Hired van,off duty plod spotted unidentified driver on phone
Discussion
We had a hired van(while our vehicle was in for repair) This was driven by at least three different workmen.On the last day of the hire it was 'spotted' by an off duty police officer who has 'caught' the driver using a mobile phone.
Having discussed the matter with all possible drivers no one had any recollection of the incident.
We have spoken to the Police control to see if they can give us a description of the driver,also asked if the off duty plod made any attempt to alert the driver of alleged traffic offemce they seemed to get a bit vague and stated that they will ring us back with details,despite me ringing them back a further two times seeking this info i'm still waitng.....
As this happened on the last day of the hire when the van was also collected if could also have been the hire companys driver at fault.
All thoughts on the best way to proceed.
To cap it off the insurance company that provided us with the van have sent us a £50+vat for sending the letter out!
Having discussed the matter with all possible drivers no one had any recollection of the incident.
We have spoken to the Police control to see if they can give us a description of the driver,also asked if the off duty plod made any attempt to alert the driver of alleged traffic offemce they seemed to get a bit vague and stated that they will ring us back with details,despite me ringing them back a further two times seeking this info i'm still waitng.....
As this happened on the last day of the hire when the van was also collected if could also have been the hire companys driver at fault.
All thoughts on the best way to proceed.
To cap it off the insurance company that provided us with the van have sent us a £50+vat for sending the letter out!
The first thing to ascertain is whether it was in your possession at the date/time of the offence and was in the location given. If not return the S172 saying that. Claim the money back that you have been charged for the letter.
If it was in your possession then you need to ascertain who of the three staff was driving by making diligent efforts. When you have done that send the S172 back either nominating the driver or say you are unable to despite your efforts. The police will then do the rest.
If it was in your possession then you need to ascertain who of the three staff was driving by making diligent efforts. When you have done that send the S172 back either nominating the driver or say you are unable to despite your efforts. The police will then do the rest.
Don't nominate one driver - if it's the wrong one it might be PCoJ for you personally (which is bad).
I'm Not a Lawyer.
Assuming the form has been sent to the company rather than to you personally, send the form back, but attach a letter to it (write "PLEASE SEE ATTACHED" across the form in case the two get "accidentally" separated). On the letter, explain to the police that you have looked into it as much as possible but you are unable to determine who would have been driving the van at the time. Then give all of the details for all of the possible drivers.
Here's the relevant bit of the law.
Since the first NIP in the chain went to the rental company, the requirement on subsequent NIPees is lower. Added to that, the normal "You should keep a record of who has the keys" is at least partially negated when you have a short term hire vehicle.
If they believe you are taking the piss a bit then they'll charge the company with S.172 which is a slightly bigger fine but at least nobody gets any points. It's only if they think you've actively trying to hide information that they'll go for you personally.
I'm Not a Lawyer.
Assuming the form has been sent to the company rather than to you personally, send the form back, but attach a letter to it (write "PLEASE SEE ATTACHED" across the form in case the two get "accidentally" separated). On the letter, explain to the police that you have looked into it as much as possible but you are unable to determine who would have been driving the van at the time. Then give all of the details for all of the possible drivers.
Here's the relevant bit of the law.
S172 said:
(2)Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—
(a)the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and
(b)any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
(my emphasis)(a)the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and
(b)any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
Since the first NIP in the chain went to the rental company, the requirement on subsequent NIPees is lower. Added to that, the normal "You should keep a record of who has the keys" is at least partially negated when you have a short term hire vehicle.
If they believe you are taking the piss a bit then they'll charge the company with S.172 which is a slightly bigger fine but at least nobody gets any points. It's only if they think you've actively trying to hide information that they'll go for you personally.
PAULJ5555 said:
Sounds strange an off duty plod would report this.
If I was one I would have to spend half my life reporting people and doing paperwork, I see at least 3-4 every day.
True, even I don't report them.If I was one I would have to spend half my life reporting people and doing paperwork, I see at least 3-4 every day.
I just pit maneuver them causing them to have a violent crash, and drive off.

It's been a while but when I had similar I gave the details of all the possible drivers.
They didn't like this and I later had a call asking me to name which one was driving - I read out the bit on the form which says it's an offence to give misleading information - that went down well.
But I never heard anything after that (several years ago)
They didn't like this and I later had a call asking me to name which one was driving - I read out the bit on the form which says it's an offence to give misleading information - that went down well.
But I never heard anything after that (several years ago)
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



