Court Proceedings for Speeding Conviction
Court Proceedings for Speeding Conviction
Author
Discussion

JC LA LA

Original Poster:

222 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
For the first time in 23 Years of driving I have been caught speeding and now have to appear in Court. I won’t go into the specifics of my offence, but let’s just say I am looking at a hefty fine possibly even a ban… I’m not proud and feel utterly ashamed of what I have done!!!

Anyway… I have read through the witness statement and need some advice from the PistonHead Community.

The PCSO statement is two pages long and goes into great detail about the pre-checks that were carried out on the Laser Speed Device (LTI20-20 Speedscope) prior to commencing enforcement. It clearly states the times all these checks were carried out and what actions were taken including a “Self Check” after power up, a “distance check” and a “scope alignment” check.

The statement reads as follows:

I later that same day located to ******** prior to commencing enforcement I checked that the speed limit signs were all correct and clearly visible. I then set up the equipment in the designated area and prior to commencing enforcement I turned off my mobile phone.

I then turned on the equipment, confirmed that the machine “powered up” and it then conducted a self check which showed me that it was again performing correctly.

At 3:40pm on the same day I performed an initial scope alignment test in accordance with the manufactures instructions in both the vertical and horizontal plane. No adjustment was required.

At 3:19pm on the same day my attention was drawn to…..

My questions are as follows:

1) What is an initial scope alignment test?
2) The statement confirms the initial scope alignment test was done AFTER I was caught speeding. Should this have been done before?
3) Can I challenge the accuracy of the speed gun based on the above?
4) Would this statement stand up in Court?
5) If I challenged the statement would I still be found guilty?
Thank you in advance for your help.

agtlaw

7,443 posts

237 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
1) Google lti20.20 manual and ACPO RPET.

2) Probably. Court won't be interested.

3) Not without evidence of operator error or device error. Speculation isn't a great defence.

4) Very likely.

5) Very likely.

These cases can be successfully defended but the point you've picked up on isn't a good one. Would be helpful to see any images or video footage.

tehguy

178 posts

162 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
Do not challenge them on technicalities of the device unless you are absolutely sure it was working incorrectly or being used incorrectly which it is highly unlike neither happened.

If they have to call an expert witness from the company and you lose, your costs will skyrocket.

Edit: I don't believe the scope alignment test has to be carried out before either.

Edited by tehguy on Thursday 28th November 10:17

timf

369 posts

275 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
pcso you say.

have they changed the rules that only a police constable can form a prior opinion of speed and then confirm with the gun ?

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Thursday 28th November 2013
quotequote all
Slippery. Lots of avoiding the question there, what is the current situation?

This item seems to imply that PCSO's alone can write letters but not issue FPNs.

Edited by speedking31 on Thursday 28th November 13:47

JC LA LA

Original Poster:

222 posts

292 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Thank you for all your replies and comments - much appreciated.
I have spoken to various people regarding the witness statement... some have said challenge it others have said it's best to plead guilty and accept the consequences.

I really don't know what to do for the best. Any more advice?

According to the statement I was travelling at 58mph in a 30 zone. I know this is shocking and I genuinely cannot believe I would have done such a thing. As I mentioned earlier I have been driving for 23 years and never had a previous motoring conviction. I understand it's 30 for a reason and 99.9% of the time I stick to it.

Does anybody have any idea what my conviction will be? 6 Points and £1000 fine? A ban?

If I challenge the witness statement and still lose what happens then?

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
JC LA LA said:
If I challenge the witness statement and still lose what happens then?
Assuming you plead 'not guilty', £600+ costs plus your fine and points and victim surcharge.

I'd suggest you turn up suited and booted, plead guilty (minimising court costs) and make a good case for a minimal sentence (low-ish fine and less than 6 points) by whatever means (others may post ideas).

If the prosecution call the witness and (s)he says you were doing 28mph over the limit, then you were doing 28mph over the limit wink . Damage limitation now - and pleading 'not guilty' and arguing the toss over statements ain't gonna limit the damage to your wallet frown .

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Wednesday 4th December 2013
quotequote all
Guidelines say that for 51-60mph in a 30 you should get a fine about equal to your weekly post-tax income and either a ban of 7-56 days or 6 points. As you're towards the top of that speed bracket you should probably be prepared for the ban rather than the points, though it's not a certainty. Pleading guilty will reduce the fine by a third, but not the ban/points (except in Scotland). There'll also be costs and victim surcharge to pay - around an extra £100 if you plead guilty, comsiderably more if you plead not guilty and you're convicted after trial - especially if you challenge the accuracy of the device and the prosecution call expensive expert witnesses.