Use of manufacturer logos in artwork
Use of manufacturer logos in artwork
Author
Discussion

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
What are the legal implications of an artist using a manufacturers logo on a piece of artwork that they are intending to sell?

If I am producing such works, do I have to seek a brand license from the manufacturer in question, or could a disclaimer be added to the work, stating clearly that it is not an official product?

I'm thinking along the lines of T shirts, that sort of thing. The logo would not be the main focus of the work, the main artwork would be correctly licensed for commercial use.



Edited by Kozy on Wednesday 13th November 14:49

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
If the copyright is infringed then deep trouble.

dvd

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Potential trademark infringement, for one. Have you checked to see if the logo is a registered trademark?

Also, what do you mean by artwork that you are planning to sell? I think Nike (to take an arbitrary example) would take very different views of one painting that included a swoosh to prints that were to be sold in large numbers.

Depending on exactly what you're planning to do, I'd be tempted to consider asking the company in question if it's okay for you to use their logo. You might find they're supportive of your plans.

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Sorry OP, you edited your original post before I had finished my reply.

If you're planning to sell mugs and t-shirts, then I would definitely seek permission from the company concerned - especially if the logo is a registered trademark.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
I'm doing some prints of different vehicles, much like some of the T shirts for sale in the PH shop. I'd like to use the logo's as part of these, it's not essential to the work, but is a nice finishing touch. I don't know whether they'll actually sell in any decent numbers, but some initial interest suggests they will at least sell in small numbers.

If I were to contact say, Ford, and ask if they were OK with it, am I likely to have to pay for the use? I understand every company will be different, but more as a kind of 'on average' kind of question. Does every shirt featuring the Ford logo have official Ford endorsement?

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Well I've just put a request in to Ford, let's see what they say...

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
To give you an idea, Paul James deliberately changes logos just enough to avoid paying royalties.

Look at "Streetwise Charlie" and "Spray it again Charlie" as two examples - subtle changes to McDonalds carton, B&H packet and the can of Stella.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Blimey, I'm surprised he even needed to bother, you can hardly notice them!

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
If you're including the logo as it would be seen on the car in question (for example the diamond on the front of a Renault) then I doubt there would be a problem. If you're planning to include the Renault logo alongside the picture of the car, then I'd be inclined to seek permission.

It's unlikely that you'll run into problems, but in theory at least if Renault (say) were to take umbrage at your use of their mark (given that they've probably registered it for clothing) then they could take action against you.

I expect you'll probably not get much of a response from any of the companies. If I were you I'd include something along the lines of the following in your emails: "if I don't hear from you within {a reasonable period of time, for example 21 days}, I will assume that you have no objections to my use of your mark in this way", as you might be able to mitigate any liability for damages in the very unlikely event they were to take action against you.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Good advice. The Ford request was put in through an official channel, so I hope to hear back within 5 days as they state on the website.

Neonblau

875 posts

164 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
A lot of manufacturers take a very tough stance on this. I believe VAG are one of the toughest but more and more you'll see "Officially Licenced Product" which translates into "we charge for this", and are Ford are well into that.

If you are producing any kind of volume (as above I don't think a painting would bother anyone - see Dale Klee's work for example) I would would either ensure you've got permission or as above make it different enough to keep you in the clear. Any unlicensed use could result in seizure of all the stock.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Ok that's pretty much as I expected. These are not one off pieces, so it's definitely a concern.

I don't mind paying for it if it is a reasonable royalty on each piece sold.

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
As Neonblau says above, there are potentially very serious consequences if one of these companies does object - although stock seizure would only happen if fought a court action brought against you (which you'd be daft to do as you might end up being liable for their costs!).

On a positive note, well done for even thinking about this and for asking the question. So many people are completely ignorant of intellectual property rights.

I hope the companies concerned play ball OP. Good luck.

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
Blimey, I'm surprised he even needed to bother, you can hardly notice them!
He's a nice guy, and very switched on commercially. Licencing costs money...

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
The manufacturer will have something to say about how their brand is portrayed. Unless you hit the jackpot and your creation exactly fits their brand guidelines then I'd imagine it will be easier for them to just prohibit its use. They may (read: mostly likely will) not even want unauthorised channels to be advertising on their behalf.

I'd be surprised if they authorise the use, unless as stated it is shown in situ on a vehicle, and even then I think they'd have something to say about it.

In Ford's case, they have form for being particularly militant.

GoneAnon

1,703 posts

183 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
I had a solicitor's "cease and desist" letter sent to a company using our brand and logo in their website.

I think "passing off" was the legal issue as their site made them appear to be part of the manufacturer.

Also, the XROC had to stop using the Ford logo on their merchandise many many years ago, I guess for a similar reason.

If your artwork appears to be made by/for the maker they will take a different view than if it is piece of work as a homage.

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Wednesday 13th November 2013
quotequote all
GoneAnon said:
I had a solicitor's "cease and desist" letter sent to a company using our brand and logo in their website.

I think "passing off" was the legal issue as their site made them appear to be part of the manufacturer.
Somewhat off topic GoneAnon, but it might be worthwhile looking into registering your brand/logo as a trademark, as it's much easier to bring and win a trademark infringement action than a passing off action.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Thursday 14th November 2013
quotequote all
GoneAnon said:
I had a solicitor's "cease and desist" letter sent to a company using our brand and logo in their website.

I think "passing off" was the legal issue as their site made them appear to be part of the manufacturer.

Also, the XROC had to stop using the Ford logo on their merchandise many many years ago, I guess for a similar reason.

If your artwork appears to be made by/for the maker they will take a different view than if it is piece of work as a homage.
I'm not sure how they will take it in honesty. The pieces are [removed] The logos give them an authentic feel, but I don't necessarily want to pass them off as being 'produced by Ford'. They'll have my 'produced by' my name/company.


Edited by Kozy on Monday 6th January 11:54

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Thursday 14th November 2013
quotequote all
As an option, would blending by own logo in with manuf. logos constitute enough of a change to prevent any issues?

Hungry Pigeon

239 posts

215 months

Thursday 14th November 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
As an option, would blending by own logo in with manuf. logos constitute enough of a change to prevent any issues?
Not sure exactly what you mean, but if their logo is still identifiable then you still have a problem. In fact, by blending your logo with theirs you might make things worse by appearing to suggest that your company is somehow associated with the manufacturers.

If you want to use the logos your only real option is to seek permission from the companies involved.