Minor insurance industry rant
Minor insurance industry rant
Author
Discussion

5lab

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

227 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
My car got reversed into the other day whilst at a petrol station. No injuries, the woman reversing admitted liability, its on CCTV, all good. Nice clear-cut situation. The car in question is a 1989 944 S2. There's probably £600 of damage to it if I sorted it out using used parts (ie if I had done the damage myself) - maybe double that for a porsche approved place to repair it. The car was worth about £3000 (no idea on book value - but 944 S2s are priced all over the place - anywhere between 2k with interstella milage to 15k for pristine - mine is relatively low miles but has a previous accident repaired in 1999 (cat C)).

The woman sent me her policy details - HSBC. So I ring them up. 'sorry, we can't deal with a member of public'. So basically their forcing me down the path of an accident management company or a claim through my insurers, pushing up their costs.

So off I go to phone my insurers, explaining I don't want to claim off my policy, just push it through theirs 'sorry sir, you have to pay us your £800 excess up front'. I explain to them that I don't have £800 to hand, and I wasn't going to pay. After much hassle they agree that the repairers could quote, but not do any work until liability was agreed (thus avoiding a claim on my policy). Great. They recommend a local bodyshop, who I've never heard of. Frequently asked questions on their site suggests they only use manufacture approved bodyshops. 'oh yes', they say 'it is kia approved'. I point out my car is not a kia and ask them to try again. Turns out they do have a porsche approved place, in Glasgow. I'd have to take my car to them. I'm in Brighton. I point out this is sub-optimal, and they agree I can use my own garage, so I find the nearest pork-approved place and they agree I can use them.

Fantastic. Now, we've passed your details onto a credit hire place, to get you a replacement car in the mean time. Cost to the claim? £250 a day. Lets assume it takes a week to find the parts (pretty rare), fit it and give it a spray - that's £1500.

Basically, it writes my car off. Which I'm fine with (I was thinking of selling anyway, so this removes a lot of the hassle) - but when people complain about high premiums, this is exactly why - a very simple claim has rocketed in cost due to 'policies' the company has in place which seem to only screw themselves out of cash.

tl:dr insurance companies suck.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
You could tell the exact same story, just in a different tone and it would show how great a service your insurance company have provided you.

They've allowed things to progress even though you can't afford the excess you chose. They've sorted out a courtesy car for you. They've allowed you to go to a garage of your choosing. All the while they're probably dealing with the third party's insurers on your behalf.

What's your problem?

bradjsmith88

117 posts

159 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Strange by HSBC - most insurers have teams to actively seek out claimants like you called third-party intervention teams.

I would wonder if it was a HSBC broker you contacted - as the HSBC actual insurance operation downsized some time ago - however back when they were active they were notoriously hard to do business with as a third-party (representative).

5lab

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

227 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
it was a broker - some law company (I'm not sure who). I asked if there was any way I could deal with them directly and they said no.

The problem isn't with what I have to do as a customer - its just an example of how they manage internally to drive up the cost of claims and there's little to nothing a customer can do to avoid it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Claim from the person that drove into you, dont bother with their insurance. If they choose not to forward stuff on to their insurer then you take them to the small claims court. It wont get that far but it is their insurance co refusing to deal with you then go directly to the person who had the accident.

Failing the above, pay £20 extra on your insurance to include insurance cover to claim back via a company.

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I thought you could only ever claim off your own policy and that your insurer passes the claim on to the 3rd party. Never heard of going direct to the 3rd party, or that you can somehow avoid having a claim on your own policy by doing so.

bradjsmith88

117 posts

159 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
5lab said:
it was a broker - some law company (I'm not sure who). I asked if there was any way I could deal with them directly and they said no.

The problem isn't with what I have to do as a customer - its just an example of how they manage internally to drive up the cost of claims and there's little to nothing a customer can do to avoid it.
Brokers don't deal with claims - they pass them to the insurer. Might have been prudent to find out who the actual insurer was - brokers won't give a flying!!

I'm sure the actual insurer wouldn't promote this practice however I agree that actions like this do drive up premiums - especially credit hire! Almost as bad as - if not worse than whiplash.

Insurers seem to employ a lot of monkeys - pay them peanuts and spend the money on inflated claims costs instead!

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
You don't have to accept credit hire. If you're happy to go without a car until liability is settled you can. Or you can fund a hire car yourself and claim it back from the 3rd party later.


Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
I thought you could only ever claim off your own policy and that your insurer passes the claim on to the 3rd party. Never heard of going direct to the 3rd party, or that you can somehow avoid having a claim on your own policy by doing so.
You can claim from the third party if you prefer to - in fact it's your only option if you're claiming for something which isn't covered by your own insurance (eg you've got 3rd party only insurance, or you're claiming for personal injury, or for that matter if you're a pedestrian hit by a car). You do still have to inform your own insurers of the accident.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
You can claim from the third party if you prefer to - in fact it's your only option if you're claiming for something which isn't covered by your own insurance (eg you've got 3rd party only insurance, or you're claiming for personal injury, or for that matter if you're a pedestrian hit by a car). You do still have to inform your own insurers of the accident.
Or you don't have courtesy car cover but you still insist on having a car at £250 per day. Then moan about premiums!

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
You can claim from the third party if you prefer to - in fact it's your only option if you're claiming for something which isn't covered by your own insurance (eg you've got 3rd party only insurance, or you're claiming for personal injury, or for that matter if you're a pedestrian hit by a car). You do still have to inform your own insurers of the accident.
What's the point given you'd still have to declare the claim?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,305 posts

181 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
5lab said:
The woman sent me her policy details - HSBC. So I ring them up. 'sorry, we can't deal with a member of public'.
This is your first problem, you got thru to an idiot. They don't get to choose who they deal with when a third party is claiming off them. They are providing their client with third party liability cover, you are the third party, so they need to deal with you. Ask to speak to someone in authority.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
You could tell the exact same story, just in a different tone and it would show how great a service your insurance company have provided you.

They've allowed things to progress even though you can't afford the excess you chose. They've sorted out a courtesy car for you. They've allowed you to go to a garage of your choosing. All the while they're probably dealing with the third party's insurers on your behalf.

What's your problem?
Spot on. The OP appears to be unhappy that his insurers have done what everyone else wants them to do.

wibble cb

4,183 posts

238 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
I thought you could only ever claim off your own policy and that your insurer passes the claim on to the 3rd party. Never heard of going direct to the 3rd party, or that you can somehow avoid having a claim on your own policy by doing so.
You used to be able to, years ago I had a a numpty reverse out of his parking spot directly into the side of my car, I got his details and dealt direct with his insurer,to the extent that they agreed to start repairs on my car before he even admitted liability, I didn't want/need a courtesy car, but the slight panel damage, paint and a new wheel still cost him 2,500 gbp...all for not looking in his rear view mirror before engaging reverse. I thought that the service provided back then was as good as it could have been.

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
Aretnap said:
You can claim from the third party if you prefer to - in fact it's your only option if you're claiming for something which isn't covered by your own insurance (eg you've got 3rd party only insurance, or you're claiming for personal injury, or for that matter if you're a pedestrian hit by a car). You do still have to inform your own insurers of the accident.
What's the point given you'd still have to declare the claim?
Your no claims bonus isn't affected, even temporarily (if a claim on your own policy is still unresolved at renewal time it can be a right PITA). You don't have to pay your excess up front. You get a replacement car if yours isn't roadworthy, even if your policy doesn't give you cover for one. (All assuming the accident is clearly the other guy's fault and liability isn't disputed). There are disadvantages too, for example you have to do more work yourself, and when dealing with an insurer other than your own you don't have the protection of the Financial Ombudsman if, eg, you don't like the valuation they put on your car.

Triple7

4,015 posts

268 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Seems a load of tosh. You CAN choose who repairs your car, on another thread the bodyshop will give you a car in the interim as that is the 'deal' between insurers and repairers. Don't accept a ridiculously expensive hire car, that ends up all costing us a fortune and makes the hire agency rich with our premiums.

In essence, nothing to do with your insurers. Call HSBC back, I assume you have the other party's details and peruse the claim. I had someone hit my car in a private car park, being a colleague they meet their details, and I sorted everything out with one call to their insurers.......

barryrs

5,053 posts

254 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
5lab said:
Fantastic. Now, we've passed your details onto a credit hire place, to get you a replacement car in the mean time. Cost to the claim? £250 a day. Lets assume it takes a week to find the parts (pretty rare), fit it and give it a spray - that's £1500.
I would think twice before taking a car at that rate as the third party insurer will most likely reject your claim and you will be liable for the difference. Most would consider £50-£60 a day for the average joe acceptable.

When my wife was bumped into her then insurer caused us loads of hassle by passing us off to an accident management company who in turn tried to start false injury claims. Albany assistance (the accident management co) then tried to get us a hire car but refused to tell me how much they would bill the 3rd party per day so i refused. The 3rd party insurer (Churchill i think) were excellent but Admiral caused all the agro and they didnt need to do anything.

5lab

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
so, update and a question..

Eventually the 3rd parties insurance underwriter (covea) phoned me up to tell me that they did want to take the claim directly, so I closed the case with my company, and opened one directly with them. All good. Agreed a low cost hire car whilst mine was in for repairs (focus @ £22/day), however I got a quote off the agreed repairer, which at £3800 inc vat (not sure if insurance companies pay vat?) - has written my car off. Still all good. Unfortunately, they're now playing silly buggers with the valuation.

I think the car's worth £3k - a couple of guides (its an old car, so not on glasses etc) suggest £5k for the condition. Insurance company think its £1700 (there are no cars for sale for that figure, in the whole of the UK) minus £400 to keep the salvage, and have sent me the cheque for £1300. They are telling me that if I cash the cheque, it won't impact my dispute on the value of the car.

Is this correct? I've bought a replacement car, so the money would be handy, but I'm vigilant not to do something which might harm my ability to claim the full value. If I cash the initial cheque, would that stop me persuing them with an accident management company/the ombudsman/the small claims court (all of which I think are valid options at the moment), or would my action be perceived as some form of acceptance?

Thanks in advance

JimmyConwayNW

3,664 posts

156 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
Do not take it and send evidence showing national searches for a similar vehicle and the prices involved.

jensenhealey2

163 posts

190 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
5lab - I expect Porsche Club GB have a valuation service, many clubs do. If you are a member they might be able to give you an authoritative figure, but I can see it may not be worth joining just fo r that unless you are thinkiing of another Porker.