Taking guy to court over respray,can i sell car just now?
Taking guy to court over respray,can i sell car just now?
Author
Discussion

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
I'm taking someone to court over a bad car respray,to be honest im absolutely gutted and just want shot of the car,lost all heart in it!While i'm waiting for court proceedings to kick off,can i actually sell the car in the meantime?Main reason i'm asking is if i do sell it then the car will legally be someone else's,and by that time the court case might come up and the car's no longer mine?Don't know if i'm worrying over nothing?

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Keep the car.

It works in two good ways.

One you have it as evidence.
Two after a payout,you can have it redone and be happy with it.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Unless this is a very valuable car or unless it is a small claims issue where costs are not at issue, you may wish to re-think litigation.

As a guide, in a recent small dispute I worked on the amount in dispute was just £13k. The legal fees on each side were in the region of £35k each (the problenm was that both sides had litigation insurance, so both sides dragged on a non-case that should have been settled.

What, roughly, is the value of the claim you are making/have made?




Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Unless the OP had the work done south of Hadrians Wall, he might be borderline for a small claims track claim. The limit in Scotland is incredibly parsimonious compared with E&W - £3k v £10k.

Also, in E&W cases are automatically referred to (non mandatory) mediation prior to litigation. I don't think there is any such provision north of the border.

Edited by Red Devil on Monday 25th November 13:31

jeff666

2,462 posts

222 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
I'm taking someone to court over a bad car respray,to be honest im absolutely gutted and just want shot of the car,lost all heart in it!While i'm waiting for court proceedings to kick off,can i actually sell the car in the meantime?Main reason i'm asking is if i do sell it then the car will legally be someone else's,and by that time the court case might come up and the car's no longer mine?Don't know if i'm worrying over nothing?
I take it you had no luck getting it resolved with the painter then ? may i ask what his reply was when you said you were not happy with the work done ?

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
jeff666 said:
I take it you had no luck getting it resolved with the painter then ? may i ask what his reply was when you said you were not happy with the work done ?
To be honest i can't even look at the car,i've just left it for a while.Now i'm getting around to going through to the court with the small claims form.This might go against me but i don't really care,but he offered to redo faulty parts but as a few painters have told me,it 'all' needs taken back and done again.So my opinion was a)Although he offered to fix parts,would he 'really' be prepared to undertake basically more work 'now' than he couldn't be bothered to do 'before'?and b)I didn't want him anywhere near the car again to be honest,he can't paint!!
I'm just going to depend on the basic facts in the court,he quoted me an amount to do what i asked him to do,and he didn't do what i asked,and what he did do he did badly.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
I thought (perhaps incorrectly) that the supplier of services must be given an oppurtunity to make good any defects in their work.

In my line of business 5-10% of the invoice value is normally withheld for exactly this reason.


Who knows?

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
hman said:
I thought (perhaps incorrectly) that the supplier of services must be given an oppurtunity to make good any defects in their work.

In my line of business 5-10% of the invoice value is normally withheld for exactly this reason.


Who knows?
Yes he was given,and offered the chance to put it right but i declined it.Once you've been pooped on from a great height you don't go back to the same spot for more eh?Pooping!!Well i don't!Believe it or not i was in this same position about 20 years ago.Guy painted car,put wipers on wrong spindle after respray and left a nice arc across the bonnet through the unhardened paint!!The question of putting it right never even came up then,it was just court then money back?

Andyr86

209 posts

230 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
Yes he was given,and offered the chance to put it right but i declined it
Why offer the chance to resolve it then then decline it? I'd imagine it would hurt your case if you were too not let him have a chance of rectifying what he has done. Court should be seen as a last option.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
Yes he was given,and offered the chance to put it right but i declined it.Once you've been pooped on from a great height you don't go back to the same spot for more eh?Pooping!!Well i don't!Believe it or not i was in this same position about 20 years ago.Guy painted car,put wipers on wrong spindle after respray and left a nice arc across the bonnet through the unhardened paint!!The question of putting it right never even came up then,it was just court then money back?
I understand your reasoning for not giving the recent guy a chance to rectify the situatuion. He's demonstrated that he lacks competance. The case above though seems a little bit harsh. He made a mistake when putting the wipers on, nothing to do with his painting skills.

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Andyr86 said:
Why offer the chance to resolve it then then decline it? I'd imagine it would hurt your case if you were too not let him have a chance of rectifying what he has done. Court should be seen as a last option.
That is making it sound like i stood there and said right,i'm giving you the chance to resolve it,then before he says anything i shout No!!I'm not letting you!!.,i just said im not taking the car like this,what are you going to do?then he said he would try and repair all the parts.!!'Then' i declined(i was looking for more of a massive discount in the price).I was under duress at the time as he threatened to take the car away if i didn't pay,plus he was still holding the bonnet at his paint place for some reason.

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
I understand your reasoning for not giving the recent guy a chance to rectify the situatuion. He's demonstrated that he lacks competance. The case above though seems a little bit harsh. He made a mistake when putting the wipers on, nothing to do with his painting skills.
It wasn't just the wiper down the bonnet,i just couldn't be bothered going through the other faults.And incase you think i was being picky,he had painted it in a shade during a gale and it was covered in dirt all over,plus he had just painted over where there had been glue from decals etc.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
hmmm

My thoughts on this are - buy cheap - buy twice

but for you it seems

buy cheap, expect quality work, feel let down when cheap work arrives, complain, get offered resolution refuse to allow rectification, go to court, get money back - still unhappy.

sorry mr stiltskin it doesnt seem to me like you are doing yourself any favours in life.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
Letter before action.

1. Outline to him your issues:
a. You contracted him to paint your car for £X
b. He is under an implied duty to use reaonable care and skill.
c. He didn't do that.
d. You suffered damage as a reuslt.
2. Out the remedy you seek:
a. you do not have faith that he possesses the required care and skill to rectify his work.
b. the remedy sought is a refund of all monies paid.
3. Outline the timescale (say 14 days) he has to explain why he isn't liable or to pay you £X.
4. Finish with this letter should be considered as a Letter before Action and that you reserve your rights to commence proceedings in the small claims court.

Send it recorded to his home address and a copy to his work address or hand deliver it.

Then he is under no illusion that he has to pay you or face a claim.

Keep your particualrs of claim relatively simple - it isn't the HIgh COurt.

Good luck.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Monday 25th November 2013
quotequote all
To be fair to Stiltkin, even if the job was cheap it shouldn't be crap. Nobody wants a crap job irrespective of price.

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Regardless if he wont bring it up to standard then you need to get a report done by a paint expert with letter next to his name to present to the court, makes the judges job much easier

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
johnfm said:
To be fair to Stiltkin, even if the job was cheap it shouldn't be crap. Nobody wants a crap job irrespective of price.
Sorry, but you are in a fantasy world if you ever think cheap paint work is going to be a good paintwork .

The cost of paint alone makes car painting a fairly expensive task - then prep materials, spray booth facility, purchase and maintenance of equipment is not cheap then add labour hours and you can begin to understand why a cheap job will have to have cut a corner somewhere - which will result in a cheap job.

There is good work and there is cheap work - very rarely is there ever good cheap work

(because the good cheap guy will have to raise prices eventually to cover the outgoings involved in getting good results).

I know of 3 or 4 painters that are good - they arent cheap but the work is first class every time - no need for rectification work after delivery. The guys I know that are cheap operate from sub standard premises with sub standard materials and get sub standard results.

Paint is the finishing touch to your car and makes up a huge proportion of how you and the rest of the world judge a cars condition- why on earth would you want cheap paintwork???

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I have reports from two other painters of the faults, plus many detailed pics, selling the evidence? Do I have to bring the car slong to the court house? Probably not! This is why I ssked my original question, just incase there was some legal technicality where I still had to have/own the car at court time? If you know what I mean?

AdeTuono

7,626 posts

258 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
If the work is truly as appalling as you state (so bad that you can't even look at it...), then I doubt anyone will want to buy it at a reasonable price.

Care to post some pictures, along with perceived values and cost of the re-spray, so that we're availed of all information?

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Is this the silver Jag? If so it would appear this thread is already starting to go the same way as the last one with people chipping in with unnecessary and pointless comments.

Good luck with it OP. Hopefully someone will come along soon and actually answer your question.