Death. Inquest and Lawyers
Author
Discussion

3Dee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

252 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
A friend has just suffered the death of her dad (early 70s) over the weekend and today she mentioned that the death was going to inquest.

It appears that her Dad had a heart bypass several years ago and had been put on statins for the forseeable. he bypass was a success and he was well.

Then a few months ago he was diagnosed with anaemia and a senior consultant took him off statins whilst he was on a course of new medication for what was to take 4 months. Apparently there was a risk of serious problems with combining both medications.

Last week Dad went for a routine GP review and a locum (not his normal doctor) started the statins again.
Within a few days he was feeling very ill with rapid muscle wastage + other complications, and he was rushed into hospital where there was an attempt to flush out all the medication, but he died of kidney failure.

An inquest has been scheduled and the family has been advised that they might wish to attend and have a lawyer present.

From what I know, it appears that there is a potential for the court to find that the locum was culpable.
Would I be right?
...and how important is it for the family to be represented by a lawyer actually at the inquest? or could they (if they really felt justified) take on a lawyer after the inquest to review the case?

Most of the family don't want fuss after they have lost their Dad, BUT should it be shown that serious medical deficiencies had actually caused the death, (would a lawyer help at the inquest to frame the right questions to get at the truth?) then they don't want to take the option away from the wife if that is what she wants in the end.

Perhaps some legal-eagles could comment?

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Get a solicitor / counsel sooner rather than later.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
yes , get some legal advice ASAP.

As a bit of background, if a death is expected and a patient has been seen by a GP (or hospital Doctor) within the last (from memory) week then the GP (or hospital Doctor) can 'sign off' the death certificate and there will be no inquest at his/her option (and there will be liaison between the dying patient's GP and the coroner's office before the patient passes on in the case of general Practice). This is not, I assume, the case here frown .

Unexpected deaths are reported to the coroner who decides if an inquest is required. The coroner's office liaises with the deceased's GP from the earliest stages after the deceased has passed on and also as the process moves along (including requesting a letter from the GP regarding the deceased's medical background and medication and any other important/salient info, plus possibly an appearance at the inquest by the deceased's GP to give evidence) smile .

What I'm trying to say here is that, in this particular case, the involvement of the coroner's office and mention of an inquest isn't as serious as it appears at this stage (it is in fact more routine than many people think) smile .

Rushjob

2,318 posts

289 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
I was involved in an odd little inquest some years ago when I went to a flat to break in as an elderly lady had collapsed.

Whilst waiting for Ambo to arrive, the lady's GP appeared ( the surgery was just round the corner ) and started to treat her, part of which involved him administering an injection.

Thought nothing more of it, waited for the council to arrive to secure the flat as she'd been taken to hospital alive but confused and then carried on with my beat.

After my weekend off, I arrived at work to be told to get on with the Coroners File for the sudden death I'd been to on Friday.

Soon worked out that the lady mentioned above had subsequently died over the weekend so cracked on with statements and visiting the flat again with the son of the deceased to seize any medication etc which was standard procedure, for some reason whilst there I did a quick bin dive and recovered the ampoule for the injection given by the Doctor.

Many weeks later I'm called to Coroner's Court to give evidence at the Inquest.

In my narrative I mentioned the injection - as soon as I said this a lawyer jumped up ( turned out he was representing the GP ) and started telling me I didn't understand what the treatment involved and that I was mistaken and no injection was administered.

With the permission of the Coroner, I reached into my grab bag and produced the medication etc. to the Coroner.

On seeing the ampoule I'd recovered, the proceedings were suspended.

Turned out, the GP had failed to inform either the Ambulance crew or Hospital about the injection and there had been some sort of massive reaction when she was treated at the hospital and had also "lost" the relevant page of her notes and accidentally missed out mentioning the injection when he produced his report to the Coroner - following the inquest being resumed the GP decided to come clean - the GP ended up being struck off for it.

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Wednesday 20th November 2013
quotequote all
Get in touch with these folks, they know their stuff http://www.avma.org.uk/

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
3Dee said:
From what I know, it appears that there is a potential for the court to find that the locum was culpable.
Would I be right?
...and how important is it for the family to be represented by a lawyer actually at the inquest? or could they (if they really felt justified) take on a lawyer after the inquest to review the case?

...
The Coroner's Court cannot and does not apportion blame or establish civil or criminal liability. It investigates the cause of death.

The relatives can ask or have a lawyer ask questions of witnesses at the Inquest, but can't make submissions as to the facts. If there is an apparent case of negligence, the family might wish to be represented, but the loss arising from the death of a man in his 70s would usually be small. If there is real concern that the doctor was careless, a complaint via the NHS and/or to the GMC might be an option.

Rushjob

2,318 posts

289 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
The Coroner's Court cannot and does not apportion blame or establish civil or criminal liability. It investigates the cause of death.

The relatives can ask or have a lawyer ask questions of witnesses at the Inquest, but can't make submissions as to the facts. If there is an apparent case of negligence, the family might wish to be represented, but the loss arising from the death of a man in his 70s would usually be small. If there is real concern that the doctor was careless, a complaint via the NHS and/or to the GMC might be an option.
This is the way that the case I was involved in followed.
The admission by the GP that he'd failed to update the hospital and omitted it from his report became a matter of record, the family then quite rightly IMHO complained to the GMC and NHS.

3Dee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

252 months

Friday 22nd November 2013
quotequote all
Thanks Breaders (Hi!) and thanks all... a really difficult time for the family and I have made them aware of the potential cost of any litigation (if it seemed to them appropriate) with the potential for not much in the way of return if any. I think they agree that this is not perhaps the best route to be thinking about especially at this early stage, and when emotions are raw, even though I do know that the information they have points to the supposition that a combination of drugs that should never have been taken together. Of course this may or may not be supported by the coroners findings.

I think they will probably just attend the inquest to listen, and then when and if they they feel it appropriate, make a complaint to the PCT, as on the surface it seems that the Locum involved may have made a big error of judgement when reinstating the statins without seeking prior and explicit advice from the Consultant involved. The family would not want this to happen to anyone else.

I am sure things will come out in the wash...