Identical twins' DNA can't identify rapist
Identical twins' DNA can't identify rapist
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Identical twins who cannot be told apart by their DNA have both appeared in court charged over the alleged rape of a woman.

Prosecutors charged both Mohammed and Aftab Asghar but said it may be “that only one faces trial”.

The pair, aged 22, appeared at a preliminary hearing at Reading Crown Court, Berkshire.

But police and the Crown Prosecution Service are still trying to determine whether they should continue to pursue the case against both men. Prosecutor Sandra Beck requested more time for the Crown to pursue particular lines of inquiry.

She said: “It is an unusual case. They are identical twins. The allegation is one of rape. There is further work due … it may mean that only one of the defendants faces trial."

No details were divulged about the circumstances of the alleged offence, which is said to have occurred on Nov 5, 2011.

Ms Beck confirmed that a trial date had already been set for Dec 2. The twins, from Reading, have been granted conditional bail.

Identical twins share matching DNA but have different fingerprints, according to the Forensic Science Service.

The case is not the first time this has posed a problem for investigators. In February, identical 24-year-old twin brothers were held in Marseille, France, by police hunting a rapist as their genetic codes were so similar that normal DNA tests could not tell them apart.

Streaky

greygoose

9,675 posts

226 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
I remember the French case though I don't know if they ever got to the bottom of which one it was.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
get them on the old Jeremy Kyle show, surely his lie detector will solve it rofl

markiii

4,342 posts

225 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
So they are knowingly charging someone they know didn't commit a crime? Unless they suppose they both raped her?

That malicious prosecution surely?

Pannywagon

1,044 posts

217 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
markiii said:
So they are knowingly charging someone they know didn't commit a crime? Unless they suppose they both raped her?

That malicious prosecution surely?
??

The evidence points to both being prime suspects. Once charged, the Police can still investigate, and eliminate one or the other based on alibi etc.

It may be that they are both guilty and tag-teamed the victim. Nothing malicious in charging both based on the DNA evidence.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
markiii said:
So they are knowingly charging someone they know didn't commit a crime? Unless they suppose they both raped her?

That malicious prosecution surely?
What would you rather happen? Leave them be and give every set of identical twins a free pass to commit whatever crime they want? Also, leaving at least one of these free to continue their rape hobby?

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
greygoose said:
I don't know if they ever got to the bottom of which one it was.
Why would they need to get to their bottom? To collect the DNA?

Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Something similar happened in Singapore, someone committed the henious crime of having a few plant trimmings in the back of their car so faced the death penalty but during the arrest somehow they also picked up this person's twin brother and in custody mixed them up so no one was sure who was who.

Fortunately for them, despite being ridiculously draconian the Singaporian legal system is based on the UK one and so they were both set free by the judge ultimately...

Edit: link to the case: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/02/08/r-sathis-...

Also it would seem that they had plant extract as well as plant trimmings, so obviously it would have been perfectly sensible to judicially murder them otherwise

Edited by Somewhatfoolish on Wednesday 21st August 23:22

kenny Chim 4

1,604 posts

289 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
A couple of years ago a sensible person on here asked 'what is the net benefit of importing islam to the UK?'.

There was no logical response and that's how it remains to this day- completely pointless other than it guaranteed New Labour voters.

This article should raise alarm bells amongst those lefties who actively encouraged and engendered this disgusting level of Asian criminals being allowed British citizanship : http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/3913/uk-muslim-p...

Despite your political leanings, adherents of this poisonous, backward cult are clearly over represented. As abject wrongdoers who have no interest in the our ways and customs, they should be shipped back to whichever 'istan' they crawled out of.

markiii

4,342 posts

225 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
markiii said:
So they are knowingly charging someone they know didn't commit a crime? Unless they suppose they both raped her?

That malicious prosecution surely?
What would you rather happen? Leave them be and give every set of identical twins a free pass to commit whatever crime they want? Also, leaving at least one of these free to continue their rape hobby?
I'd rather they find some actual evidence before charging

DeadPrez

140 posts

162 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
kenny Chim 4 said:
A couple of years ago a sensible person on here asked 'what is the net benefit of importing islam to the UK?'.

There was no logical response and that's how it remains to this day- completely pointless other than it guaranteed New Labour voters.

This article should raise alarm bells amongst those lefties who actively encouraged and engendered this disgusting level of Asian criminals being allowed British citizanship : http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/3913/uk-muslim-p...

Despite your political leanings, adherents of this poisonous, backward cult are clearly over represented. As abject wrongdoers who have no interest in the our ways and customs, they should be shipped back to whichever 'istan' they crawled out of.
You cray' bro?

kenny Chim 4

1,604 posts

289 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
DeadPrez said:
You cray' bro?
Sorry, but I'm struggling to understand what you mean by that statement.

Is there anyone on here who can speak jive?

Skyrat

1,185 posts

221 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
kenny Chim 4 said:
A couple of years ago a sensible person on here asked 'what is the net benefit of importing islam to the UK?'.

There was no logical response and that's how it remains to this day- completely pointless other than it guaranteed New Labour voters.

This article should raise alarm bells amongst those lefties who actively encouraged and engendered this disgusting level of Asian criminals being allowed British citizanship : http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/3913/uk-muslim-p...

Despite your political leanings, adherents of this poisonous, backward cult are clearly over represented. As abject wrongdoers who have no interest in the our ways and customs, they should be shipped back to whichever 'istan' they crawled out of.
I fail to see what any of that has to do with the topic.


streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
greygoose said:
I don't know if they ever got to the bottom of which one it was.
Why would they need to get to their bottom? To collect the DNA?
Maybe their 'front bottom'.



kenny Chim 4 said:
DeadPrez said:
You cray' bro?
Sorry, but I'm struggling to understand what you mean by that statement.

Is there anyone on here who can speak jive?
Presumably DeadPrez.


Streaky

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
If DNA is based on bodily fluids and the offence of rape needs penetration
who had the victims DNA ?
Think about it.

dvd

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
The National Dyslexic Association?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
DNA is merely one form of identification, as is appearance.

Convictions were made in the past pre DNA checks. Identical twins who are both offenders, or even one with the other supporting, have always proved a bit of a problem' There can be few divisions across the country which haven't had such problems.

One fairly common feature with regards twins is that they tend to stick together (literally in the case of conjoined) and that often is their 'downfall'. They stand out and witnesses often suggest in crimes such as disorder or offences against the person that both acted in concert.

There can be the evil/good twin situation where one is an habitual offender and the other is a stalwart of the community, or something similar, and this can cause problems early on but what sometimes happen is that one gets beaten or, in one case I know, injured so that they walk differently.

There are fingerprints of course.

The charging of both is unusual of course, but for all we know the two may have both been involved in the rape.

An interesting case, if one can disassociate from the offence.

worsy

6,630 posts

206 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Pannywagon said:
It may be that they are both guilty and tag-teamed the victim.
The victim would surely have noticed this and thought to mention it in her complaint to the police.

markiii

4,342 posts

225 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
WeirdNeville said:
markiii said:
I'd rather they find some actual evidence before charging
What, like DNA?
But it's not evidence of the only guilty party is it?

By this logic a partial print that could actually be either of 2 people justifys charging both, same principle you know you have wilfully charged an innocent person, you just don't know which one of them it is.