Who is at fault?
Author
Discussion

Chicken

Original Poster:

143 posts

168 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
An accident occurred recently involving one of my colleagues and it sparked quite a lively debate at work.
30mph urban street. One of our vans moved out to overtake a cyclist, but realised that there wasn't enough space with oncoming traffic. They pulled back in, but the oncoming car was forced to slow. The oncoming car was then rear ended by another vehicle with minor damage.

Who is at fault? My stance is that both our driver, and the driver of the vehicle that rear-ended share responsibility. Others are saying its purely our drivers fault.

TIA

GaryGlitter

2,317 posts

214 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Has no-one suggested that the driver who actually rear-ended the oncoming vehicle is at fault, as it was they that failed to stop in time?


CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
GaryGlitter said:
Has no-one suggested that the driver who actually rear-ended the oncoming vehicle is at fault, as it was they that failed to stop in time?
This, completely, with no question (provided the original two vehicles mentioned in the OP did not make contact at any point, there is no culpability on either of those).

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Entirely the rear enders fault....

klingelton

70 posts

160 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Driver that rear ended is completely to blame. They should be reading the road ahead and adjusting their speed according to the conditions.

jatopack

179 posts

261 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
This is clear cut - IF you cannot stop in the available distance, you are travelling to closely.

IF an emergency stop by the lead vehicle - that is a different situation....but this situation the vehicle slowed.

The van driver is in the clear - the oncoming car is definitely not at fault - but the car following is at fault.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
The van driver could have been at fault had there been a collision but he was able to avoid it, whether by luck or judgement.

To establish negligence, you first have to establish the existence of a duty that could be breached, and 'but-for' causation (i.e., had the party alleged to be at fault not taken that action, would the accident still have occurred).

His driving may have been open to challenge but the question is whether he owed a duty that could be breached. Was he really obliged, in respect of the rear-ending driver (whom he possibly could not see) to avoid pulling out so that the car in front wouldn't have to slow down? Bear in mind that the car that was hit could have slowed down there for any reason - a cat running out, a passenger who suddenly wanted to be dropped off, mechanical failure etc., and the collision would have occurred without any fault on the van driver's part.

I could see a 90:10 split in a serious incident (if you can establish both duty and causation as above) but even if the van driver had handbrake turned across the path of the other car, once it had stopped in time it was completely in the following driver's power to avoid the collision by leaving a safe following distance and watching the road for hazards.

over_the_hill

3,340 posts

277 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
jatopack said:
This is clear cut - IF you cannot stop in the available distance, you are travelling to closely.

IF an emergency stop by the lead vehicle - that is a different situation....but this situation the vehicle slowed.

The van driver is in the clear - the oncoming car is definitely not at fault - but the car following is at fault.
Even if the lead vehicle does an emergency stop it is still the fault of the rear ender. They should not be so close that they can not pull up in time.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Chicken said:
Who is at fault? My stance is that both our driver, and the driver of the vehicle that rear-ended share responsibility. Others are saying its purely our drivers fault.

TIA
Seriously? Incredible.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
CAPP0 said:
GaryGlitter said:
Has no-one suggested that the driver who actually rear-ended the oncoming vehicle is at fault, as it was they that failed to stop in time?
This, completely, with no question (provided the original two vehicles mentioned in the OP did not make contact at any point, there is no culpability on either of those).
This.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
over_the_hill said:
jatopack said:
This is clear cut - IF you cannot stop in the available distance, you are travelling to closely.

IF an emergency stop by the lead vehicle - that is a different situation....but this situation the vehicle slowed.

The van driver is in the clear - the oncoming car is definitely not at fault - but the car following is at fault.
Even if the lead vehicle does an emergency stop it is still the fault of the rear ender. They should not be so close that they can not pull up in time.
Absolutely.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Perhaps you should re-word the original thread. Your vehicle was not “involved” in an accident, but was witness to one ?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
The shunting car is at fault.

There are some exceptional circumstances where the shunting car might not be at fault (or not 100% at fault) but this doesn't seem to be one of them.

In a 30 limit then you should always have space to stop regardless of what the car in front does.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
In a 30 limit then you should always have space to stop regardless of what the car in front does.
Shirly you should do that whatever the limit ?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
covboy said:
Snowboy said:
In a 30 limit then you should always have space to stop regardless of what the car in front does.
Shirly you should do that whatever the limit ?
I don't disagree in theory.
But, in practice if I'm following a car on a 60mph A road and they go from 60mph to emergency stop for no reason I can see there's a good chance I'll crash.
Or perhaps on the motorway or a dual carriageway.

If one sees brake lights one doesn't assume an emergency stop.
It'll depend a lot on the exact details of the moment, how close I am, how alert I am, how quickly I realise it's stppong not just slowing etc.

But, I think it's fair to say that in a 30 limit drivers should be ready for sudden stops.

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
over_the_hill said:
jatopack said:
This is clear cut - IF you cannot stop in the available distance, you are travelling to closely.

IF an emergency stop by the lead vehicle - that is a different situation....but this situation the vehicle slowed.

The van driver is in the clear - the oncoming car is definitely not at fault - but the car following is at fault.
Even if the lead vehicle does an emergency stop it is still the fault of the rear ender. They should not be so close that they can not pull up in time.
Absolutely.
I think you'll find it's not necessarily the case that the van driver is 100% in the clear.

There are plenty of examples where blame has been apportioned to a driver, even though that driver made no contact with anyone or anything in a crash resulting from their actions.

But yes, primary blame is with the driver following to closely.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
I think you'll find it's not necessarily the case that the van driver is 100% in the clear.

There are plenty of examples where blame has been apportioned to a driver, even though that driver made no contact with anyone or anything in a crash resulting from their actions.

But yes, primary blame is with the driver following to closely.
Basing this on what exactly? This is a minor shunt.

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
I don't disagree in theory.
But, in practice if I'm following a car on a 60mph A road and they go from 60mph to emergency stop for no reason I can see there's a good chance I'll crash.
Or perhaps on the motorway or a dual carriageway.

If one sees brake lights one doesn't assume an emergency stop.
It'll depend a lot on the exact details of the moment, how close I am, how alert I am, how quickly I realise it's stppong not just slowing etc.

But, I think it's fair to say that in a 30 limit drivers should be ready for sudden stops.
Have you considered leaving more space, especially if you're not feeling alert? If not, why not?

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Centurion07 said:
I think you'll find it's not necessarily the case that the van driver is 100% in the clear.

There are plenty of examples where blame has been apportioned to a driver, even though that driver made no contact with anyone or anything in a crash resulting from their actions.

But yes, primary blame is with the driver following to closely.
Basing this on what exactly? This is a minor shunt.
Based in no small part on a post YOU made IIRC! biggrin

My answer was not so much in relation to this minor shunt, as addressing the fact that people seemed to hold the view that as long as driver A makes no contact with anyone else involved in a collision they could be seen to have had some involvement in causing, that driver A gets away completely scott-free. Not only in terms of damage but from a legal standpoint as well.

As you seem to be inferring, probably not relevant to a minor shunt such as this.

Quite happy to be corrected if anything I said is wrong.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
there's clearly more to this story
the way this story has been told no one in their right mind would consider the van driver even 50% at fault, let alone 100%