Quick questions regarding rejection
Quick questions regarding rejection
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
I see a few posters lately have had issues with used cars bought from dealers.

If one has given the dealer fair time to fix issues present on delivery discovered on the weekend of collection (and notified two days after collection), and they officially reject the car:

1. How easy is have others found it to get money back? (around 10k or so in this case)
2. Is it possible to also get back, say, £600 spent pre-collection on an elective gearbox oil change?
3. Is there any allowance for insurance cancellation costs, tax disk and loss of use/car hire during time car at repairing garage not being repaired?

In my case selling dealer arranged for car to be dropped off at nearby main dealer a week and a half ago and main dealer have downed tools (rightly) as supplying dealer had been in dispute over the bill so far since last Thursday.

I'm faced with rejecting the car today or collecting it and paying the bill myself/suing supplying dealer for bill so far plus next few hundred quid to complete it.

Cheers
SM

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Have the defects been repaired? i.e. Have you been presented with a car that, as far as you know, is free from defects and so on.

If so, I am not sure on what basis YOU can reject the car. You have a contract with the supplying dealer.

There is a dispute between the supplying dealer and the main dealer over costs - but you are not a party to that contract and so have no standing.

Main dealer seems to be asserting a lien over the car over the monies owed to it by the supplying dealer.

Have you paid the supplying dealer for the car?

Have you already paid for the world's most expensive 'elective gearbox oil change'?

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
johnfm said:
Have the defects been repaired? i.e. Have you been presented with a car that, as far as you know, is free from defects and so on.

If so, I am not sure on what basis YOU can reject the car. You have a contract with the supplying dealer.

There is a dispute between the supplying dealer and the main dealer over costs - but you are not a party to that contract and so have no standing.

Main dealer seems to be asserting a lien over the car over the monies owed to it by the supplying dealer.

Have you paid the supplying dealer for the car?

Have you already paid for the world's most expensive 'elective gearbox oil change'?
Defects still present, main dealer standing by since supplying dealer not paying the bill.
Supplying dealer has been paid for car purchase
Gearbox oil changed and paid for by me (maintenance is an investment/disease for me depending on your viewpoint)

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
So the vehicle cost around £10k, you've owned it around 2 weeks and paid the supplying dealer £600 for an elective oil change before driving it away?

Please can you advise in general terms how old it is and what mileage it has covered?

smile

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
aw51 121565 said:
So the vehicle cost around £10k, you've owned it around 2 weeks and paid the supplying dealer £600 for an elective oil change before driving it away?

Please can you advise in general terms how old it is and what mileage it has covered?

smile
No because it'll deviate the thread from the answers I'm looking for. By all means raise a thread in Jag forum to discuss the rights and wrongs of elective gearbox oil changes and I'll see you over there smile

SM

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
supermono said:
johnfm said:
Have the defects been repaired? i.e. Have you been presented with a car that, as far as you know, is free from defects and so on.

If so, I am not sure on what basis YOU can reject the car. You have a contract with the supplying dealer.

There is a dispute between the supplying dealer and the main dealer over costs - but you are not a party to that contract and so have no standing.

Main dealer seems to be asserting a lien over the car over the monies owed to it by the supplying dealer.

Have you paid the supplying dealer for the car?

Have you already paid for the world's most expensive 'elective gearbox oil change'?
Defects still present, main dealer standing by since supplying dealer not paying the bill.
Supplying dealer has been paid for car purchase
Gearbox oil changed and paid for by me (maintenance is an investment/disease for me depending on your viewpoint)
What bill is the main dealer waiting for payment for if the defects are still present?

You have paid for the car. You do not need to accept the vehicle if there are defects upon delivery to you.

The £600 damages for the oil change (What did they use? Dom Perignon 1932??) is more difficult. You would argue it as a claim for damages (one of the heads of loss in your claim for breach: your total remedy sought being refund and £600 wasted cost of oil change).

The main and the supplying dealer aren't covering themselves in glory here.

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
£600 elective gearbox oil change... Your election, your problem.

Presumably, once the main dealer has sorted the car, you'll be happy with it. In which case, you don't need to reject it, you need a courtesy car.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
mikeveal said:
£600 elective gearbox oil change... Your election, your problem.
.
A point of view I have sympathy with.

However another POV is I expected the car to be of merchantable quality so invested this money with the expectation of many happy years of motoring ahead in good faith. When that turned out not to be the case I'd like it back.

Which is right in law?

SM

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
How come there are still defects AND the main dealer is demanding payment?

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
johnfm said:
What bill is the main dealer waiting for payment for if the defects are still present?
...
The main and the supplying dealer aren't covering themselves in glory here.
First defect according to the information I have was commenced but turned out to be two things (I'm keeping out of that, not my problem I asked for remedy not details) first thing done, second thing not. Car drivable.

Second defect not started and completely unrelated to first.

Completion of first defect and second approx £450 bill. So far first bill totals approx £600.

The main dealer are actually doing rather well considering how they've been messed about, I would commend them highly in fact. Supplying dealer however...

SM

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
johnfm said:
How come there are still defects AND the main dealer is demanding payment?
Because further authorisation refused so they can't carry on with the work and they want the car out of the way. I suspect they want no further business from supplying dealer.

SM
eta: work stopped by supplying dealer request last Thursday

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
Well it is a mess.

It is your car, but you are not a party to their dispute, yet the main dealer are exercising a lien over your car for a debt owed from the supplying dealer.

The most practical issue is for you to pay for the repairs, accept the car and then chase the supplying dealer for those costs.

At least then you will have a car with which to drive to the small claims court come the day...

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
supermono said:
mikeveal said:
£600 elective gearbox oil change... Your election, your problem.
.
A point of view I have sympathy with.

However another POV is I expected the car to be of merchantable quality so invested this money with the expectation of many happy years of motoring ahead in good faith. When that turned out not to be the case I'd like it back.

Which is right in law?

SM
How is this different from you having a very flash hi-fi installed, where the cost of installation runs into hundreds of pounds?

IANAL, but I refer you to my earlier answer. Any money you have spent in this manner is a consequential losses. Chasing consequential losses is complicated. You'll need a qualified legal opinion on that one. But, as the proceedure was elective and not necessary I think you'll have a really tough time.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
mikeveal said:
But, as the proceedure was elective and not necessary I think you'll have a really tough time.
I tend to agree but it's the notion of good faith spending I'm wondering about. However news is coming in that the monies have been paid and work complete...

We'll see...

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 29th November 2013
quotequote all
mikeveal said:
How is this different from you having a very flash hi-fi installed, where the cost of installation runs into hundreds of pounds?

IANAL, but I refer you to my earlier answer. Any money you have spent in this manner is a consequential losses. Chasing consequential losses is complicated. You'll need a qualified legal opinion on that one. But, as the proceedure was elective and not necessary I think you'll have a really tough time.
Consequential lss?

I don;t think so. A consequential loss would be if, due to the car's failure he broke down and was unable to make a meeting and that caused a loss of profit form a deal that woudl have flowed form that missed meeting.

It is a sticky issue though.

He instructed the work on reliance of the seller's agreement to supply the car at the agreed price with the faults rectified at the seller's cost.