Injuctions - Noisy neighbour
Discussion
Being owner occupiers, living in an attached house, the local housing association bought next door a few years back & we have had problems ever since. The current resident moved in just over one year ago, from day 1 we suffered loud music till the early hours & anti social behaviousr for over 8 months. Despite taking the appropriate action with the HA, making logs etc they basically denied it was happening (quite laughable). The environmental health got involved too but each time any monitoring took place they would be quiet for a convenient period. We believe the tenant did get a demoted tenancy but a year to the day since they first moved in & the noise has started again for over a week now. We assume demoted tenancy has ceased with a renewed tenancy agreement & they know they can get away with for another few months again.
We & 2 other neighbours would like to consider an injuction action the tenant or direct legal against the HA for failing to act we have plenty of evidence & this time now its starting to have a bigger impact as we thought we had gotten over it.
Can anybody please advise on what we should do, we seriously need to get something done
We & 2 other neighbours would like to consider an injuction action the tenant or direct legal against the HA for failing to act we have plenty of evidence & this time now its starting to have a bigger impact as we thought we had gotten over it.
Can anybody please advise on what we should do, we seriously need to get something done
Could this come under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997? Noise being a recognised method of harassmen within the act, when used to create alarm/distress?
Have you exhausted all of the options offered in the very comprehensive and factually dependable Neighbours From Hell website? www.nfh.org.uk
Have you exhausted all of the options offered in the very comprehensive and factually dependable Neighbours From Hell website? www.nfh.org.uk
ReaderScars said:
Could this come under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997? Noise being a recognised method of harassmen within the act, when used to create alarm/distress?
Have you exhausted all of the options offered in the very comprehensive and factually dependable Neighbours From Hell website? www.nfh.org.uk
They even accused us of the ones harassing their resident by complaining to the HA so much (there are 3 other neighbours who made official diary logged complaints too) Have you exhausted all of the options offered in the very comprehensive and factually dependable Neighbours From Hell website? www.nfh.org.uk
I shall check out the link thanks
You've only been suffering this for 12 months - way to go!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24967042
Hope you get it sorted. Nothing worse than anti-social couldn't-care less people next door.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24967042
Hope you get it sorted. Nothing worse than anti-social couldn't-care less people next door.
If we could move we would but we love the place we are in & it was idyllic before. Current position is the property could be seriously devalued unless a proper resolution is in place, we cannot rely on the HA doing this, especially as the HA has allocated the property to problem young people!
We will start making video diaries this time round, good point, thanks for that.
Currently discussing with our household insurance if our legal cover will cover the expenses of going down the injunction/suing legal route. Though an injunction against the resident is fine until the next one comes along...
We will start making video diaries this time round, good point, thanks for that.
Currently discussing with our household insurance if our legal cover will cover the expenses of going down the injunction/suing legal route. Though an injunction against the resident is fine until the next one comes along...
Are these still the same neighbours, or is it another lot??
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
I feel your pain, it always follows the same path, authorities are at best completely useless, at worst, they turn on the complainant.
The EH would unbelievably notify my antagonists every time before they did any monitoring!
I came to the conclusion that EHOs only existed to keep complaints out of the courts. If you look at the figures for their successful resolutions/prosecutions - a tiny fraction of complaints - you will see they are indeed near useless. You can bypass them.
http://www.environmentlaw.org.uk/rte.asp?id=73
The EH would unbelievably notify my antagonists every time before they did any monitoring!
I came to the conclusion that EHOs only existed to keep complaints out of the courts. If you look at the figures for their successful resolutions/prosecutions - a tiny fraction of complaints - you will see they are indeed near useless. You can bypass them.
http://www.environmentlaw.org.uk/rte.asp?id=73
cptsideways said:
If we could move we would but we love the place we are in & it was idyllic before. Current position is the property could be seriously devalued unless a proper resolution is in place, we cannot rely on the HA doing this, especially as the HA has allocated the property to problem young people!
We will start making video diaries this time round, good point, thanks for that.
Currently discussing with our household insurance if our legal cover will cover the expenses of going down the injunction/suing legal route. Though an injunction against the resident is fine until the next one comes along...
You need to step back and take stock without the emotion. There is an endless supply of noisy neighbours waiting to take up residence after you have won this battle. We will start making video diaries this time round, good point, thanks for that.
Currently discussing with our household insurance if our legal cover will cover the expenses of going down the injunction/suing legal route. Though an injunction against the resident is fine until the next one comes along...
Not you specifically OP, but I often wonder in situations like this why people are so keen to be right but unhappy .
Fab32 said:
You need to step back and take stock without the emotion. There is an endless supply of noisy neighbours waiting to take up residence after you have won this battle.
Not you specifically OP, but I often wonder in situations like this why people are so keen to be right but unhappy .
This is a very good point.Not you specifically OP, but I often wonder in situations like this why people are so keen to be right but unhappy .
Most people can put up with noisy neighbours, however, until you have experienced seriously problematic neighbours, not had ANY sleep for six months etc., you will realise that it is pragmatism and not emotion that requires the situation to be confronted. You either end up in hospital or you sell at half the market rate.
I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
Mr GrimNasty said:
Most people can put up with noisy neighbours, however, until you have experienced seriously problematic neighbours, not had ANY sleep for six months etc., you will realise that it is pragmatism and not emotion that requires the situation to be confronted. You either end up in hospital or you sell at half the market rate.
I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
Having never experienced it personally only professionally I can only empathise with the situation, however I still don’t see the logic.I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
In this specific situation for example, the OP has said they have had problems since the house was purchased by a housing association, to me that would suggest it’s not likely to get any better anytime soon.
If it was me I would ring up the housing association and ask them if they wanted to buy my house too.
Fab32 said:
Mr GrimNasty said:
Most people can put up with noisy neighbours, however, until you have experienced seriously problematic neighbours, not had ANY sleep for six months etc., you will realise that it is pragmatism and not emotion that requires the situation to be confronted. You either end up in hospital or you sell at half the market rate.
I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
Having never experienced it personally only professionally I can only empathise with the situation, however I still don’t see the logic.I've only ever had this situation once, but it was worth my sanity and the value of the property to confront it, and the new owners are thankfully completely normal.
In this specific situation for example, the OP has said they have had problems since the house was purchased by a housing association, to me that would suggest it’s not likely to get any better anytime soon.
If it was me I would ring up the housing association and ask them if they wanted to buy my house too.
Make it their personal problem too and you'll see a much quicker result.
The first thing is not to let the local authority fob you off.
The Environmental Protection Act 1990 under s79 says (my emphasis):
"it shall be the duty of every local authority to cause its area to be inspected from time to time to detect any statutory nuisances which ought to be dealt with under section 80 below and, where a complaint of a statutory nuisance is made to it by a person living within its area, to take such steps as are reasonably practicable to investigate the complaint."
Noise that is a nuisance emitted from a premises is a statutory nuisance under s79(1)(g).
If the local authority is satisfied there is a statutory nuisance, they are bound to act (my emphasis);
(s80(1)) "where a local authority is satisfied that a statutory nuisance exists, or is likely to occur or recur, in the area of the authority, the local authority shall serve a notice (“an abatement notice”) imposing all or any of the following requirements"
In the case of noise, they can either serve an abatement notice or choose to give an initial warning. If they choose the latter and, at the end of 7 days following the warning, the authority is satisfied it's going to continue, they can then serve the notice. If the noise stops and the behaviour continues more than 7 days later, it's unlikely they'll choose just the warning notice next time.
Contravening the abatement order is an offence.
The Environmental Protection Act 1990 under s79 says (my emphasis):
"it shall be the duty of every local authority to cause its area to be inspected from time to time to detect any statutory nuisances which ought to be dealt with under section 80 below and, where a complaint of a statutory nuisance is made to it by a person living within its area, to take such steps as are reasonably practicable to investigate the complaint."
Noise that is a nuisance emitted from a premises is a statutory nuisance under s79(1)(g).
If the local authority is satisfied there is a statutory nuisance, they are bound to act (my emphasis);
(s80(1)) "where a local authority is satisfied that a statutory nuisance exists, or is likely to occur or recur, in the area of the authority, the local authority shall serve a notice (“an abatement notice”) imposing all or any of the following requirements"
In the case of noise, they can either serve an abatement notice or choose to give an initial warning. If they choose the latter and, at the end of 7 days following the warning, the authority is satisfied it's going to continue, they can then serve the notice. If the noise stops and the behaviour continues more than 7 days later, it's unlikely they'll choose just the warning notice next time.
Contravening the abatement order is an offence.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


