Brake at it again
Author
Discussion

covboy

Original Poster:

2,593 posts

205 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24982173



I know we’ve been through it before, but is that going to include our “highly trained” BIB and their communication systems ?

unimatrix1066

94 posts

221 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Next it will be listening to a radio in the car distracts you.
They had an interview on the radio today with the Brake rep mentioning that driving a vehicle the full risk of using a handsfree should be considered
Next they will suggest banning passengers because surley this is the same if your talking to them

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
unimatrix1066 said:
Next it will be listening to a radio in the car distracts you.
They had an interview on the radio today with the Brake rep mentioning that driving a vehicle the full risk of using a handsfree should be considered
Next they will suggest banning passengers because surley this is the same if your talking to them
Passengers talking does distract you, so does singing along or shouting at Ed Balls on Radio 4 at 7:45am. It's just about what's acceptable in mitigating risk, banning phones isn't acceptable as it's so impractical but they'll still have a go to keep themselves in the news.

Robb F

4,614 posts

202 months

Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I am deeply suspicious of any results obtained from the use of simulators as pictured in the article. I saw a news item about people driving too fast in fog where this was demonstrated using a simulator. The presenter was driving along a motorway with varying levels of visibility when a truck appeared on screen in front and the presenter crashed into it. The truck did not however appear at the limit of visibility it just popped into existance on an otherwise clear road at less than half of the viewing distance.

This may not be deliberate, it may just be that the simulator is not very good, the graphics certainly look like that are from the late 90's.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
it's Brake ...

you have to remember the basis of brake - the founding as an abnormal grieving response and the subsequent jumping on the bandwagon by the professional political class ...

MadRob6

3,594 posts

251 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Toltec said:
I am deeply suspicious of any results obtained from the use of simulators as pictured in the article. I saw a news item about people driving too fast in fog where this was demonstrated using a simulator. The presenter was driving along a motorway with varying levels of visibility when a truck appeared on screen in front and the presenter crashed into it. The truck did not however appear at the limit of visibility it just popped into existance on an otherwise clear road at less than half of the viewing distance.

This may not be deliberate, it may just be that the simulator is not very good, the graphics certainly look like that are from the late 90's.
That and people driving in simulators is nowhere near the same as driving in real life. For example I've had a few friends have a go on a racing simulator game I have with a full wheel set up and they don't use the brakes. These are people that drive in real life but can't apply the same rules to a simulation.

The whole phone situation could be summed up to "Some people are better at multitasking than others, if you can't concentrate on the road while talking to somebody then don't do it."

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I'd be quite happy to see the fine/points/level of enforcement for handheld phone use go up.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
covboy said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24982173



I know we’ve been through it before, but is that going to include our “highly trained” BIB and their communication systems ?
the reasons, emergency services radio and amateur radio equipment was not included in the original hand held equipment legislation was down to the simple fact that they aren't used like telphones and all users are trained in both operation and message handling / VP ...

once again one of the 'powerfully built' demonstrates their lack of knowledge and insight

selym

9,581 posts

202 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
creampuff said:
I'd be quite happy to see the fine/points/level of enforcement for handheld phone use go up.
So would I. Any enforcement would be an improvement. Hands free kits don't cost the earth.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
covboy said:
I know we’ve been through it before, but is that going to include our “highly trained” BIB and their communication systems ?
Yes I think it is quite likely Old Bill will be banned from using any communication equipment at all in their cars. They will get all updates, communications from other officers and all instructions from inside the station in a sit down chat with a cup of tea, with their patrol car safely switched off and parked outside.

Frik

13,696 posts

274 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I'm all for improving road safety, but BRAKE always seem to want to chase the wrong enemy.

Of course cynic in me considers this a not very subtle way of getting their larger agenda into the headlines.

wiliferus

4,225 posts

229 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I think I saw on the news Brake were suggesting that mobiles should be in the boot of car whilst on the move. Just madness?
What are Brake going to say the first time someone dies stuck in their car upside down in a ditch because they couldn't reach their mobile to call for help.

Personally I think an increase in the penalty would be acceptable. Not a financial increase as firstly it's just a tax, but secondly, to some financial penalties are meaningless if they have sufficient funds. I think 6 points would sharpen the mind of those considering doing it. That would really put people at risk of getting banned.

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
As much as I despise Brake, this is the logical conclusion from where we are now. All the evidence I've seen shows that it is the conversation without face-to-face contact that is potentially dangerous, not the act of holding the phone in your hand. The current law is poorly implemented and does little for road safety.

Either repeal the current law and go back to the perfectly acceptable position we had before which was covered by the careless driving law (I'm actually in favour of this approach) or extend it based on the scientific evidence. What will be amusing is that there are many regulars on here who were in favour of the mobile phone law, presumably because they had hands-free kits and adopted a holier than thou attitude. The only problem is that it won't end here. Next we'll have specific anti-eating and anti-drinking laws.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
The good thing about handsfree kits is that you cannot text, netsurf or read Facebook on them.

You can with a handheld phone.

GPSHead

657 posts

272 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I think driving is terrible and that this is a wonderful idea.

(Just getting it in before one of the usual suspects does...)

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
'Peter Rodger from the Institute of Advanced Motorists said a ban would be very difficult for the police to enforce and that a cultural change, which made it morally unacceptable to talk while driving, would be more effective.'

Better scrap the commentary from the IAM and RoSPA advanced driving tests then!

biglaugh

Oh dear, someone driving with a police driver trainer sat beside them in the car can show that they've seen and understood the sign without having to go anywhere near a simulator or wearing some S&M gag to stop them talking.


When education can drastically improve the performance of the most cerebrally challenged armchair critic, why would we not think that the same education and training could also apply to drivers?

confused

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
carinaman said:
'Peter Rodger from the Institute of Advanced Motorists said a ban would be very difficult for the police to enforce and that a cultural change, which made it morally unacceptable to talk while driving, would be more effective.'

Better scrap the commentary from the IAM and RoSPA advanced driving tests then!
A silly arguement. Do you not see the difference between a telephone conversation which could be about anything, but almost certain not to be about the drive and providing a one way commentary of your driving for the purposes of an assessment?


carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Isn't it dancing on the head of a needle while it slides down a slippery slope?

Before we know it, it'll be an offence to talk while pushing a pedal cycle or pass wind in your own car.

Is it a silly argument? I don't suppose I may have discussed the differences between talking to someone physically there in the car beside you and someone on the phone via a hands free with a driving instructor while having a refresher before a RoSPA test?

The IAM should be going on about the standard of driving and raising it. not vouching an opinion on how difficult something would be for the police to do their job. He's not the police is he. It was an opportunity to get the IAM brand out there, just as it was when they jumped to conclusions about raising the M-way speed limit after that terrible accident on the M5 at Taunton on 4 November 2011. The IAM have become leading purveyors of the soundbite, just like BRAKE!

If I wanted a religion I'd get one. The Bottom Inspectorate are bigger employer than the Arms Industry and HS2 will be.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
alock said:
As much as I despise Brake, this is the logical conclusion from where we are now. All the evidence I've seen shows that it is the conversation without face-to-face contact that is potentially dangerous, not the act of holding the phone in your hand. The current law is poorly implemented and does little for road safety.

Either repeal the current law and go back to the perfectly acceptable position we had before which was covered by the careless driving law (I'm actually in favour of this approach) or extend it based on the scientific evidence. What will be amusing is that there are many regulars on here who were in favour of the mobile phone law, presumably because they had hands-free kits and adopted a holier than thou attitude. The only problem is that it won't end here. Next we'll have specific anti-eating and anti-drinking laws.
We are currently in a compromise situation and there's no reason why we shouldn't stay exactly where we are.