The newspapers deliberately mislead you and me
The newspapers deliberately mislead you and me
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Nearly a year ago it was reported in the press that a detective superintendent (DSp) had 'bungled' an investigation into a murder. His 'error of judgement', they all said, meant that a killer got away with murder.

As so often in such cases, especially when there is agreement amongst all papers, from the Gaurdain to the right wing ones, all was not as it seemed.

Firstly, the headlines and copy were factually incorrect and the reports biased, despite all the media knowing the full facts of the case. Even now we have the DT suggesting 'The mother of a murdered 20-year-old, who was denied justice when a senior detective breached a legal technicality . . .' This is not the case.

The officer has been suspended for some 10 months, albeit on full pay, yet all the facts of the case are known by the force in question and the discipline authorities.

The DSp is in fact, as is known by the headline-seekers and those with an agenda to push, something of a hero. He decided to risk his career, job and pension to help out a distressed women. Had he not done so it is likely that he would never have been able to bury her daughter. Further, his actions did not stop the murderer being prosecuted. There was insufficient, that's insufficient, not just no quite enough, but a scarcity of evidence, that the offender had committed the offence and there was little of no likelihood of being able to obtain any more. All there was was location, dates and MO. Similar in many ways to a partial print. Everyone knows it is him but there is no way to prove it.

What the DSp did was to use his years of experience to pick the time to ask the offender where he had buried the body of a previous victim. The DSp knew that the mother was distressed and wanted to bury her child. So he went outside the guidelines of Codes of Practice and the requirements of the laws of evidence and away from his brief the DSp asked the offender to locate the body of his other victim, which he did.

There had been many attempts to get the offender to admit his crime but he had refused. The murderer was already in custody for another offence of murder which the offender had confessed to.

What would you have done in similar circumstances? Would you have followed procedure and said to the mother, 'Tough, old girl. Nothing I can do about it. There are procedures you see.', or would you have considered all the alternatives and then opted on the high risk, at least for the DSp's interests, strategy of trying to find the grave by ignoring, or rather not ignoring, but going outside, the guidelines?

The rotten thing is that I know exactly what I would have done and I feel a bit ashamed. Quite a bit in fact. Even knowing how grateful the mother is for being able to bury her daughter, and knowing also how I would feel in such circumstances, I still believe that I would have followed procedures and I am not comfortable about it.

I've always thought that a hero is one who takes risks with his own safety/welfare/interests in cold blood for the sake of others that a normal person would not.

So DSp Steve Fulcher, you are, by my definition, a hero.

The newspapers at the time of the original story knew exactly what was going on, and knew why the officer did what he did, but words such as inept, bungling - well you know the rest - were used. Some TV news did not run the story, feeling that they had a responsibility to be honest.

So those who buy newspapers or go online and read them, are, no doubt, firmly of the opinion that a senior detective did not know the basics of his job.

And people wonder why police officers, and other sensible people, suggest that when a story breaks in the DM that we should, perhaps, wait until the full facts are available before thinking that the police are criminal, inept or just bloody-minded.

The decision of the IPCC is expected this week. One wonders not only what it will be but the police force's reaction to it. Will they think 'Damn the press. They will twist and turn everything to their own ends.' and support their hero? The thing is that if DSp was in the position to make such a decision on another hero, I know full well he'd do the right thing. And that's what has caused him to be suspended for 10 months and be in line to lose his career, his job and his pension.

DSp Fulcher, I'd throw a salute up to you if I ever met you. Best of luck, mate.

hidetheelephants

36,465 posts

224 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
If this is the case I think it is I heartily agree with you.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Newspapers don't care about misleading you and me.
Newspapers care about selling advertising space and making a profit.

The only exception to this (I am aware of) is the BBC.
Who don't sell newspapers. wink.
And even then I'd only call them impartial because different articles are biased in different ways.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Nearly a year ago it was reported in the press that a detective superintendent (DSp) had 'bungled' an investigation into a murder. His 'error of judgement', they all said, meant that a killer got away with murder.

The officer has been suspended for some 10 months, albeit on full pay, yet all the facts of the case are known by the force in question and the discipline authorities.

The DSp knew that the mother was distressed and wanted to bury her child. So he went outside the guidelines of Codes of Practice and the requirements of the laws of evidence and away from his brief the DSp asked the offender to locate the body of his other victim, which he did.
He breached a suspect's rights by asking questions without the presence of his lawyer, despite knowing how wrong this was.

The trial was aborted due to the unlawful questioning & lack of regard for the suspect's rights.

Regardless of the guy's guilt or innocence, someone broke the rules & deliberately interfered with correct legal process for the sake of personal whims.

The rules are clear. The rules are there for a reason. He broke the rules & must therefore be prepared to pay the price.


BJG1

5,966 posts

243 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Just reading up on this, to be clear, this is what the media reports I've read have said.

Girl goes missing, Man is arrested and brought in for questioning.

Officer doesn't wait for a solicitor and questions suspect anyway

This leads to them finding the body and successful prosecution of said man for murder

During this interview, which was outside of guidelines, the killer asked "do you want another one" and revealed the location of a girl he'd murder a year previous

Because of how this info was obtained, he couldn't be prosecuted for the older murder.


Are you saying that the fact they couldn't prosecute for the 2nd murder was because of insufficient evidence, rather than what is suggested and further, the killer didn't just reveal it out of the blue but the officer knew he'd committed that murder so got him to give the location of the body?

Elroy Blue

8,858 posts

223 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
He breached a suspect's rights by asking questions without the presence of his lawyer, despite knowing how wrong this was.

The trial was aborted due to the unlawful questioning & lack of regard for the suspect's rights.

Regardless of the guy's guilt or innocence, someone broke the rules & deliberately interfered with correct legal process for the sake of personal whims.

The rules are clear. The rules are there for a reason. He broke the rules & must therefore be prepared to pay the price.
And you're the same person who continually quotes the 'I was only following orders" line when condemning Police Officers.

You're a hypocrite of the highest order and beneath contempt.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Derek Smith said:
Nearly a year ago it was reported in the press that a detective superintendent (DSp) had 'bungled' an investigation into a murder. His 'error of judgement', they all said, meant that a killer got away with murder.

The officer has been suspended for some 10 months, albeit on full pay, yet all the facts of the case are known by the force in question and the discipline authorities.

The DSp knew that the mother was distressed and wanted to bury her child. So he went outside the guidelines of Codes of Practice and the requirements of the laws of evidence and away from his brief the DSp asked the offender to locate the body of his other victim, which he did.
He breached a suspect's rights by asking questions without the presence of his lawyer, despite knowing how wrong this was.

The trial was aborted due to the unlawful questioning & lack of regard for the suspect's rights.

Regardless of the guy's guilt or innocence, someone broke the rules & deliberately interfered with correct legal process for the sake of personal whims.

The rules are clear. The rules are there for a reason. He broke the rules & must therefore be prepared to pay the price.
I'm going back on my word. I said I'd never comment on one of your posts again and hoped, but not believed of course, that you would extend the same courtesy to mine. But needs must. Further, I don't like personal insults and rarely indulge myself, but this is exceptional.

That post of yours is the most pathetic you've ever produced, and going by your output, that is really saying something.

Do you not see the obvious?

The whole point is that, to quote you, something which I only do reluctantly, "He broke the rules and must therefore be prepared to pay the price."

Is it beyond your comprehension to realise that the whole point is that he is prepared to pay the price? The price being career, job and probably pension?

It is not a difficult or obscure point, just an unusual one in that people do not often risk so much for someone else entirely unconnected with them.

And further, such an act means nothing more than any evidence gained from the questioning cannot be admitted.


Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
You're a hypocrite of the highest order and beneath contempt.
You're very abusive, aren't you?

If you have nothing better to say then I'll leave you to it.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
the whole point is that he is prepared to pay the price? The price being career, job and probably pension?
Fair play if he's man enough to pay the price.

It's just wrong that he deliberately infringed a prisoner's rights in the first place in order to make a woman happy. This IMHO does not make him a hero.

BJG1

5,966 posts

243 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
It's just wrong that he deliberately infringed a prisoner's rights in the first place in order to make a woman happy.
That's one way of phrasing it.

Personally I'd phrase it as "he deliberately infringed on the rights of a man he knew to be a murderer in order to allow a mother closure and a funeral for her murdered daughter"


markmullen

15,877 posts

265 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Crazy situation.

I wasn't aware of the case so did some research, the first article from the Telegraph sums it up pretty accurately from what I see
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-ord...

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
BJG1 said:
Just reading up on this, to be clear, this is what the media reports I've read have said.

Girl goes missing, Man is arrested and brought in for questioning.

Officer doesn't wait for a solicitor and questions suspect anyway

This leads to them finding the body and successful prosecution of said man for murder

During this interview, which was outside of guidelines, the killer asked "do you want another one" and revealed the location of a girl he'd murder a year previous

Because of how this info was obtained, he couldn't be prosecuted for the older murder.


Are you saying that the fact they couldn't prosecute for the 2nd murder was because of insufficient evidence, rather than what is suggested and further, the killer didn't just reveal it out of the blue but the officer knew he'd committed that murder so got him to give the location of the body?
The chap was in custody for one murder, the evidence being overwhelming. The MO was similar to another murder but questioning proved negative. There was no evidence of the second case. The police were stymied. I don't know if this is true but it is probable that the brief told the offender that it was against his interests to admit to the second murder.

The chap said he would lead the police to the body of the murder victim he'd admitted to, so off they go. The DSp assumed, one would assume, that the murder would follow normal procedure and bury bodies in the same general location but sufficient distance apart so that they do not get them mixed up. So away from the bloke's brief the DSp suggested to the offender that he might want to put the mother out of her misery and that by taking the police to the body of his first victim he would not be admitting to doing it nor could it be entered into evidence.

The location of the body, which had been buried since 2002 I believe, was identified and so what remained could be exhumed and properly dealt with.

There was little, in the sense of practically no, likelihood of finding the body by any other means.

By the way, the mother is full of praise for the DSp.

So, to repeat the question, not only to you but everyone, what would you have done in the circumstances?


Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
markmullen said:
Crazy situation.

I wasn't aware of the case so did some research, the first article from the Telegraph sums it up pretty accurately from what I see
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-ord...
Thanks for the link to the blog. Didn't see that at the time.

205alive

6,087 posts

207 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Rovingsh!tehawk said:
It's just wrong that he deliberately infringed a prisoner's rights in the first place in order to make a woman happy
You must be out of your tiny, ingenuous, mind. Or a troll.

BJG1

5,966 posts

243 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
The chap was in custody for one murder, the evidence being overwhelming. The MO was similar to another murder but questioning proved negative. There was no evidence of the second case. The police were stymied. I don't know if this is true but it is probable that the brief told the offender that it was against his interests to admit to the second murder.

The chap said he would lead the police to the body of the murder victim he'd admitted to, so off they go. The DSp assumed, one would assume, that the murder would follow normal procedure and bury bodies in the same general location but sufficient distance apart so that they do not get them mixed up. So away from the bloke's brief the DSp suggested to the offender that he might want to put the mother out of her misery and that by taking the police to the body of his first victim he would not be admitting to doing it nor could it be entered into evidence.

The location of the body, which had been buried since 2002 I believe, was identified and so what remained could be exhumed and properly dealt with.

There was little, in the sense of practically no, likelihood of finding the body by any other means.

By the way, the mother is full of praise for the DSp.

So, to repeat the question, not only to you but everyone, what would you have done in the circumstances?
Thanks, so to be clear, you are saying the media portrayal of events (which i wouldn't say were negative) were completely untrue?

You are saying as part of a by-the-book investigation into the murder of one woman, he managed to get the killer to reveal the other body by not going by the book? The reports I have read suggest that he went off the book for the first two, interviewing him without a lawyer present because he believed there was a chance the girl was still alive and thought her right to life superseded his right to an attorney. During the course of this, he also revealed the location of another body which was completely out of the blue. Are you saying this is completely untrue?

This is the easiest to follow version of events I am referring to - http://www.channel4.com/news/sian-ocallaghan-murde...

I'd be grateful if you could tell me how the actual events differed from what is outlined there.


In any case, I have no issue with what he has done, regardless of whether you or the media are correct.

FiF

49,060 posts

282 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Not sure what would have done probably played safe. Unless there was an option identified thus:-

This option will really brass Rovinghawk off.

Then would have done that for sure.

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
They will always put a slant on matters. Whether that is deliberate is a question for each situation (some do appear inevitably to be deliberate).

Terminator X

21,050 posts

235 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
There are always exceptions to "the rules" and this sounds like one of them. Why can't the people in charge be allowed some discretion in cases such as this? If there is no discretion allowed then they should be re-written. Clearly the rules are there to stop people being beaten in to a confession however the crim wasn't beaten so why press charges and/or hound the man?

TX.

singlecoil

35,901 posts

277 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
205alive said:
Rovingsh!tehawk said:
It's just wrong that he deliberately infringed a prisoner's rights in the first place in order to make a woman happy
You must be out of your tiny, ingenuous, mind. Or a troll.
I'm going with the second of those. The guy obviously has some intelligence, he's just perverted it into an unreasoning hatred of the police, and he enjoys pushing the buttons* of people who have a more balanced view.




  • Sorry about the American expression, it's just so apt.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
I think the popularity of Life on Mars speaks volumes.

But if you ever trusted what you read in the press you should remind yourself how David Icke first raised his profile. Probably best to avoid the mainstream press accounts...