Discussion
Please forgive the new login name.
I received an s172 letter.
It says about not stopping after an accident and driving without due care and attention.
The time and date of me being there are correct however there was no accident. Don't want to put the full story but basically someone swerved in front, braked sharply and was very abusive/threatening etc demanding insurance details.
I think it was one of those "staged" accidents gone a bit wrong.
I tried taking a photo of the back of the car for the reg no but he kept blocking it up by standing in front of it.
I managed to get away but obviously didn't report it to the police as there was nothing to report.
What do I do with the notice? Fill it in and post it back as it is, or do I include a letter explaining what happened?
The reg no on the letter is wrong so do I need to notify them of that too so its corrected?
On a more important note is there any way that the police or anyone else will pass on my address on to him?
Having been on the receiving end of him once I really don't want to meet him again and to be honest I quite believe some of his threats as he came across as a nasty piece of work.
I received an s172 letter.
It says about not stopping after an accident and driving without due care and attention.
The time and date of me being there are correct however there was no accident. Don't want to put the full story but basically someone swerved in front, braked sharply and was very abusive/threatening etc demanding insurance details.
I think it was one of those "staged" accidents gone a bit wrong.
I tried taking a photo of the back of the car for the reg no but he kept blocking it up by standing in front of it.
I managed to get away but obviously didn't report it to the police as there was nothing to report.
What do I do with the notice? Fill it in and post it back as it is, or do I include a letter explaining what happened?
The reg no on the letter is wrong so do I need to notify them of that too so its corrected?
On a more important note is there any way that the police or anyone else will pass on my address on to him?
Having been on the receiving end of him once I really don't want to meet him again and to be honest I quite believe some of his threats as he came across as a nasty piece of work.
A few months ago I had something similar, someone driving very erratically in front of me (accelerating, heavy braking, rolling back at junctions etc) then stop and try and block the road. I just drove around them and phoned the police on 101 and reported their reg number.
The police said it was probably someone looking to cause an impact, to take time stamped photos of my car ASAP to prove there was no damage and had been no impact and to phone my insurance company and advise them just in case someone tried to make a claim.
So, I guess reply to the request from the police and take some photos of your car now to show there is no damage and maybe call your insurer to advise that there has been no accident.
The police said it was probably someone looking to cause an impact, to take time stamped photos of my car ASAP to prove there was no damage and had been no impact and to phone my insurance company and advise them just in case someone tried to make a claim.
So, I guess reply to the request from the police and take some photos of your car now to show there is no damage and maybe call your insurer to advise that there has been no accident.
Thanks guys.
Hindsight is a great thing and I now realise I should have reported it.
Good call on taking some photos. I will do that.
I did tell my insurance company about it at the time as it seemed like a fake accident thing was the most likely scenario and there being a dodgy claim was all that worried me really.
Hindsight is a great thing and I now realise I should have reported it.
Good call on taking some photos. I will do that.
I did tell my insurance company about it at the time as it seemed like a fake accident thing was the most likely scenario and there being a dodgy claim was all that worried me really.
Is it best to write a letter and send with the form, phone them to explain what went on or should I just wait until I hear back from them?
What do I need to do about the wrong reg no?
If I send the form back signed as it is then I am saying I was driving a different car which seems a bit of a wrong thing to do.
What do I need to do about the wrong reg no?
If I send the form back signed as it is then I am saying I was driving a different car which seems a bit of a wrong thing to do.
Randomstranger said:
Any help or advice please?
Been there, the situation you are in is horrid.The area of the incident, any cctv coverage, from local businesses etc ?
Having been the victim of this, I personally always use a reputable dash cam now, one of our resident insurance experts doesn't think highly of it, but it is all I can do, and of course hope it doesn't happen again.
Mine took nine months to sort out.
Good luck.
Thanks for the replies.
I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
Randomstranger said:
Thanks for the replies.
I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
Read the form carefully but if the Reg is wrong then that is not your car / problem.I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
Why be overly helpful ?
I have taken this approach since my 8' bright red jet ski was stolen and found in a private house's rear garden - the occupiers - 2 brothers both with criminal records, denied knowledge of the bloody obvious and got away with it.
I've found that no one cares - they just go for the easy targets
Randomstranger said:
Thanks for the replies.
I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
RTA 1988 Section 172I have been looking at the dash cams over the weekend!
I am not familiar with the area so don't know about any cctv. I would imagine if there was any it would be gone by now as it was over 2 weeks ago.
There is 1 digit of the reg wrong. No make or model on there.
I can only assume either a misprint their end or maybe its the closest match to the make and model with a similar reg. Not sure it actually works like that though!
It does give the location.
If I reply that I don't own the vehicle mentioned that means that I cant sign the form as there is not an option for that. Is there a problem with that approach?
Thinking of the old failing to identify driver, not filling the form out etc
Should I mention that I own a similar vehicle?
(2)Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—.
(a)the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and.
(b)any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
You are not the RK of the vehicle with that registration number so sub-paragraph (a) doesn't apply to you. You cannot be expected to know to whom that VRM is registered. The lack of make/model/colour is to your advantage.
That said, the location is the difficult bit. You were there so that makes you 'any other person' (not being the RK of the vehicle with the specified VRM) who is in a position to give 'any information'. That would include the correct VRM. Thus you are ensnared by sub-paragraph (b). It's your call whether you want to try the 'that vehicle VRM is not registered to me' approach first and see what their response is. If the information is accurate enough to identify a specific place (not just X road which might be 10 miles long) then I wouldn't risk it. The window is only 28 days and the penalty for failure to furnish is 6 points. Really not worth it.
Choose your preferred approach and wait and see what happens. If it looks like going south (which without any independent witnesses it is very unlikely to - it's just his word against yours as there was no collision resulting in damage to either vehicle) and they prefer a charge against you then get some advice from a motoring solicitor (Ms Demeanour on here).
http://www.pattersonlaw.co.uk/About-us/contact-us....
IANAL.
The way this has gone down in court is that if the error is not serious enough to mislead the person, the error is not serious enough to stop a prosecution. It sounds like you know what happened at the time and place mentioned, so the error is trivial.
However, I would be inclined to reply with a letter rather than on the form (that is allowed). Write "SEE ATTACHED" on the form so there's no chance of them suggesting you sent it back blank, and then send a letter along the lines of
"Dear X,
Following receipt of the attached S.172 notice, I can confirm that I am not the registered keeper of a vehicle with the VRM XXXX XXX, and have no connection to that vehicle. However, I am the registered keeper of VRM XXXY XXX, and I was the driver of the vehicle at the time of the alleged offence."
Ensure you have provided all of the information requested on the form, and make sure to sign the letter.
Because it's not a straight speeding offence what follows is a little bit different. The police will probably want to have a "chat" with you. Did you keep the photos you tried to take? Even if they don't show the registration number they might show that the car in front wasn't hit, and that it didn't actually have five people in it as the complainant has no doubt suggested...
The way this has gone down in court is that if the error is not serious enough to mislead the person, the error is not serious enough to stop a prosecution. It sounds like you know what happened at the time and place mentioned, so the error is trivial.
However, I would be inclined to reply with a letter rather than on the form (that is allowed). Write "SEE ATTACHED" on the form so there's no chance of them suggesting you sent it back blank, and then send a letter along the lines of
"Dear X,
Following receipt of the attached S.172 notice, I can confirm that I am not the registered keeper of a vehicle with the VRM XXXX XXX, and have no connection to that vehicle. However, I am the registered keeper of VRM XXXY XXX, and I was the driver of the vehicle at the time of the alleged offence."
Ensure you have provided all of the information requested on the form, and make sure to sign the letter.
Because it's not a straight speeding offence what follows is a little bit different. The police will probably want to have a "chat" with you. Did you keep the photos you tried to take? Even if they don't show the registration number they might show that the car in front wasn't hit, and that it didn't actually have five people in it as the complainant has no doubt suggested...
My brother had similar, and the police went out of their way to do him for leaving the scene of an accident. They turned down the offer of looking at his car (which was almost new, and was immaculate). They wanted to interview him about the so called accident, so he took a solicitor, and was advised not answer questions about an accident that didn't occur. He did provide them with a written statment of what actually happened.
The police took it no further, but supplied the other person with the insurance details so they could start a claim. The insurance company opened a case, which my brother disputed. Fortunately the insurance company saw sense and sent someone to look for damage, they found nothing on the car, so told the other person to get lost
The police took it no further, but supplied the other person with the insurance details so they could start a claim. The insurance company opened a case, which my brother disputed. Fortunately the insurance company saw sense and sent someone to look for damage, they found nothing on the car, so told the other person to get lost

Devil2575 said:
Randomstranger said:
but basically someone swerved in front, braked sharply and was very abusive/threatening etc demanding insurance details.
At which point I would have called the Police.Not helpful to the OP I know.
It broke my headlight and scratched his bumper.
He jumped out and asked to swap details
My reply was along the lines of "F**k off you c#nt" and I got back in my car and drove off - never heard anything further
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


