that the employee is being hard done by, but I suspect that few would agree.
That wouldn't be my intention at all - I wasn't trying to project my own thoughts onto the facts presented, other than that I think he'll do a stretch.FWIW - I don't think he's being hard done by at all. The actions of a few make life very difficult for the majority!
We had an accountant stealing money from us and our clients. We found around £140k, he was charged with something like £70k (CPS didn't want to have to prove each and every cheque, so charged with a representative cross-section). The case was sent to Crown Court as the Magistrates didn't have sufficient sentencing powers for the maximum sentence. He pleaded guilty as late as possible, received two years so served something like 7/8 months before coming out on a tag.
I would say that the company has little to no prospect of getting the money back. If that was important, they should have accepted the offer from the parents. It has taken us FIVE years from the sentencing to get any money, and that was less than 15% of the amount taken and only possibly because he had reasonable equity in his house.
I would say that the company has little to no prospect of getting the money back. If that was important, they should have accepted the offer from the parents. It has taken us FIVE years from the sentencing to get any money, and that was less than 15% of the amount taken and only possibly because he had reasonable equity in his house.
The business concerned won't be affected by the cash loss in the slightest. I have no doubt they would rather it go to Court as BV said "pour encourager les autres". I don't know if the parent's offer was conditional in some way to avoid the Police being involved - very possibly, as it was refused.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


