accident - insurance query?
Discussion
A guy drove into the back of my car this morning at a roundabout, he thought i'd moved off when actually i was waiting for traffic to right to clear.
He admitted liability at the scene and gave me his insurance details.
So do I need to call my insurance company to inform them or just route it all through his insurance?
He admitted liability at the scene and gave me his insurance details.
So do I need to call my insurance company to inform them or just route it all through his insurance?
Up to you, if you claim via your own insurance your excess may be applicable and they will claim back from the other insurer.
You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
Personally I would contact the other parties insurer directly, and ask them if they will deal. If they wont then utilise your own insurance.
This keeps the overall claims costs to a minimum in terms of credit hire etc. also.
You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
Personally I would contact the other parties insurer directly, and ask them if they will deal. If they wont then utilise your own insurance.
This keeps the overall claims costs to a minimum in terms of credit hire etc. also.
bradjsmith88 said:
Up to you, if you claim via your own insurance your excess may be applicable and they will claim back from the other insurer.
You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
Personally I would contact the other parties insurer directly, and ask them if they will deal. If they wont then utilise your own insurance.
This keeps the overall claims costs to a minimum in terms of credit hire etc. also.
Cheers. Been so long since I've been involved in a shunt that I've forgotten the process.You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
Personally I would contact the other parties insurer directly, and ask them if they will deal. If they wont then utilise your own insurance.
This keeps the overall claims costs to a minimum in terms of credit hire etc. also.
rscott]radjsmith88 said:
You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
/quote]
I'd check your policy about this - some require you notify them immediately.
Called my insurer and advised them it was "for notification only" initially as I intended to run through third parties insurance. They were happy with that, took details and gave me a ref in case I wanted to/needed to proceed via them rather than the third party./quote]
I'd check your policy about this - some require you notify them immediately.
TPS said:
bradjsmith88 said:
You do not have to notify your insurer until next renewal.
So you don't need to notify your insurance company to a claim that they may be involved in or have an interest in?Is this just your opinion?
RTA or any incident needs to be declared within 48 hours usually whether you intend to claim or not.
TPS said:
So you don't need to notify your insurance company to a claim that they may be involved in or have an interest in?
Is this just your opinion?
Technically you should. Pragmatically it won't make one iota of difference to this year whether you do or don't. Is this just your opinion?
And no, an insurer will not try to wriggle out of a subsequent claim despite what the pedants will now post.
My one piece of advice is keep a record of absolutely everything (name of person, time you spoke to, if you were transferred, which dept etc.). The moment you think you're being palmed off, get it escalated to the complaints department and don't relax until the cheque is in your hands.
I refused to repair my vehicle until I had the money for it and made it clear they would be paying for reasonable alternative transport arrangements and any storage fees the garage might charge while they were deciding what to do.
It was initially a nightmare dealing with the third party's insurer because i chose not to use an accident management company. In the end, I dealt only with the complaints department of the insurer who were so much more efficient and provided a reasonable goodwill gesture as a result of their many f-ups.
I refused to repair my vehicle until I had the money for it and made it clear they would be paying for reasonable alternative transport arrangements and any storage fees the garage might charge while they were deciding what to do.
It was initially a nightmare dealing with the third party's insurer because i chose not to use an accident management company. In the end, I dealt only with the complaints department of the insurer who were so much more efficient and provided a reasonable goodwill gesture as a result of their many f-ups.
Then whichever insurer you dealt with is crap.
They shouldn't pay you in advance. The threat of hire is irrelevant good luck arguing that one around mitigation. They shouldn't deal with any complaint from you as there is no contract of insurance. The issue is one of legal liability and they should advise you to bugger off and litigate if you're convinced you have a case.
They shouldn't pay you in advance. The threat of hire is irrelevant good luck arguing that one around mitigation. They shouldn't deal with any complaint from you as there is no contract of insurance. The issue is one of legal liability and they should advise you to bugger off and litigate if you're convinced you have a case.
TPS said:
So you don't need to notify your insurance company to a claim that they may be involved in or have an interest in?
Is this just your opinion?
Perhaps I should have expanded further. Is this just your opinion?
Many policy booklets will say to notify them as soon as possible of any incidents you are involved in.
And if this was a fault incident I agree to notify a.s.a.p. to allow the best possible defence to be prepared - however this seems straight forward non-fault.
As the OP's insurers have done they just take details and say thanks very much and goodbye! Next renewal they will include it on the invitation.
Conversely the OP could just call them at renewal and make a late disclosure.
Doesn't have any bearing on the index accident.
bradjsmith88 said:
Perhaps I should have expanded further.
Many policy booklets will say to notify them as soon as possible of any incidents you are involved in.
And if this was a fault incident I agree to notify a.s.a.p. to allow the best possible defence to be prepared - however this seems straight forward non-fault.
As the OP's insurers have done they just take details and say thanks very much and goodbye! Next renewal they will include it on the invitation.
Conversely the OP could just call them at renewal and make a late disclosure.
Doesn't have any bearing on the index accident.
But what happens when the third party changes their mind about liability?Many policy booklets will say to notify them as soon as possible of any incidents you are involved in.
And if this was a fault incident I agree to notify a.s.a.p. to allow the best possible defence to be prepared - however this seems straight forward non-fault.
As the OP's insurers have done they just take details and say thanks very much and goodbye! Next renewal they will include it on the invitation.
Conversely the OP could just call them at renewal and make a late disclosure.
Doesn't have any bearing on the index accident.
This happened to me five years ago, in a clear cut non fault accident. They admitted liability at the scene and later on in writing.
They then decided that it wasn't their fault at all!
Tim
catman said:
But what happens when the third party changes their mind about liability?
This happened to me five years ago, in a clear cut non fault accident. They admitted liability at the scene and later on in writing.
They then decided that it wasn't their fault at all!
Tim
Then it would probably make fThis happened to me five years ago, in a clear cut non fault accident. They admitted liability at the scene and later on in writing.
They then decided that it wasn't their fault at all!
Tim
k all difference. catman said:
But his Insurers said that they were obligated to try to fight his case. It dragged on for ages before they admitted defeat.
Tim
Except they're not as it's a surrogates loss and an admission in writing would bugger their case and make it expensive and up winnable. Highly unlikely. Tim
LoonR1 said:
Except they're not as it's a surrogates loss and an admission in writing would bugger their case and make it expensive and up winnable. Highly unlikely.
I don't understand your "highly unlikely" comment. I stated what I was told by his Insurers. Are you saying that I made it up? For the record, he was driving a company van and his Employer had already made an offer to pay for the damage, as he had told them that it was just a scratch. (My car was written off)
I also had an independant witness. That's how one-sided it was. I really hope that you aren't implying that I'm lying.
Tim
It's entirely possible that you dealt with an utter muppet in a third party insurer, but if it was clear cut on liability, with no conflicting instructions as to what happened and an independent witness, they would have been stupid to fight their case.
Think of the knight in Monty Python insisting it's just a flesh wound, and you're in the right ballpark as to how obliged they really were to keep defending.
It's highly unlikely that any insurer would want to keep someone on who took that approach to an unwinnable case because they just quintupled (or more) their average cost of claims.
So while I wouldn't suggest that you're lying, it's highly unlikely either that the case was as one-sided as you thought, or alternatively that it is highly unlikely that any one person in that situation would encounter such incompetence on the other side.
Edit: if the driver told his employer that it was just a scratch, might he have told the insurer the same thing and then they were more than a little confused when you presented a smouldering heap instead of a smart repair for them to deal with? Might that have delayed an admission or caused them to investigate whether your claim was somehow fraudulent? If they were accepting the facts in full but disputing the outcome, it seems very odd as above.
Think of the knight in Monty Python insisting it's just a flesh wound, and you're in the right ballpark as to how obliged they really were to keep defending.
It's highly unlikely that any insurer would want to keep someone on who took that approach to an unwinnable case because they just quintupled (or more) their average cost of claims.
So while I wouldn't suggest that you're lying, it's highly unlikely either that the case was as one-sided as you thought, or alternatively that it is highly unlikely that any one person in that situation would encounter such incompetence on the other side.
Edit: if the driver told his employer that it was just a scratch, might he have told the insurer the same thing and then they were more than a little confused when you presented a smouldering heap instead of a smart repair for them to deal with? Might that have delayed an admission or caused them to investigate whether your claim was somehow fraudulent? If they were accepting the facts in full but disputing the outcome, it seems very odd as above.
No, it was well after they knew the extent of the damage. The damage wasn't huge, but it was a fairly old but low miles fsh Mondeo. It was never going to be a massive claim. If they had settled quickly, it would have cost them probably £1000-£2000 including car hire charges.
The Insurer was a very well known and far from "back street" company. The other driver was a complete wierdo!
He told me that he'd already hit a bus that day, and suggested that instead of claiming for the damage to my car, that he'd donate £200 to my nominated charity, so that some good would come out of the accident...
With reference to the costs involved changing their view on liability, I eventually received £600 for my car and they then received a bill of circa £6000 for a hire car, because they dragged it out for so long.
They never did provide me with a reason for arguing his case from any logical point, only that he had changed his mind. Make of this what you will, but I have relayed the facts exactly as they occured.
Tim
The Insurer was a very well known and far from "back street" company. The other driver was a complete wierdo!
He told me that he'd already hit a bus that day, and suggested that instead of claiming for the damage to my car, that he'd donate £200 to my nominated charity, so that some good would come out of the accident...
With reference to the costs involved changing their view on liability, I eventually received £600 for my car and they then received a bill of circa £6000 for a hire car, because they dragged it out for so long.
They never did provide me with a reason for arguing his case from any logical point, only that he had changed his mind. Make of this what you will, but I have relayed the facts exactly as they occured.
Tim
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


