A friend, family and money...
A friend, family and money...
Author
Discussion

mcxuk1

Original Poster:

452 posts

171 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
A friend of mine was given £1000 by a family member. He signed to say XXX XXXXX received £1000 from XXXXXX XXXX on the 01/05/2013.

The family member has now asked for the money back but my friend isn't in a position to pay it back as he has recently lost his job. The family member is now threatening to go to the police etc. What is the likely outcome here?

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
They won't be friends for much longer?

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
mcxuk1 said:
The family member is now threatening to go to the police etc. What is the likely outcome here?
No criminal offence- civil matter.

Also, the paper as described makes it sound like a gift rather than a loan.

kam05

272 posts

176 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
No criminal offence- civil matter.
+1

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
No criminal offence- civil matter.

Also, the paper as described makes it sound like a gift rather than a loan.
Certainly no police interest.

I do wonder, though- is it more likely you'd sign an itemised receipt for a gift or a loan? I'd bet on the latter, as why would you need to sign a receipt for a gift?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
No crime has been commited.
It's not a police matter.

If you dud call they would probably suggest small claims court or Judge Judy.

Mandat

4,657 posts

269 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
What would Judge Judy say?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Mandat said:
What would Judge Judy say?
Sir, you're an idiot.
You might be a nice and kind idiot, but you're still an idiot.
You shouldn't lend money to friends when you know they can't afford to pay it back.

And you Sir, you are also an idiot. Borrowing money off friends is a stupid thing to do.

Both of you, next time use a bank.
Sheeesh, aye aye aye

Judgement for the plaintif in the amount of one thousand dollars, um, pounds.

Now get out of here and make better life choices in the future.

Next.


Edited by Snowboy on Tuesday 26th November 11:59

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Certainly no police interest.

I do wonder, though- is it more likely you'd sign an itemised receipt for a gift or a loan? I'd bet on the latter, as why would you need to sign a receipt for a gift?
Agree with you that there is absolutely no offence disclosed here.

The counter-argument though is why would you not specify repayment terms for a loan? Might there have been some other consideration? Even then there's a presumption against creating legal relation between family members.

In any event, if the aggrieved family member does sue on the terms of what I will describe as a 'loan note', he's only going to get an order for repayment in instalments at best, if the 'borrower' is as broke as he says - and those instalments are likely to be very small.

Gillett66

98 posts

174 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Sir, you're an idiot.
You might be a nice and kind idiot, but you're still an idiot.
You shouldn't lend money to friends when you know they can't afford to pay it back.

And you Sir, you are also an idiot. Borrowing money off friends is a stupid thing to do.

Both of you, next time use a bank.
Sheeesh, aye aye aye

Judgement for the plaintif in the amount of one thousand dollars, um, pounds.

Now get out of here and make better life choices in the future.

Next.


Edited by Snowboy on Tuesday 26th November 11:59
Very good, as I read I even heard the accent in my head. Outstanding work.

mcxuk1

Original Poster:

452 posts

171 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Thanks guys. The friend has had difficulties with this family member in the past so they both wanted it documenting apparently!

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
mcxuk1 said:
Thanks guys. The friend has had difficulties with this family member in the past so they both wanted it documenting apparently!
What did they each think they were documenting?

And why, if they'd had difficulties, did either agree to make/accept the loan as applicable?

freshmicropig

247 posts

180 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
BOLOGNA!

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
mcxuk1 said:
Thanks guys. The friend has had difficulties with this family member in the past so they both wanted it documenting apparently!
What did they each think they were documenting?

And why, if they'd had difficulties, did either agree to make/accept the loan as applicable?
I would be guessing a loan agreement for repayment that is legally binding if one should happen to fall behind in repayments or 'forget' to pay, that means the owner of the loan can take the Friend to court and win easily and friend needs a bloody good reason as to why they have ignored a payment, etc.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
If that's the case then why create such an utterly ambiguous document?

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
If that's the case then why create such an utterly ambiguous document?
Create the note beforehand on the proviso it got paid and was a gentlemans agreement.

Then for some reason or other the borrower says they cant pay, etc, etc, etc...

Maybe cant or dont want to get a basic job or make the effort to pay as they are unemployed now so they should be allowed some slack... The person who loaned them the money doesnt see it this way as its not their problem that the borrower has no job and it was agreed to repay X...

The person who loaned them the money eventually gets pissed off with excuses, etc and demands a loan agreement to be now written up that is now legally binding.

Just a guess and have seen it in the past when the above happens and thankfully its not something I would ever have to do to my friends, but I do have a loan agreement out on someone that is terrible with money and a bad liar... she is not liking it at all. I got her to pay more interest than a bank would charge to get her off my loan and onto a bank loan, but she refuses so therefore pays me something like 12% interest per year.

mcxuk1

Original Poster:

452 posts

171 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
It seems the money was an early part of my friends inheritance. The document was just to show what had been given to my friend and it was not any kind of loan - the money came out of the blue apparently. He is now wishing that he'd never been given it in all honesty!

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
If that's the case then why create such an utterly ambiguous document?
Because people are stupid.

If any of my good frineds needs a couple of £100 to help out I'll gladly get it from the bank and hand it over telling them to pay it back when they can. I do expect it to be paid back at some point but I don't stress as in my mind it's a gift and a small price to pay if someone doesn't even make an attempt to pay you back to learn who they are.

If asked to lend a grand I would (as a rule baby operations and deep st things might melt my wallet strings) decline. I can't afford to give that much away really and it only ends up in trouble when payments get missed and "Can i borrow that gold chain i gave you as collateral for a night out next week" comes into play.

Infact I can't think of more than 5 people who I would lend a grand or more to 3 of them are blood relatives, one is my best mate and the other is the mrs.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
mcxuk1 said:
It seems the money was an early part of my friends inheritance. The document was just to show what had been given to my friend and it was not any kind of loan - the money came out of the blue apparently. He is now wishing that he'd never been given it in all honesty!
In which case on what grounds does the person who gave him the money expect to get it back.

"I gave you a gift and now I want it back"

The correct reply is "It was a gift, I don't have it to give you and even if I did I wouldn't"

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
mcxuk1 said:
It seems the money was an early part of my friends inheritance. The document was just to show what had been given to my friend and it was not any kind of loan - the money came out of the blue apparently. He is now wishing that he'd never been given it in all honesty!
It sounds like you're only getting half the story from your friend.

It's not possible to give sensibl advice without the full background.
Except to say; the police won't care.
It's a small claims court matter.

The police will care if someone tries to get the money back by force though.