parking ticket-fight it or not?
parking ticket-fight it or not?
Author
Discussion

jamieclueless

Original Poster:

3,701 posts

193 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
I recently parked at a roadside in Edinburgh in a marked bay alongside a pay and display meter, I went to buy a ticket but noted it was outside of the pay and display time window (it ended at 4:30 and I parked at 5:35) . When I returned to the car I had ben issued with a ticket for parking in a no-waiting area. I then carefully studied all the surrounding road signs and markings to find that part of the area was a no waiting area during rush hour (4:30 to 6) and that is why I received the ticket. The bay in which my car was parked was very clearly marked with a dotted white line, but on closer examination there were also remnants of a solid yellow line alongside the kerb. I wrote to the authority disputing the offence had been committed as the area had not been properly marked as a no waiting area.
I have received their reply stating that they are unable to cancel the ticket as while they did not dispute 'that small parts of the line may be slightly broken' they 'considered' that the 'remaining yellow lines and kerb markings are sufficiently clear' to enforce the ticket.
Part of me (the bit that listens to my wife) says it's only £30, just pay it and be done with it, but I'm inclined to risk doubling it to £60 and take the challenge to the next level.
What do my fellow PHers think?
My car is the elderly golf alongside the meter in the photo, it's only badly parked because I'd started to pull away then thought 'I'd better get a picture' and nipped back briefly so please don't put me in the bad parking thread (and no suggestions that the second time it was worse because I knowingly committed the offence by reparking to take the photo).


HustleRussell

26,709 posts

191 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Fight, always fight. You've nothing to lose- they freeze the usual 'doubling of the fina after two weeks' if you dispute it...

shocks

803 posts

195 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all

I'd fight it. Which road is this ? Looks like Bruntsfield / Morningside ?

Was the sign for no-waiting close to the bay ?

The facts remain it is an active bay, unless the sign is right beside the bays themselves - how would you know it was a no-waiting during xyz hours ?

Think Edinburgh appeal to parking fine revenue generation dept rejects out of hand in most cases, see 02 in their list of reasons in your case :

http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/info/1274/tickets_clam...

Then get on to these folks :

http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/scotland/consumer_s/...

jamieclueless

Original Poster:

3,701 posts

193 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
shocks said:
I'd fight it. Which road is this ? Looks like Bruntsfield / Morningside ?

Was the sign for no-waiting close to the bay ?

The facts remain it is an active bay, unless the sign is right beside the bays themselves - how would you know it was a no-waiting during xyz hours ?
Yes it was Bruntsfield Road . This sign was about 20 metres away at the top of Montpelier Street. I'd never seen one of these multi-use signboards before and at first thought it meant that the metered area was in the direction of the arrow (where I was parked) and the other notices referred to the other direction. I'm not denying that the area was a no waiting area, just that it was difficult to work this out from the combination of signage and road markings (especially for a visiting country bumpkin like myself).

Terminator X

21,017 posts

235 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
The LA will never back down in my experience as it's simpler / better for them to just say no to anyone that dares challenge a ticket. Take it to the adjudicator as you'll only lose the ability to pay 50% of the fine. I like to make them work for their 100% rather than do nothing for their 50% but that might just be me!

TX.

Edit - that sign is a horror, what on earth does the left hand side indicate as it contradicts the right hand side?

Edited by Terminator X on Wednesday 20th November 12:56

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
As deliberately confusing as that sign tries to be, if you think about it carefully and read it it's not too difficult to end up at the fact that you were too early to be abandoning there.

Pay up IMHO, I think it'd be luck more than justice if you were to get away with an appeal.

jamieclueless

Original Poster:

3,701 posts

193 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Randomthoughts said:
As deliberately confusing as that sign tries to be, if you think about it carefully and read it it's not too difficult to end up at the fact that you were too early to be abandoning there.

Pay up IMHO, I think it'd be luck more than justice if you were to get away with an appeal.
The point is that I didn't see the sign till after I got the ticket and went looking for it and even at that took a while to work it out. I parked at what I could see was a clearly marked parking bay next to a ticket machine. Yes there was also a (very damaged) single yellow line which I thought was irrelevant.

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
jamieclueless said:
The point is that I didn't see the sign till after I got the ticket and went looking for it and even at that took a while to work it out. I parked at what I could see was a clearly marked parking bay next to a ticket machine. Yes there was also a (very damaged) single yellow line which I thought was irrelevant.
So you parked in a bay and didn't go looking for the conditions or restrictions?

Whilst this could be less confusing, you failed to do what would be expected of a normal individual when entering into a contract (to park).

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Whether you fight it or not is your call.
But either way, you could suggest that the fix that sign information to all the pay and display machines.

jamieclueless

Original Poster:

3,701 posts

193 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Randomthoughts said:
jamieclueless said:
The point is that I didn't see the sign till after I got the ticket and went looking for it and even at that took a while to work it out. I parked at what I could see was a clearly marked parking bay next to a ticket machine. Yes there was also a (very damaged) single yellow line which I thought was irrelevant.
So you parked in a bay and didn't go looking for the conditions or restrictions?

Whilst this could be less confusing, you failed to do what would be expected of a normal individual when entering into a contract (to park).
I parked in the bay then went to the machine where I read a notice on the meter that it was only a pay and display area up to 4:30 so assumed that parking was free after that.

Craivold

172 posts

231 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
If you're ok with accepting the risk that you have to pay the full 100% of the fine if you lose at adjudication then you should definitely fight it, the signage is surely not sufficient enough (and confusing) for your appeal to be considered by the Third Party Tribunal. The council should be making more of an effort to make people aware of all the regulations if they are going to make it so complex and then include simple, and misleading information, on the parking meters like "No charge after 4.30pm".

As someone else said above the councils say no to everyone I think, I had a case recently against North Devon Council where my valid ticket had moved from the dash to my seat, they rejected my appeal twice and when I submitted all the supporting information to TPT they suddenly changed their tune and said they would cancel the penalty charge "on the grounds of fairness"... Not sure why they couldn't do that first time round the greedy sh@ts.

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
jamieclueless said:
I parked in the bay then went to the machine where I read a notice on the meter that it was only a pay and display area up to 4:30 so assumed that parking was free after that.
Again, easy mistake to make but the conditions of parking on public roads have to be displayed on the sign as they have been and you subsequently located.

Sorry, you're on to a loser here IMHO. As I say, the best I expect you'll get is a lucky escape because the lines are broken. There certainly won't be any substantial challenge to it based on where the sign is based on your description.

AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Randomthoughts said:
jamieclueless said:
I parked in the bay then went to the machine where I read a notice on the meter that it was only a pay and display area up to 4:30 so assumed that parking was free after that.
Again, easy mistake to make but the conditions of parking on public roads have to be displayed on the sign as they have been and you subsequently located.

Sorry, you're on to a loser here IMHO. As I say, the best I expect you'll get is a lucky escape because the lines are broken. There certainly won't be any substantial challenge to it based on where the sign is based on your description.
I wouldn't say you are automatically on to a loser, I would contest the ticket to your local council first of all stating that the signage is unclear.

.blue

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
I would only not contest if you knowingly parked in bay that wasn't OK to park in.

If the facts are that the only sign that said you couldn't park where you had parked was 20m away from the space, you have every right to contest it. If you do, there's at least a chance they will put a sign up where it can be seen and others avoid having to pay for tickets.

For more advice check out pepipoo: I would have thought that having a clearly marked parking bay as well as a yellow line falls foul of the guidelines.

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Well you have parked on a single yellow where you cant park but in a parking bay where you can, I would say that constitutes confusion.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
I see nothing confusing about the sign. It is laid out from the top down. A photograph of the signage on the P&D machine might be instructive, but parking in any town/city centre without carefully checking and understanding all the relevant nearby (and far away on entry to a CPZ) signs is fraught with risk.

Streaky

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Even though it says no loading at any time and then says no loading monday to friday etc. If its not a confusing sign you tell me when or if you can load.

moreflaps

746 posts

186 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Pay up, sorry. The yellow one is the one you needed to obey...

Cheers

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
It may be correct, it may be wrong but for an extra £30 I would fight it all the way, ask the council for the TRO, get them working for the money, ask for a personal hearing at PATAS or whatever its called.

When you have done all that get your money back by other means, when you were thinking of going back to that town dont bother, but it on Amazon instead. I walked to the supermarket every week for a year until I got back my £60 cost for no seat belt FPN in saved fuel costs.

Frik

13,692 posts

274 months

Thursday 21st November 2013
quotequote all
Or just pay £30, get on with your life and stop wasting other people's time and your taxes.

The sign is confusing at first but ultimately clear about when you can and can't park.