Who's to blame
Author
Discussion

Chim

Original Poster:

7,259 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Have a tricky one, wife just had a bump in the local shopping centre car park. Guy was reversing out of a parking space as she was about to reverse into one and they collided. Sounds cut and shut and his fault, added bit of info though. The car park has designated arrows for direction and she had cam up the lane against the arrow having not noticed as the arrows are very faded.

So, question is one of fault, was it the wife as she was against the arrows or him for not taking due care when reversing out of the space or perhaps its a 50/50.

4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
I'd say it's 100% your wife's fault as she was driving in contradiction to the traffic flow as designated by the arrows. Had she have driven in the correct direction then chances are the collision would not have occurred.

The driver reversing out of the space would not be expecting a car to be approaching him from that direction and would have been concentrating on ensuring that here were no vehicles coming from the correct direction.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
If she was stationary as she claims it's 100% his fault.
If she was moving then it's a different story.

If she was stationary it also depends on whether she was there for 20 seconds waiting or just stopped 2 seconds before the impact.

Garybee

453 posts

197 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
4rephill said:
I'd say it's 100% your wife's fault as she was driving in contradiction to the traffic flow as designated by the arrows. Had she have driven in the correct direction then chances are the collision would not have occurred.

The driver reversing out of the space would not be expecting a car to be approaching him from that direction and would have been concentrating on ensuring that here were no vehicles coming from the correct direction.
I agree with this guy.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Difficult to say as neither party is travelling in line with the anticipated traffic flow, both could probably have had the same opportunity to see the other (but didn't), both were reversing, etc.

I don't think it's cut and dried unless one witness statement is compelling as to position, speed, conditons, etc.

The other party could also admit liability.

Having said all that, unless one party is very clear in describing the other's negligence and excluding their own, I'd find it very hard to argue against 50:50.

4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
Difficult to say as neither party is travelling in line with the anticipated traffic flow, both could probably have had the same opportunity to see the other (but didn't), both were reversing, etc.

I don't think it's cut and dried unless one witness statement is compelling as to position, speed, conditons, etc.

The other party could also admit liability.

Having said all that, unless one party is very clear in describing the other's negligence and excluding their own, I'd find it very hard to argue against 50:50.
Assuming the driver leaving the parking space is reversing out and pointing his car to continue in the designated direction of travel, as indicated by the arrows, then he his performing a standard, expected manoeuvre seen in every car park round the World (how else is he meant to get out of the space?), and is obeying the rules set out for travelling through the car park.

The driver travelling against the designated direction of travel is not performing an expected manoeuvre because they are not obeying the rules clearly set out for travelling through the car park.

That means the driver who is disobeying the rules is the one at fault! - it really is that clear-cut as far as I'm concerned!

If you go against the flow of traffic and crash then it's your fault!

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
It depends how far and how fast but in general I don't think it's negligent to go past a space and then reverse into it.

What we are talking about is a scenario similar to this, if the blue Mazda3 saloon had reversed out while the Toyota is parking.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_IaM6I0IiU

Edited by CYMR0 on Saturday 23 November 15:36

Chim

Original Poster:

7,259 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
have made a little picture to help with the view points. Big arrow shows the way the traffic should travel. Wife was reversing as per the arrow and he was coming out as per the arrow. Although pointing the wrong way she was in fact travelling the correct way albeit in reverse.


SegueUK

71 posts

162 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Nice picture.

littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Wow! Ford Pilot V8s! Not surprised you're upset at any damage. smile

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
In most car parks I use nobody follows the direction markings on the floor.

If a car reverses into a stationary car, they are at fault.
If both cars are reversing and both moving it's 50:50.

If someone is reversing in a car park without checking behind them then they are idiots - because there are always hazards in carparks from kids to trolleys to doddery old folk to other reversing cars.


littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
If she was stationary as she claims it's 100% his fault.
Where was that claim made then? There's no mention of it in the OP...

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Not that it helps, but this is one reason I reverse park, to give better vision when driving out.




smile

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
littleredrooster said:
Snowboy said:
If she was stationary as she claims it's 100% his fault.
Where was that claim made then? There's no mention of it in the OP...
Op said she was about to reverse into a space.
I inferred that she was stationary waiting for the other guy to move out the way.
I may have inferred wrong. smile


Chim

Original Poster:

7,259 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
littleredrooster said:
Snowboy said:
If she was stationary as she claims it's 100% his fault.
Where was that claim made then? There's no mention of it in the OP...
Op said she was about to reverse into a space.
I inferred that she was stationary waiting for the other guy to move out the way.
I may have inferred wrong. smile
Nope, sorry, my bad, she was reversing as per the little pic

littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Chim said:
Nope, sorry, my bad, she was reversing as per the little pic
Not your fault. Your post never actually said that she was stationary. It is typical of PH that, at some point in the post, somebody will make their own assumptions.

Chim

Original Poster:

7,259 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
littleredrooster said:
Wow! Ford Pilot V8s! Not surprised you're upset at any damage. smile
hehe

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
The directional arrows on the road carry little weight in apportioning liability; in a car park they carry bugger all weight.

Both reversing then it'll be 50/50. Reality is that this scenario would be 50/50 anyway. Both would claim they were stationary and the other was reversing if it made it to court and as long as both are credible witnesses, then it'd be hard to work out who was telling the truth and who not.

Independent witnesses are key to having any chance of winning these claims.

JM

3,170 posts

237 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Chim said:
Guy was reversing out of a parking space as she was about to reverse into one
Don't believe you, I've never seen a woman reverse into a parking space in a car-park.



But, if she was then I'd say the other guy is more at fault, as it sounds like he came out of a space without seeing if it was clear to do so. And if he had reversed into the space in the first place he'd have had a much better view when coming out.

4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Chim said:
have made a little picture to help with the view points. Big arrow shows the way the traffic should travel. Wife was reversing as per the arrow and he was coming out as per the arrow. Although pointing the wrong way she was in fact travelling the correct way albeit in reverse.

Mmmmmm..... scratchchin

That clears things up a bit!

So she's driven in the wrong direction to start with (otherwise, how is she facing the wrong way? confused ), spotted a space behind her and decided to reverse back to the space, giving her a far more restricted view of any cars that might pull out of spaces behind her? Also, how fast was she reversing?

I still think your wife is largely at fault, but as I see it now, it's something like 70% her fault/30% the other drivers fault (going forwards or backwards, he should have been cautious that a car coming along could be a possibility).

I would say, whilst your wife was technically driving in the correct direction of travel at the time of impact, if she'd been driving forwards in the designated direction of travel rather than in reverse, would she have had a better chance of seeing the driver pulling out of the parking space?

Out of the two drivers, the driver pulling out of the parking space was performing a manoeuvre that could be expected in a car park, whilst your wife was not as she was going backwards when she should have been going forwards.

Had your wife been travelling forwards in the designated direction of travel, then the driver pulling out is bang to rights at fault.


Tell you what, take away your emotional attachment to the situation (as it involves your wife and you're likely to be a bit defensive), and imagine if you were the driver pulling out of the parking space. If you had a collision with someone reversing along that stretch of car park in the manner that your wife did, would you happily accept responsibility for the accident? - Or would you query why they were travelling backwards in the first place and consider that to be a major contributing factor in the incident?