Chief Con admits crime figures con
Discussion
BBC News Mobile said:
Crime statistics are manipulated, says police chief
Mr Creedon's comments look set to fuel a debate on the reliability of crime data
An "obsession" with reducing crime is creating pressure on police to "manipulate" crime figures, a senior police officer has said.
Derbyshire's Chief Constable Mick Creedon said numerous officers in "many forces" had told him it was happening.
He said officers were "doing everything they can" to avoid crime going up.
Policing Minister Damian Green said a "robust" inquiry into recording practices by the Inspectorate of Constabulary would report next autumn.
On Tuesday, MPs heard claims that forces were routinely manipulating crime statistics to meet targets.
BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said it was the first time a chief constable had spoken out in this way and his comments would fuel a debate about the reliability of crime data.
Mr Creedon, who speaks for the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) on organised crime, insisted the "real position" was that domestic violence and sexual violence were going up.
He said manipulation of the figures was the "unintended consequence" of pressure from police leaders, inspections and plans drawn up by police and crime commissioners to cut crime.
Addressing the Acpo conference, he said: "Inadvertently we are putting pressure on officers to do all they can to manipulate to create crime reductions."
Peter Fahy, Greater Manchester Police's chief constable, said it was not about "fiddling" figures, but about the way forces chose to categorise various types of offence.
"There's a huge field of interpretation," he said.
Mr Fahy said it was time to move away from the police figures and focus more on the Crime Survey for England and Wales - which draws estimates of crime levels from speaking to 35,000 members of the public.
Meanwhile, Mr Green told the conference that crimes measured by the survey were falling and were less than half of the peak seen in 1995.
The minister said it would be "unacceptable" if police were found to be manipulating the data, adding the Inspectorate of Constabulary's recording practices review would report in autumn 2014.
Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe said mis-recording crime "can never be right".
And Chief Constable Jeff Farrar, Acpo's spokesman on crime recording, insisted that "nobody joins the police service with the intention of recording crime inaccurately".
But he acknowledged that issues including a lack of awareness and knowledge, work pressures, system errors and "the possible pressure to achieve local performance targets" may all contribute to human error.
On Tuesday, Metropolitan Police constable James Patrick - who is currently awaiting disciplinary proceedings - told the House of Commons public administration committee his concerns about crime under-reporting had begun after he joined the force in 2009.
He said he had found robberies being logged as "theft snatch" in order to get them off the books.
And a former West Midlands chief inspector described practices such as recording thefts as "lost property".
Committee chairman, Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin, said he was "shocked" by the claims of such manipulation "on such a wide scale".
Pretty much what has been said here repeatedly, and denied by our BiB.Mr Creedon's comments look set to fuel a debate on the reliability of crime data
An "obsession" with reducing crime is creating pressure on police to "manipulate" crime figures, a senior police officer has said.
Derbyshire's Chief Constable Mick Creedon said numerous officers in "many forces" had told him it was happening.
He said officers were "doing everything they can" to avoid crime going up.
Policing Minister Damian Green said a "robust" inquiry into recording practices by the Inspectorate of Constabulary would report next autumn.
On Tuesday, MPs heard claims that forces were routinely manipulating crime statistics to meet targets.
BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said it was the first time a chief constable had spoken out in this way and his comments would fuel a debate about the reliability of crime data.
Mr Creedon, who speaks for the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) on organised crime, insisted the "real position" was that domestic violence and sexual violence were going up.
He said manipulation of the figures was the "unintended consequence" of pressure from police leaders, inspections and plans drawn up by police and crime commissioners to cut crime.
Addressing the Acpo conference, he said: "Inadvertently we are putting pressure on officers to do all they can to manipulate to create crime reductions."
Peter Fahy, Greater Manchester Police's chief constable, said it was not about "fiddling" figures, but about the way forces chose to categorise various types of offence.
"There's a huge field of interpretation," he said.
Mr Fahy said it was time to move away from the police figures and focus more on the Crime Survey for England and Wales - which draws estimates of crime levels from speaking to 35,000 members of the public.
Meanwhile, Mr Green told the conference that crimes measured by the survey were falling and were less than half of the peak seen in 1995.
The minister said it would be "unacceptable" if police were found to be manipulating the data, adding the Inspectorate of Constabulary's recording practices review would report in autumn 2014.
Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe said mis-recording crime "can never be right".
And Chief Constable Jeff Farrar, Acpo's spokesman on crime recording, insisted that "nobody joins the police service with the intention of recording crime inaccurately".
But he acknowledged that issues including a lack of awareness and knowledge, work pressures, system errors and "the possible pressure to achieve local performance targets" may all contribute to human error.
On Tuesday, Metropolitan Police constable James Patrick - who is currently awaiting disciplinary proceedings - told the House of Commons public administration committee his concerns about crime under-reporting had begun after he joined the force in 2009.
He said he had found robberies being logged as "theft snatch" in order to get them off the books.
And a former West Midlands chief inspector described practices such as recording thefts as "lost property".
Committee chairman, Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin, said he was "shocked" by the claims of such manipulation "on such a wide scale".
Streaky
streaky said:
Pretty much what has been said here repeatedly, and denied by our BiB.
It's never been politically advantageous to really be bothered about this. I wonder what's spurred them on now. I know HMRC have been a little more interested in this of late and there are now departments to really ensure NCRS is complied with. We're recoding all sorts of rubbish now. I couldn't care less about the data or politics, but I don't want to be wasting 10 minutes recording a minor crime against a criminal who couldn't care less. There's a couple of things to add:
1) I've always speculated that the degree of manipulation is consistent, so the relative gains and losses have value.
2) As mentioned in the article, the Crime Survey of England and Wales shows reductions, which makes me question the scale in which this goes on. I don't think it's that statistically relevant as most crime is recorded directly by the relevant department who have someone in there from the Home Office who ensures the required standards are complied with.
3) I think we're coming to a saturation point in terms of reductions. You can't keep reducing things forever and this has been one of the main 'performance' measurements year after year. And guess what the Commissioners have done? Yep, more reduction targets. The problem is the reductions aren't forthcoming because you can only squeeze so much juice out of the orange, both in actual reductions and manipulated ones.
If I were a cynical and speculative Man, I'd suggest the political establishment have realised this and when recorded crime inevitably rises, it'll be because "the police used to record it incorrectly", which will really mask the fact it's hard to keep on reducing things when making large funding cuts.
streaky said:
Pretty much what has been said here repeatedly, and denied by our BiB.
Streaky
Has this been denied by the police, ex and current, on here?Streaky
What isn't said in the article is that the government is complicit, or at least the Home Office. The figures need to come down and to ensure they do they pay money to the forces when it does. Fiddling figures is hardly unique to the police.
With regards to what are reported as robberies being crimed as thefts: tell that to the CPS.
As for thefts being reported as lost property: Someone phones to say that they had their mobile stolen but don't know when or where. "I had it with me when I was got out of the taxi but four clubs and a dozen drinks later when I was sitting in the gutter wanting to phone Wayne, it wasn't there. Someone must have stolen it."
If force A finds a way to cut their robberies by creative interpretation of the facts then the force in the same family with higher figures will not be praised by the HMIC. Quite the reverse. They will be threatened. The HO will be thrilled by the lower figures. There will be a HO Circular about it, with demands that other forces follow suit.
The suggestion of the article is that this is dishonest police trying to cover their lack of ability by telling lies. Not the way I see it. This is a way of police forces coping with the unreasonable demands of the HO and government, with the full knowledge of the HO and government.
La Liga said:
If I were a cynical and speculative Man, I'd suggest the political establishment have realised this and when recorded crime inevitably rises, it'll be because "the police used to record it incorrectly", which will really mask the fact it's hard to keep on reducing things when making large funding cuts.
Nail and head. The whole crime statistic game has been manipulated and changed by Politicians throughout my whole Police career. I've had a number of stand up arguments with our crime recorders, who operate to the latest Political dictact from the Home Office. It was horrendous under Blunkett, it hasn't really changed since.
Elroy Blue said:
I think you'll find we've been saying the much trumpeted fall in crime is a sham. Cameron's fanboys however then go on the verbal attack and accuse us making it up for political purposes.
You've been claiming the credit. Now the lies are being exposed you're trying to shift the blame.
Shane on you.
Rovinghawk said:
Elroy Blue said:
I think you'll find we've been saying the much trumpeted fall in crime is a sham. Cameron's fanboys however then go on the verbal attack and accuse us making it up for political purposes.
You've been claiming the credit. Now the lies are being exposed you're trying to shift the blame.
Shane on you.
Don't get me wrong, there are many other factors that have / may have influenced that, but it stands there as objective data.
Elroy Blue said:
Rovinghawk said:
You've been claiming the credit.
Now the lies are being exposed you're trying to shift the blame.
Shane on you.
The thread has just ended. The troll has arrived. Now the lies are being exposed you're trying to shift the blame.
Shane on you.

You think he would have learned to be a bit more subtle by now, but I guess the urge to put the boot in, no mater how unjustified, just overwhelms him. He should be reported for under-reporting his own crimes against logic.
La Liga said:
don't think that's the case. It's more complicated than that. The Crime Survey for England and Wales has shown reductions since the mid-1990s, quite a few years prior to the current method of police statistics.
Don't get me wrong, there are many other factors that have / may have influenced that, but it stands there as objective data.
I think the essence of the British Crime Survey is that it is subjective: experiential. That's not to criticise it in any way. Evidence of what a person believes is still evidence. Whether the data becomes objective if one compares one year with another is open to argument.Don't get me wrong, there are many other factors that have / may have influenced that, but it stands there as objective data.
It's not just England , this has been making headlines north of the border the last couple of weeks. This is from a recent Daily Record.
It is particularly worrying that, under Sir Stephen’s ( House ) watch, crime figures have become “more selective”.
The revelation adds to mounting evidence that the police are becoming unnecessarily secretive about their activities.
In August, our sister paper the Sunday Mail carried out an investigation into the transparency of Police Scotland and their reporting of crime figures.
On one Saturday in July the only incidents the police said had happened in the whole of Scotland were a couple of road crashes and a handful of music festival arrests.
But in fact, 1921 crimes were reported to Police Scotland that day, including two attempted murders, four rapes, 12 sex attacks, 16 serious assaults, 13 arson attacks and three robberies.
The public are not stupid. They know that crime is taking place in their communities because they see it with their own eyes – so for the force to deny it is happening is laughable.
It is particularly worrying that, under Sir Stephen’s ( House ) watch, crime figures have become “more selective”.
The revelation adds to mounting evidence that the police are becoming unnecessarily secretive about their activities.
In August, our sister paper the Sunday Mail carried out an investigation into the transparency of Police Scotland and their reporting of crime figures.
On one Saturday in July the only incidents the police said had happened in the whole of Scotland were a couple of road crashes and a handful of music festival arrests.
But in fact, 1921 crimes were reported to Police Scotland that day, including two attempted murders, four rapes, 12 sex attacks, 16 serious assaults, 13 arson attacks and three robberies.
The public are not stupid. They know that crime is taking place in their communities because they see it with their own eyes – so for the force to deny it is happening is laughable.
La Liga said:
The headline figures are quantifiable. If someone is asked if they've been a victim of assault then I think most people across the country will have a consistent definition of what being assaulted is. The same with having a vehicle stolen etc.
And the definition of theft is? And that of robbery? Having a car stolen is the classic case of course.It is common for someone to phone to report a robbery. "I've just returned to my house and the front door's been kicked in."
Further, most people do no understand what, legally, an assault is.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




